Best Pizza restaurants in Columbus [2024]

Welcome to our mouthwatering exploration of the Best Pizza restaurants in Columbus! If you’re a pizza aficionado, or simply someone seeking a delightful culinary experience, you’ve come to the right place. Columbus, renowned for its vibrant food scene, boasts an array of establishments that excel in crafting delectable pizzas. From classic Neapolitan-style pies to innovative and creative flavors, we’ve scoured the city to present you with the ultimate guide to satisfy your pizza cravings. Get ready to embark on a cheesy adventure through the Best Pizza restaurants in Columbus!

Forno Short North

Address: 721 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone: +1 (614) 469-0053
Website: fornoshortnorth.com
Details: $$, New American restaurant

Nestled in the heart of Columbus, Forno Short North is a must-visit pizza restaurant renowned for its inviting atmosphere, attentive staff, and delectable menu. The vibrant ambiance sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. Whether you’re seated indoors or at the bar, you’ll be greeted by a lively vibe that adds to the enjoyment of your meal.

The staff at Forno Short North stands out with their exceptional service. From the moment you step in, you’ll be met with friendly and knowledgeable servers who go the extra mile to ensure your satisfaction. Their attentiveness and willingness to provide menu suggestions create a personalized touch that elevates the dining experience.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show—the pizza! Forno Short North takes pride in crafting exceptional pies with a crispy, airy dough and just the right amount of bready crust. The flavors are divine, and whether you opt for a classic pepperoni or venture into unique combinations, you’re in for a treat. Pair your pizza with their extensive selection of beers and wines for a perfect culinary journey.

While Forno Short North is known for its pizza, their menu offers more than just cheesy goodness. From the delightful appetizers like calamari and arancini to mouthwatering entrees like petite filet and salmon, there’s something to please every palate. The portions are reasonable, striking a balance between hearty and satisfying.

With its prime location near major sites and close proximity to Ohio State University, Forno Short North is an ideal stop for locals and visitors alike. Make sure to plan ahead and secure a reservation to avoid missing out on this culinary gem. So, if you’re craving a memorable dining experience with great food and a lively atmosphere, Forno Short North should be at the top of your list.

Figlio

Address: 1369 Grandview Ave, Columbus, OH 43212
Phone: +1 (614) 481-8850
Website: figliopizza.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Nestled in a cozy and inviting atmosphere, Figlio is a charming pizza restaurant in Columbus that promises a delightful dining experience. From the moment you step into the small yet warm dining area, you’ll be greeted with a welcoming ambiance. With ample tables and the option for reservations, finding a spot to enjoy their mouthwatering pizza is a breeze.

The highlight of Figlio is undoubtedly their delectable pizza. The wood-fired oven adds a distinct flavor to the crispy thin crust, making each bite a delight. The menu also offers an array of pastas and appetizers, showcasing the versatility of their culinary creations. Whether you opt for the truffled mushroom pizza or the pear and Brie pizza, each dish is carefully crafted and bursting with flavor.

The staff at Figlio goes above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. From the attentive and friendly servers to the knowledgeable recommendations, the exceptional service adds to the overall charm of the restaurant. The menu features a well-curated selection of wines and beers, perfectly complementing the delicious fare.

Figlio is not just a place for pizza lovers; it’s a cozy and inviting establishment that invites friends and families to gather and create lasting memories. The combination of great food, attentive staff, and a warm atmosphere make it the perfect spot for both casual outings and special occasions. So, make sure to reserve a table and indulge in the flavorsome offerings of Figlio – an experience you won’t want to miss.

Mikey’s Late Night Slice

Address: 1030 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201
Phone: +1 (614) 737-3488
Website: latenightslice.com
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

Mikey’s Late Night Slice is a popular pizza destination in Columbus that offers a fantastic dining experience. The staff is efficient and quick, ensuring that your order is promptly taken and delivered with a smile. The pizza itself is a standout, with hot and flavorful slices that are generously sized. Whether you choose to dine in or take it to go, the taste is magnificent and the quality is consistently impressive. The menu offers a variety of options, making it easy to find something to satisfy your pizza cravings.

The atmosphere at Mikey’s Late Night Slice is lively and welcoming, creating a fun and enjoyable environment. It’s a popular spot downtown, so be prepared for long lines. However, the wait is absolutely worth it. Additionally, the secret speakeasy bar downstairs adds an unexpected twist to your visit, providing a cool and unique experience. The younger vibe and good energy contribute to the overall enjoyment of the place.

One of the standout features of Mikey’s Late Night Slice is its dedication to delivering excellent pizza. The combination of fresh ingredients, crispy crusts, and flavorful toppings results in sheer perfection. The pizza slices are among the best you’ll find anywhere, making it a go-to spot for pizza lovers. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite with friends or a late-night snack, Mikey’s Late Night Slice is the ideal choice.

Oh Pizza And Brew

Address: 88 E Broad St, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone: +1 (614) 940-8687
Website: ohpizzabrew.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Oh Pizza And Brew, located in Columbus, is a hidden gem offering delicious pizza and excellent service. Despite its unassuming exterior, the interior is small yet welcoming, accommodating a nice crowd. The staff is friendly, providing prompt and attentive service. The pizza itself is outstanding, with a thin and crispy crust that is bursting with flavor. The unique combinations of toppings, such as pepperoni, banana peppers, and green olives, create a mouthwatering experience. Even the crust is a standout, with a delightful garlic flavor that makes it impossible to resist. The menu also offers delectable appetizers like loaded potato skins, infused Buffalo tots, and awesome sauce wings, all of which leave a lasting impression. Additionally, the pizza place offers a variety of craft beers, complementing the tasty fare.

The atmosphere at Oh Pizza And Brew is vibrant, bustling with activity and lively conversations. The dining area may be small, but it adds to the cozy and intimate vibe. While it can get loud, it only adds to the overall ambiance. Whether you choose to dine in or opt for takeout, the quality of the food and the friendly service remain consistent. The location is convenient, making it an excellent choice for a quick and satisfying meal. The attention to detail in both the food and service ensures a memorable dining experience.

Overall, Oh Pizza And Brew exceeds expectations with its outstanding pizza and warm atmosphere. The combination of flavorful toppings, crisp crust, and friendly service make it a must-visit spot in Columbus. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, this pizza place will surely leave you craving more. So, step inside, indulge in their delectable pizza creations, and enjoy the lively atmosphere that Oh Pizza And Brew has to offer.

Hounddog’s Three Degree Pizza

Address: 2657 N High St, Columbus, OH 43202
Phone: +1 (614) 261-4686
Website: hounddogspizza.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Hounddog’s Three Degree Pizza in Columbus is an excellent place to enjoy delicious pizza in a relaxed and friendly atmosphere. The staff is known for their friendly service, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The menu offers a variety of mouthwatering pizza options, such as the medium pep and cheese with the spicy sauce and the smoking joes crust, which are both highly recommended. The pizza itself is incredible, with a perfect blend of flavors and high-quality ingredients. Accompanying dishes like side salads and deep-fried wild mushrooms are also excellent choices.

The atmosphere at Hounddog’s is vibrant and welcoming, with wooden tables, great lighting, and a rock music backdrop that sets the mood. Despite its unassuming exterior, the place exudes a warm and inviting ambiance. The prices are reasonable, making it a great option for a quick dinner or a casual meal. The service is efficient and courteous, ensuring that guests are well taken care of. Additionally, Hounddog’s offers a selection of craft beers to complement the delicious pizza.

Whether you’re a local or a visitor to Columbus, Hounddog’s Three Degree Pizza is a must-visit destination for pizza lovers. The outstanding pizza, friendly staff, and inviting atmosphere make it a favorite among both residents and tourists. With its delicious offerings, affordable prices, and relaxed environment, Hounddog’s is sure to leave a lasting impression on pizza enthusiasts. So, stop by and savor the flavors of their delectable pizzas for a truly satisfying dining experience.

Mellow Mushroom Columbus

Address: 2170 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus, OH 43240
Phone: +1 (614) 885-6355
Website: mellowmushroom.com/location/oh-columbus-2170-polaris-pkwy-43240
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Mellow Mushroom Columbus is an amazing pizza restaurant that offers a wide variety of delicious pizzas and refreshing drinks. The pizza is outstanding, with options like the House Pizza loaded with meats and veggies, and the white pizza with added pepperoni, both receiving high praise from customers. The toppings are fresh and plentiful, and the crusts come in different styles to suit everyone’s preferences. The menu also includes appetizers like pretzel bites and calzones, as well as tasty salads. The staff at Mellow Mushroom is known for their friendly and attentive service, ensuring a pleasant dining experience for all guests.

The atmosphere of the restaurant is fun and inviting, with quirky decor and a vibrant vibe. The establishment features unique artwork that adds to the overall charm, making it a great place for friends and families to gather and enjoy a meal together. The restaurant is spacious, allowing for comfortable seating even during busy times. The relaxed ambiance, combined with the fantastic food and service, creates a memorable dining experience.

Customers have praised the accommodating nature of Mellow Mushroom, noting that the restaurant is able to cater to different groups, whether it’s parents and teens or coworkers. The prices are reasonable, making it an affordable option for lunch or dinner. The overall consensus is that Mellow Mushroom offers great food, great service, and a great atmosphere. So, if you’re in Columbus and looking for a unique pizza experience, Mellow Mushroom is definitely worth a visit.

Giordano’s

Address: 2137 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus, OH 43240
Phone: +1 (614) 852-4330
Website: giordanos.com/locations/columbus
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Giordano’s in Columbus offers an exceptional dining experience with its renowned deep-dish pizza and welcoming atmosphere. Visitors who have previously enjoyed Giordano’s in Chicago are thrilled to find the same quality and taste in Columbus. The pizza itself is a highlight, with its mouthwatering crust, flavorful sauce, and generous toppings. Whether opting for a personal-size deep-dish pizza or sharing a larger one, guests are delighted by the delicious flavors and well-balanced ingredients. The menu also features appetizers like garlic fries and Caesar salad, which perfectly complement the pizza offerings.

The staff at Giordano’s receives high praise for their attentiveness and friendly service. From attentive servers to helpful bartenders, the team ensures that every guest feels well taken care of. The restaurant is accommodating for both dine-in and takeout options, providing disposable plates, cutlery, and condiments for a convenient experience. The clean facilities and comfortable seating further enhance the overall enjoyment of the visit. Giordano’s is an excellent choice for families, friends, and pizza enthusiasts alike, offering an authentic taste of Chicago right in Columbus.

Guests appreciate the reasonable prices and value they receive at Giordano’s. Despite the popularity and high demand, the staff manages to provide efficient service, even during peak hours. Whether enjoying a leisurely lunch or dining at the bar, visitors are consistently pleased with the quality of the food, the refreshing beverages, and the overall dining experience. With its expansion outside of Chicago, Giordano’s has established itself as a must-visit pizza destination, and the Columbus location lives up to its reputation as a go-to spot for exceptional deep-dish pizza.

Plank’s Cafe & Pizzeria Delivery On Parsons

Address: 743 Parsons Ave, Columbus, OH 43206
Phone: +1 (614) 445-7221
Website: plankscafe.com
Details: Pizza restaurant

Plank’s Cafe & Pizzeria Delivery On Parsons is a beloved pizza destination in Columbus, known for its delicious offerings and friendly atmosphere. The menu features a variety of pizzas with a signature crust that has a touch of sweetness, making it unique and enjoyable. Customers rave about the crispy crust, flavorful toppings, and standout pepperoni. Alongside pizza, Plank’s offers other tasty dishes, such as subs, homemade roast beef over mashed potatoes, and chicken and noodles.

The waitstaff at Plank’s is attentive, friendly, and goes above and beyond to provide excellent service. The restaurant exudes a welcoming and cheerful ambiance, making it an ideal spot for families and friends to gather. The establishment is adorned with Buckeye-themed decorations, reflecting the local pride and creating a true Columbus experience. Plank’s is renowned as a family-owned establishment that prioritizes tradition and hospitality.

Customers appreciate the consistency of the food at Plank’s, whether dining in or ordering delivery. The pizzas are consistently fresh, hot, and prepared with high-quality ingredients. The value for the price is excellent, making Plank’s a go-to option for both locals and visitors. The restaurant’s long-standing presence in Columbus has earned it a reputation as a hidden gem, providing a memorable dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more.

Sarefino’s At North Market

Address: 59 Spruce St, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone: +1 (614) 228-7300
Website: pastarianorthmarket.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Sarefino’s At North Market is a go-to destination for delicious and affordable pizza in Columbus. Whether you’re in a hurry and craving a quick slice or looking to indulge in a whole pizza, Sarefino’s delivers on taste and value. The crust is perfect, the sauce is amazing, and the portions are generous, making every bite a delight. The New York-style thin crust pizza is a crowd favorite, with toppings like cheese, pepperoni, and mushrooms adding to the flavor.

The staff at Sarefino’s are quirky, helpful, and create a friendly and happy atmosphere. The service is top-notch, making the dining experience even more enjoyable. In addition to pizza, Sarefino’s offers other mouthwatering options, such as calzones and pasta dishes. The pasta with basil and tomato sauce is particularly outstanding, rivaling the taste of any other pasta dish. The prices at Sarefino’s are very reasonable, ensuring that you can satisfy your cravings without breaking the bank.

Located in the vibrant North Market, Sarefino’s provides a convenient and enjoyable dining experience. Whether you’re visiting during a cheerleading competition or exploring the market, Sarefino’s is a must-visit for its quality food and great value. From the flavorful pizza to the friendly staff, Sarefino’s is a delightful spot for lunch or a quick bite. Make sure to stop by and savor the tasty dishes that Sarefino’s has to offer.

In conclusion, Columbus boasts a vibrant pizza scene with a variety of outstanding restaurants that cater to every pizza lover’s taste. From the deep-dish wonders at Mellow Mushroom Columbus to the authentic Chicago-style pies at Giordano’s, there’s something for everyone. Plank’s Cafe & Pizzeria Delivery On Parsons offers fast, delicious slices, while Sarefino’s At North Market serves up affordable and delectable New York-style thin crust pizza. Whether you’re a fan of traditional toppings or adventurous flavor combinations, these pizza joints in Columbus have you covered. So, next time you’re in town, be sure to explore these best pizza restaurants and savor the cheesy, saucy goodness they have to offer.