Best Pizza restaurants in Jacksonville [2024]

Welcome to the ultimate guide to the Best Pizza restaurants in Jacksonville! If you’re a pizza lover seeking a slice of culinary heaven, look no further. In this article, we’ll unveil the top pizzerias in Jacksonville that are guaranteed to satisfy your cravings. From traditional Neapolitan pies to creative gourmet combinations, these eateries offer a delightful range of flavors and textures. Join us as we explore the vibrant pizza scene in Jacksonville, where every bite is a symphony of taste and satisfaction.

Moon River Pizza

Address: 1176 Edgewood Ave S, Jacksonville, FL 32205
Phone: +1 (904) 389-4442
Website: moonriverpizza.net
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

Nestled in Jacksonville is the remarkable Moon River Pizza, a culinary gem that promises an unforgettable dining experience. From the moment you step foot into this cozy establishment, the friendly staff goes above and beyond to ensure your visit is nothing short of exceptional. Their attentive service and genuine warmth create a welcoming atmosphere that instantly puts you at ease.

Prepare your taste buds for a journey of flavors as you peruse the menu at Moon River Pizza. The diverse selection caters to every palate, offering an array of mouthwatering options. Indulge in the sublime pizza creations, such as the marinated tempeh and vegan cheese-topped delight, leaving a lasting impression on even the most discerning taste buds. Each bite is a symphony of flavors that will leave you longing for an encore meal, perhaps paired with a fine red wine.

Beyond the delectable cuisine, Moon River Pizza exudes a vibrant neighborhood vibe that adds to its charm. The energetic atmosphere, accompanied by classic Rolling Stones tunes, creates a delightful backdrop for your dining experience. Whether you’re savoring a slice of their delectable pepperoni pizza or enjoying a refreshing Greek salad with olives, the attentive and friendly wait staff ensures that your needs are met with care.

For pizza enthusiasts and salad aficionados alike, Moon River Pizza is a must-visit destination in Jacksonville. The generous portions of pizza, smothered in cheese and packed with flavor, will leave you craving more. The T Rex, a meat lover’s dream, boasts a tantalizing combination of meats and cheese that delights the senses. With exceptional service and an inviting family-oriented atmosphere, Moon River Pizza stands as a beacon of culinary excellence, beckoning you to experience the best pizza Jacksonville has to offer.

V Pizza & Sidecar – San Marco

Address: 1406 Hendricks Ave, Jacksonville, FL 32207
Phone: +1 (904) 527-1511
Website: vpizza.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Nestled in the heart of Jacksonville, V Pizza & Sidecar – San Marco is a culinary treasure that will leave you craving more. As you step into this inviting establishment, you’ll be greeted by a warm and friendly staff who go above and beyond to ensure your dining experience is exceptional. The atmosphere exudes a vibrant and family-friendly vibe, making it the perfect place to savor a delicious meal.

Prepare to indulge in the finest pizza creations that will tantalize your taste buds. From the well-done crust to the top-notch ingredients, each pizza at V Pizza is a work of art. The Calabrian Peppers and signature wings are absolute must-tries, bursting with incredible flavors that will leave you in awe. With imported ingredients from Italy and a commitment to using the best-quality ingredients, V Pizza sets the bar high for pizza lovers.

Don’t miss out on the other delightful offerings on the menu. From the mouthwatering Bolognese Pasta to the Italian Roast Beef, every dish at V Pizza is prepared with care and attention to detail. The dedication to supporting cancer families through their charitable contributions adds an extra touch of heartwarming goodness to your dining experience. And for those looking to quench their thirst, the attached SideCar bar boasts talented mixologists who create incredible concoctions.

Whether you’re a local or just passing through Jacksonville, V Pizza & Sidecar – San Marco is a pizza lover’s paradise. The combination of exceptional service, phenomenal flavors, and a welcoming atmosphere ensures that each visit is a memorable one. Step into this culinary haven and let V Pizza spoil you with their unparalleled pizza expertise.

Tony D’s New York Pizza

Address: 8358 Point Meadows Dr #10, Jacksonville, FL 32256
Phone: +1 (904) 322-7051
Website: tdnypizza.com
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

Experience the true taste of New York right here in Jacksonville at Tony D’s New York Pizza. This hidden gem has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike, offering authentic NY-style pizza that will transport your taste buds to the bustling streets of the Big Apple. As you step inside, you’ll be greeted by a warm and friendly staff, creating a welcoming and relaxed atmosphere that is perfect for enjoying a delicious meal.

Prepare to indulge in the best of New York flavors with each bite of Tony D’s pizza. The hand-tossed crust is perfectly balanced, complemented by a delectable sauce that doesn’t overpower the toppings. The cheese, with its subtle salty and nutty flavor, adds a delightful touch to every slice. Whether you opt for the classic NY Special or explore their other menu offerings like chicken parm or Greek salad, each dish is prepared with care and attention to detail.

Not only does Tony D’s excel in its culinary offerings, but the restaurant itself is a testament to its New York roots. Adorned with fascinating pictures and memorabilia that pay homage to the city’s rich history and the world of the mafia, the ambiance adds an extra layer of charm to your dining experience. The friendly wait staff ensures that you feel right at home, providing excellent service and making your visit truly enjoyable.

For the best NY-style pizza in Jacksonville, look no further than Tony D’s New York Pizza. From the mouthwatering pizzas to the delectable subs and pasta dishes, this restaurant has it all. With its friendly atmosphere, attentive staff, and unbeatable flavors, Tony D’s is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts and anyone seeking an authentic taste of New York in the heart of Jacksonville.

Mellow Mushroom Jacksonville – River City

Address: 15170 Max Leggett Pkwy, Jacksonville, FL 32218
Phone: +1 (904) 757-8843
Website: mellowmushroom.com/location/fl-jacksonville-15170-max-leggett-pkwy-32218
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Indulge in the perfect pizza experience at Mellow Mushroom Jacksonville – River City. This beloved pizza joint never fails to impress with its delectable offerings. Even on a busy Sunday, finding a table was a breeze, and the friendly staff made sure we felt welcome from the moment we walked in. Don’t miss out on the bruschetta—it’s absolutely fantastic! The service was exceptional, and the team went above and beyond to ensure our dining experience was top-notch. We left with smiles on our faces, grateful for a memorable night out. We can’t wait to return.

If you’re looking for a fun and enjoyable dining experience, Mellow Mushroom is the place to be. We discovered this gem based on a recommendation and it exceeded our expectations. The service was exceptional, the atmosphere was lively, and the food was outstanding. We savored the pretzel bites and indulged in a delicious Hawaiian pizza. The extensive beer selection was the cherry on top. As we embarked on our road trip, Mellow Mushroom provided the perfect pitstop, and we’re eager to try it again when we’re back in our hometown. This restaurant comes highly recommended!

Prepare for an outstanding culinary adventure at Mellow Mushroom Jacksonville – River City. The pizzas are truly a treat, boasting a perfect combination of real cheese and delectable toppings. The mushroom trio pizza is a standout. The chef salad is fresh and generously portioned, leaving enough for leftovers. The attention to detail extends to the homemade blue cheese dressing. The service is exceptional, with servers like Ashley P and Teagan providing friendly and efficient service. The attentive manager adds to the warm and welcoming atmosphere. We can’t stress enough how much we recommend this restaurant for a fantastic dining experience.

Mod Pizza

Address: 12547 Bartram Park Blvd Suite 201, Jacksonville, FL 32258
Phone: +1 (904) 666-5190
Website: locations.modpizza.com/usa/fl/jacksonville/12547-bartram-park-blvd
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

Embark on a delightful culinary adventure at MOD Pizza in Jacksonville. This eatery offers a unique experience where you can create your own pizza masterpiece, choosing from a wide variety of toppings, cheeses, meats, and veggies. The crew is exceptional, providing friendly and attentive service that enhances your dining experience. With the option to personalize your pizza to your heart’s content, including all the extra artichokes you desire, this is a place you’ll want to visit again and again.

Upon entering MOD Pizza, the friendly staff immediately make you feel at home. They go above and beyond to assist newcomers like myself, explaining the menu and the ordering process. What sets this place apart is that they sell their pizza by size rather than toppings, allowing you to add as many toppings as you like without any additional charges. The pizzas are made with a thin, oven-baked crust that caters to those who prefer a lighter dough. They also offer a selection of sauces, such as the surprisingly delicious Balsamic sauce, which pairs perfectly with the pizza. With its reasonable prices and delectable offerings, MOD Pizza is a must-visit destination in Jacksonville.

MOD Pizza stands out with its innovative concept of personalized pizzas. For a fixed price, you have the freedom to select any toppings you desire, ensuring a truly customized dining experience. The quality and freshness of the ingredients are evident in each bite, making the pizza a mouthwatering delight. The service is consistently friendly and fast, whether you choose to dine in or take out. MOD Pizza has quickly become a go-to spot for families, as even the kids can enjoy their own pies. With its affordable prices and delicious offerings, it’s no wonder that this place has already gained a loyal following. Don’t settle for ordinary pizza when MOD Pizza offers a unique and satisfying experience that will keep you coming back for more.

Ej’s Pizza

Address: 9119 Merrill Rd # 17, Jacksonville, FL 32225
Phone: +1 (904) 743-7918
Website: facebook.com/EJsItalian
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Immerse yourself in a delightful pizza experience at EJ’s Pizza in Jacksonville. This charming spot offers a veggie pizza that is hailed as the best, even by New Yorkers who know their pizza. Whether it’s your cheat day or a special occasion, EJ’s Pizza is the go-to destination. The atmosphere is welcoming and the staff goes above and beyond to ensure your satisfaction. The menu boasts a large thin crust New York pizza, complemented by delectable house side salads and irresistible cheese garlic bread. Each bite is a burst of flavor that will leave you craving more.

Consistency is key at EJ’s Pizza, as every meal is an absolute delight. From their mouthwatering pizzas to the flavorful antipasto, the quality of their offerings never disappoints. The friendly staff adds a personal touch to your dining experience, and the owner may even pay a visit to ensure everything is perfect. With every visit, you’ll savor delicious meals that capture the essence of authentic Italian cuisine. The generous portions guarantee leftovers, making it a satisfying and memorable dining experience. EJ’s Pizza is a hidden gem that deserves the highest recommendation.

Prepare to be impressed by EJ’s Pizza, a restaurant highly praised by friends and now confirmed to be an excellent choice. The veggie pizza, customized to your preferences, is an absolute winner. The crust, a vital component of any pizza, is simply outstanding. Accompanied by a great selection of beers, EJ’s Pizza is a place you’ll be eager to return to whenever you’re in the neighborhood. Don’t let the outdated decor deter you; behind the modest exterior lies a haven of delicious pies, attentive service, reasonable prices, and a true sense of community. Discover the flavors and charm of EJ’s Pizza for yourself.

Ale Pie House

Address: 3951 St Johns Ave, Jacksonville, FL 32205
Phone: +1 (904) 503-8000
Website: AlePieHouseFL.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Experience culinary excellence at Ale Pie House, a hidden gem in Jacksonville that offers an unforgettable dining experience. Despite its modest ambiance, the food here is absolutely phenomenal. Known for serving the best pizza in town, Ale Pie House is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts and Italian food lovers alike. Indulge in their mouthwatering sketti with hot sausage or explore their extensive menu featuring a variety of pizzas, calzones, and pasta dishes. The buns served with the sketti and other pasta creations are a true delight, rivaling any other establishment. In addition, the restaurant takes pride in offering excellent butter, comparable to the renowned Kerry Gold brand.

Visiting Ale Pie House is an adventure in itself. Located slightly off the beaten path, this local hangout is worth the journey. The menu boasts a wide selection, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Try their signature 16″ Meat Veggie Fruit pie loaded with a plethora of delectable toppings. The crust is perfectly crafted, and every bite is bursting with irresistible flavors. Even non-pizza lovers will be converted after savoring the delights Ale Pie House has to offer. Parking may be limited, but the warm atmosphere and attentive wait staff make up for any inconvenience.

For those with dietary restrictions, Ale Pie House caters to various preferences. Their gluten-free crust is a standout, receiving high praise as the best in town. The gluten-free options, combined with the availability of cow-dairy free cheese, make this restaurant a top choice for those seeking a delightful and accommodating dining experience. From build-your-own pizzas with unique cheese selections to mouthwatering dishes like chicken pesto and specialty meat and fruit pizza, every item on the menu exceeds expectations. The portions are generous, and the prices are reasonable, ensuring satisfaction for every guest.

In conclusion, Jacksonville is home to a vibrant pizza scene that caters to diverse palates and preferences. Whether you’re craving classic New York-style slices, indulgent deep-dish creations, or innovative gourmet combinations, the city has something to offer for every pizza lover. From cozy local joints with a nostalgic ambiance to modern pizzerias pushing culinary boundaries, the best pizza restaurants in Jacksonville deliver on taste, quality, and experience. So, the next time you find yourself in the River City, be sure to explore these pizza havens and embark on a delightful culinary journey that will leave you craving for more.