Best Italian restaurants in Milwaukee [2024]

Welcome to our guide to the Best Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee! If you’re a food enthusiast searching for an authentic taste of Italy in the Cream City, look no further. We’ve scoured the culinary scene to bring you a curated list of the finest establishments that serve up delectable Italian cuisine. From traditional trattorias with mouthwatering pasta dishes to charming pizzerias crafting wood-fired delights, these Italian restaurants in Milwaukee are sure to satisfy your cravings. Join us as we embark on a flavorful journey through the city’s culinary gems.

Glorioso’s Italian Market

Address: 1011 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Phone: +1 (414) 272-0540
Website: gloriosos.com
Details: $$, Italian grocery store

Glorioso’s Italian Market in Milwaukee is a hidden gem that captures the essence of an authentic Italian deli. As soon as you step inside, you’ll be greeted by a wide array of mouthwatering options, including sandwiches, Italian cheese, salami, and even pizza. The store also offers an impressive selection of wines, making it a one-stop destination for all your Italian food cravings.

The atmosphere at Glorioso’s is nothing short of fantastic. With its historic charm and genuine character, the market exudes an old-world supermarket vibe that is hard to find elsewhere. The staff is attentive and helpful, patiently answering any questions you may have and providing personal recommendations. They make your visit a delightful experience, ensuring you feel welcomed and well taken care of.

When it comes to the menu, Glorioso’s truly shines. Their freshly made pasta and sauces are a highlight, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to quality and tradition. From the delectable Calzone and Italian Beef sandwich to the delightful Arancini, every bite is a culinary delight. Whether you choose to eat on-site in their cozy cafe or take your goodies home, you won’t be disappointed by the flavors and variety offered at Glorioso’s Italian Market.

Overall, Glorioso’s is a must-visit destination for any Italian food lover in Milwaukee. From the exceptional staff and inviting atmosphere to the delectable menu options, this market exceeds expectations. Whether you’re seeking specialty ingredients, a quick lunch, or simply want to indulge in some delicious Italian fare, Glorioso’s Italian Market is the perfect place to satisfy your cravings and experience the true taste of Italy.

Transfer Pizzeria Café

Address: 101 W Mitchell St, Milwaukee, WI 53204
Phone: +1 (414) 763-0438
Website: transfermke.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Transfer Pizzeria Café in Milwaukee is a beloved restaurant known for its fantastic atmosphere and exceptional staff. As soon as you step inside, you’ll be greeted by friendly servers who go above and beyond to make your dining experience enjoyable. Their attentive service and knowledge of the menu create a welcoming and comfortable environment for guests.

One of the highlights of Transfer Pizzeria Café is their mouthwatering pizza selection. With a variety of flavors to choose from, each pizza is crafted with care and bursting with deliciousness. Whether you opt for the dill pickle pizza with a garlic sauce base or the classic pepperoni mushroom, you’re in for a treat. The crust is perfect, and the combination of ingredients creates a flavor explosion that will leave you craving more.

In addition to their outstanding pizzas, Transfer Pizzeria Café also offers delectable appetizers like garlic bread and bruschetta, which are equally delightful. The menu is diverse, catering to different dietary preferences, such as vegan cheese options and gluten-free crusts. No matter your dietary needs, Transfer Pizzeria Café has something to satisfy your taste buds.

Overall, Transfer Pizzeria Café is a must-visit destination in Milwaukee. From the friendly and attentive staff to the inviting atmosphere, this restaurant offers a memorable dining experience. With their mouthwatering pizzas and a menu that caters to various preferences, it’s no wonder that Transfer Pizzeria Café is hailed as one of the best pizza places in town.

Onesto

Address: 221 N Broadway, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Phone: +1 (414) 308-1600
Website: onestomke.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Located in Milwaukee, Onesto is a delightful Italian restaurant that offers a memorable dining experience. As you approach the restaurant, the inviting aromas will captivate your senses and draw you in. The staff at Onesto is attentive and kind, ensuring that you feel welcomed and taken care of from the moment you step through the door.

The menu at Onesto is a culinary delight, featuring an array of mouthwatering pasta dishes and delectable desserts. The Cacio e pepe pasta is a standout, bursting with flavor and loved by many. The homemade bread is a highlight, hailed as the best bread in the area. Whether you indulge in the warm mushroom salad or savor the spaghetti bolognese, each dish is prepared with care and presented beautifully.

The atmosphere at Onesto is warm and inviting, with exposed cream city brick walls that add a touch of charm. The staff members are knowledgeable and friendly, ready to provide recommendations and ensure a relaxed dining experience. While the absence of bread with the meal may be a downside for some, the overall ambiance, quality of food, and excellent service make Onesto a gem worth visiting.

If you’re seeking an authentic Italian dining experience in Milwaukee, look no further than Onesto. With its friendly staff, charming atmosphere, and delectable menu offerings, this restaurant exceeds expectations. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply indulging in a Sunday meal, Onesto promises a memorable and satisfying culinary journey.

Santino’s Little Italy

Address: 352 E Stewart St, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Phone: +1 (414) 897-7367
Website: santinoslittleitaly.com
Details: $$, Restaurant

Santino’s Little Italy in Milwaukee is a hidden gem that offers an exceptional dining experience. From the moment you step inside, you’ll be greeted with warm hospitality and exceptional service. The staff at Santino’s go above and beyond to ensure that every guest feels welcomed and attended to, making your visit truly memorable.

The menu at Santino’s is a culinary delight, featuring some of the best pasta and pizza in town. Each dish is crafted with care and uses high-quality ingredients, resulting in flavorful and satisfying meals. Whether you indulge in the Carbonara with Nueske’s bacon or savor the delicious wood-fired pizzas, you won’t be disappointed. The extensive wine list complements the flavors perfectly, adding to the overall dining experience.

The atmosphere at Santino’s is inviting and cozy, making it the perfect place to relax and enjoy a meal. Whether you choose to dine inside or sit outside on a beautiful night, you’ll appreciate the well-maintained building and grounds. The friendly and helpful staff further enhance the dining experience, ensuring that you have everything you need for a memorable evening.

If you’re searching for the best Italian food in Milwaukee, look no further than Santino’s Little Italy. With its exceptional staff, inviting atmosphere, and delectable menu options, this restaurant is a go-to destination for food lovers. From the tasty pizzas to the mouthwatering pasta dishes, every bite at Santino’s is a culinary delight.

Balistreri’s Bluemound Inn

Address: 6501 W Bluemound Rd, Milwaukee, WI 53213
Phone: +1 (414) 348-5183
Website: balistreris.com
Details: $$, Restaurant

Balistreri’s Bluemound Inn in Milwaukee is a beloved Italian restaurant that offers a fantastic dining experience. The staff is attentive and polite, providing outstanding service that enhances the overall experience. Whether you choose to dine inside or enjoy the outdoor patio, the comfortable setting and welcoming atmosphere create a delightful ambiance.

The menu at Balistreri’s Bluemound Inn is a culinary delight, with a wide variety of options to choose from. The pizza, in particular, stands out as a must-try. It is reminiscent of the classic pizzas from years ago, satisfying both nostalgic cravings and discerning palates. The large pizzas are known for their generous portions, providing leftovers for another delicious meal. Additionally, the Italian appetizers and veal options add depth to the menu, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to quality and variety.

The holiday decorations at Balistreri’s Bluemound Inn add a touch of beauty and charm, making it a popular destination during the festive season. Whether you visit for lunch or dinner, the delicious dishes and impeccable service will leave you with nothing but positive memories. Balistreri’s Bluemound Inn is a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike, offering a friendly atmosphere and great food that consistently delivers an enjoyable dining experience.

Carini’s La Conca D’oro

Address: 3468 N Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53211
Phone: +1 (414) 963-9623
Website: atouchofsicily.com
Details: $$, Sicilian restaurant

Carini’s La Conca D’oro is a must-visit Italian restaurant in Milwaukee, offering an exceptional dining experience. From the moment you step inside, you’ll be immersed in the ambiance that will make you feel like an honorary Italian. The staff is attentive and friendly, ensuring that you receive top-notch service throughout your meal.

The menu at Carini’s La Conca D’oro is a treasure trove of delicious Italian dishes. The wood-fired pizza, made in their authentic oven imported from Italy, is a standout. From the perfectly crafted crust to the flavorful sauce and toppings, every bite is a delight. The homemade pasta dishes, such as the lasagna and Sicilian steak, showcase the culinary mastery of the kitchen. Whether you’re indulging in mussels and arancini for appetizers or enjoying a creamy seafood pasta dish, each dish is prepared with care and uses the freshest ingredients.

The atmosphere at Carini’s La Conca D’oro is warm and inviting, creating a cozy and welcoming environment. The decor adds to the overall charm, making it an ideal spot for a relaxed and enjoyable dining experience. The wine selection complements the flavors perfectly, offering a variety of options to enhance your meal. The attentive waitstaff adds to the positive experience, ensuring that your needs are met and that you have an unforgettable time at Carini’s La Conca D’oro.

When it comes to excellent Italian food and exceptional service, Carini’s La Conca D’oro is the go-to destination. With its cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, and a menu filled with mouthwatering dishes, this restaurant provides an authentic taste of Italy. Whether you’re craving a Neapolitan pizza, homemade pasta, or traditional Italian desserts like cannoli, Carini’s La Conca D’oro offers a culinary experience that will leave you wanting more.

Sala

Address: 2613 E Hampshire St, Milwaukee, WI 53211
Phone: +1 (414) 964-2611
Website: saladining.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Sala is a remarkable Italian restaurant in Milwaukee that offers an exceptional dining experience. From the moment you step inside, the welcoming ambience sets the stage for a memorable evening. The staff is attentive and friendly, providing top-notch service that enhances the overall experience.

The menu at Sala is a culinary delight, featuring a range of delectable Italian dishes. From the bruschetta and caprese appetizers to the flavorful pasta sauces made with fresh, homegrown tomatoes, every bite is a treat for the taste buds. The generous portions ensure that you leave satisfied, and the presentation of each dish is impressive. Whether you choose the lemon chicken, gnocchi special, or shrimp scampi, the fresh ingredients and attention to detail shine through.

The atmosphere at Sala is warm and inviting, creating a cozy and relaxed setting. The restaurant’s location near the university adds a vibrant energy, while the surrounding area of large, older homes provides a quiet and peaceful backdrop. The stylish bistro setting is adorned with modern artwork, adding a touch of sophistication to the dining experience. Additionally, Sala boasts a distinguished wine list, allowing guests to pair their meals with the perfect selection.

Sala is a hidden gem in Milwaukee, offering a casual yet stylish spot to enjoy authentic Italian cuisine. Whether you’re indulging in the eggplant appetizer, four cheese ravioli, or the diva mare, each dish showcases the restaurant’s commitment to quality and flavor. With friendly staff, an inviting atmosphere, and a menu that satisfies every craving, Sala is a must-visit destination for Italian food enthusiasts.

Dorsia

Address: 1307 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Phone: +1 (414) 539-6826
Website: dorsiamke.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Dorsia is a vibrant and lively Italian restaurant in Milwaukee that offers a delightful dining experience. The staff is welcoming and attentive, ensuring that every guest feels well taken care of. Despite the restaurant’s popularity, they strive to accommodate diners promptly, even without reservations, making the overall experience enjoyable from the start.

One of the highlights of Dorsia’s menu is their pasta flights, which allow guests to sample a variety of delicious pasta dishes. This unique offering sets Dorsia apart and is a must-try for pasta lovers. The creative and flavorful combinations, such as lobster mac & cheese, duck confit carbonara, and caprese linguini, are a true delight for the taste buds. Alongside the pasta flights, Dorsia also offers a range of other delectable dishes, including meatball Panini, prosciutto and fig pizza, and a cheese board, all prepared with attention to quality and flavor.

The atmosphere at Dorsia is vibrant and inviting, with a lively bar area and stylish decor that includes pop art featuring icons like Jeff Goldblum. Whether you choose to sit at the bar or opt for a table by the front window, you’ll enjoy a great view and an enjoyable ambiance. The restaurant is often bustling, creating a vibrant energy that adds to the overall dining experience.

Dorsia is a fantastic choice for anyone looking to enjoy delicious Italian cuisine in a lively and welcoming setting. With its exceptional pasta flights, excellent service, and reasonable prices, Dorsia offers a dining experience that is both satisfying and memorable. Whether you’re visiting Milwaukee or a local resident, Dorsia is a must-visit destination for a wonderful Italian meal.

Sorella

Address: 2535 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Phone: +1 (414) 301-6255
Website: sorellamke.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Sorella is an Italian restaurant in Milwaukee that captures the essence of authentic Italian cuisine. With its emphasis on fresh, seasonal ingredients and a carefully curated menu, Sorella delivers a fantastic dining experience. The option to dine outside adds a European touch to the atmosphere, creating a charming and enjoyable ambiance.

The staff at Sorella goes above and beyond to ensure that guests have a remarkable experience. From the warm and welcoming service to the attentive and knowledgeable waitstaff, the team at Sorella knows how to make diners feel special. The commitment to exceptional service extends throughout the restaurant, creating a well-run establishment that values teamwork and customer satisfaction.

The menu at Sorella offers a wide range of impressive dishes. From flavorful salads and appetizers to mouthwatering pizzas, each item is carefully prepared and delivers outstanding taste. The Nutella Calzone stands out as a delectable dessert option that leaves a lasting impression. Whether you’re enjoying a wood-fired mushroom pizza or indulging in their well-made pasta with the family recipe “Monday sauce,” Sorella consistently delivers delicious and satisfying meals.

For those seeking an Italian dining experience that exceeds expectations, Sorella is a highly recommended choice. With its excellent food, wonderful service, and beautiful restaurant setting, it provides a memorable dining experience for guests. Whether you’re a connoisseur of Italian cuisine or simply looking for a delightful meal, Sorella delivers on all fronts and leaves a lasting impression of quality and authenticity.

The White House Bay View

Address: 2900 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Phone: +1 (414) 897-0495
Website: whitehousebayview.com
Details: Fine dining restaurant

The White House Bay View is a fantastic Italian restaurant in Milwaukee that offers a delightful dining experience. From the moment you step inside, you are greeted with top-notch service and a warm atmosphere. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure that guests have a memorable and enjoyable time.

The menu at The White House Bay View is filled with mouthwatering dishes that are sure to please any palate. From the escargot and asparagus soup to the scallops and lamb, each item is prepared with precision and delivers outstanding flavor. The SNAP PEAS, in particular, stand out as a standout dish. The attention to detail and the high-quality ingredients truly shine through in every bite.

The White House Bay View is not only known for its exceptional food but also for its charming ambiance. Whether you choose to dine in the outdoor garden or inside the historic tavern, you are treated to a cozy and inviting setting. The owners, Allison Meinhart and Zach Byrne, have done a remarkable job in bringing new flair to the Bay View neighborhood.

For those seeking a fine dining option outside of downtown Milwaukee, The White House Bay View is a hidden gem worth exploring. With its excellent wine list, delectable menu options, and attentive staff, it provides a delightful culinary experience. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for a memorable meal, The White House Bay View delivers on all fronts and leaves guests satisfied and impressed.

In conclusion, Milwaukee boasts a vibrant culinary scene with a variety of exceptional Italian restaurants to choose from. Whether you’re craving traditional pasta dishes, wood-fired pizzas, or delectable seafood, the city offers a range of options to satisfy your Italian food cravings. From the authentic flavors of Onesto to the charming atmosphere of Sorella, these restaurants stand out for their top-notch staff, inviting atmospheres, and mouthwatering menus. Whether you’re a local resident or visiting the city, exploring the best Italian restaurants in Milwaukee is sure to be a delightful gastronomic adventure.