Best Pizza restaurants in Pittsburgh [2024]

Welcome to the ultimate guide to the Best Pizza restaurants in Pittsburgh! If you’re a pizza lover in the Steel City, you’re in for a treat. In this article, we’ll take you on a mouthwatering journey through the culinary scene of Pittsburgh, uncovering the most delectable and satisfying slices the city has to offer. From traditional Neapolitan pies to innovative creations, we’ve scoured the streets to bring you a handpicked selection of the Best Pizza restaurants in Pittsburgh. Get ready to indulge your taste buds and discover your new favorite pizza spot in the city!

Proper Brick Oven And Tap Room

Address: 139 7th St, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Phone: +1 (412) 281-5700
Website: properpittsburgh.com
Details: $$, Restaurant

Nestled in the heart of Pittsburgh, Proper Brick Oven And Tap Room is a pizza lover’s paradise. With hot and fresh pizzas bursting with delightful flavors, this restaurant promises a memorable dining experience. The menu offers a variety of options, including the Chameleon Pizza and Pesto Pizza, both crafted with a doughy texture and a crisp bottom bite that will leave your taste buds craving more. The expertly blended toppings take center stage, making each bite a true delight.

The inviting atmosphere of Proper Brick Oven And Tap Room adds to the overall experience. From the moment you step inside, you’ll be greeted by a warm and pleasant ambiance. The decor and lighting create a cozy and comfortable setting, perfect for enjoying a meal with friends or loved ones. The attentive and friendly staff ensures that your dining needs are met, further enhancing your visit.

Aside from the remarkable pizzas, Proper Brick Oven And Tap Room offers a delectable selection of salads and appetizers. Whether you choose the crispy Brussels Sprouts or the refreshing Pear Sliced Salad, each dish is crafted with care and precision. The menu also features a well-curated beer selection, allowing you to pair your pizza with a perfectly complementing brew.

Proper Brick Oven And Tap Room has earned a reputation as one of the best pizza restaurants in Pittsburgh, and for good reason. From the impeccable service to the mouthwatering food, this establishment is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts and food lovers alike. So, if you’re searching for an exceptional pizza experience with a cozy atmosphere and attentive staff, look no further than Proper Brick Oven And Tap Room. Your taste buds will thank you.

Pizzaiolo Primo

Address: 8 Market Square, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Phone: +1 (412) 575-5858
Website: pizzaioloprimo.com
Details: $$$, Italian restaurant

Nestled in the vibrant Market Square of downtown Pittsburgh, Pizzaiolo Primo is a true gem for Italian cuisine enthusiasts. From the moment you step inside, you’ll be greeted by a cozy and inviting atmosphere that sets the stage for a remarkable dining experience. The attentive and friendly staff ensures that your visit is nothing short of exceptional.

The menu at Pizzaiolo Primo boasts an array of tantalizing options, with the burrata pizza stealing the show. Each bite is a delightful combination of flavors, as the delicious burrata perfectly complements the expertly crafted crust. The portions are generous, guaranteeing a satisfying meal that is worth every penny. Moreover, the staff goes the extra mile, even providing bread to accompany your leftovers.

The service at Pizzaiolo Primo is top-notch, with attentive servers who are dedicated to ensuring your satisfaction. From friendly greetings to helpful recommendations, the staff is always ready to cater to your needs. The restaurant’s cozy ambiance and lively atmosphere create the perfect backdrop for a casual yet upscale dining experience.

Whether you’re in the mood for delectable pizzas, refreshing salads, or mouthwatering pasta dishes, Pizzaiolo Primo has it all. The handmade mozzarella and the flavorful eggplant parmigiana are just a glimpse of the culinary delights that await you. With an impressive menu, excellent service, and a location that adds to the overall charm, Pizzaiolo Primo is a must-visit destination for Italian cuisine lovers in downtown Pittsburgh.

Mercurio’s

Address: 5523 Walnut St, Pittsburgh, PA 15232
Phone: +1 (412) 621-6220
Website: mercuriosgelatopizza.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Located in the vibrant Shadyside district of Pittsburgh, Mercurio’s is a delightful pizza restaurant that promises a memorable dining experience. With a cozy and inviting ambiance, the restaurant exudes a warm and friendly atmosphere that sets the stage for an enjoyable meal. The staff at Mercurio’s goes above and beyond to ensure exceptional service, catering to guests’ needs with attentiveness and professionalism.

The star of the show is undoubtedly the mouthwatering pizza, which receives rave reviews from patrons. The thin and flavorful crust, combined with a variety of delicious toppings, leaves a lasting impression. Whether it’s the classic Margherita with creamy mozzarella and fragrant basil or the unique lasagna-inspired pizza, the quality and creativity shine through. To complement the pizza, Mercurio’s offers an extensive selection of gelato, with flavors that are both decadent and refreshing, leaving guests wanting more.

In addition to the delectable food and charming atmosphere, Mercurio’s stands out for its exceptional attention to detail. Guests appreciate the cleanliness of the restaurant and the friendly nature of the staff. Even in unexpected situations, such as misplacing belongings, the dedicated team at Mercurio’s goes the extra mile to ensure a positive experience. Visitors to Pittsburgh who seek an authentic Italian pizza experience paired with friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere will find Mercurio’s to be a top choice worth returning to time and time again.

Mineo’s Pizza House

Address: 2128 Murray Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15217
Phone: +1 (412) 521-2053
Website: mineospizza.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Nestled in Pittsburgh, Mineo’s Pizza House has been delighting pizza enthusiasts since its establishment in 1958. With a rich history and unwavering commitment to quality, Mineo’s has garnered a reputation as the go-to destination for exceptional pizza. Their dedication to preserving the original family recipe, passed down through generations, ensures that every slice embodies the same deliciousness it did over six decades ago.

The pizza at Mineo’s is a true masterpiece. Made with fresh ingredients and a homemade sauce, each bite is a flavor explosion. The cheese, in particular, stands out, with its unparalleled richness and quality. Even the plain cheese pizza is a standout, surpassing expectations and leaving a lasting impression. For those seeking unique flavors, the Buffalo Chicken Pizza offers a tantalizing combination that will leave taste buds dancing with joy.

Beyond the remarkable pizza, Mineo’s Pizza House offers a warm and inviting atmosphere that instantly makes guests feel at home. The friendly and attentive staff further enhances the dining experience, ensuring that every visit is met with exceptional service. From the moment you step foot in the restaurant, you’ll be greeted with a welcoming smile and a genuine eagerness to provide a memorable dining experience.

With its timeless appeal and dedication to excellence, Mineo’s Pizza House continues to reign as the best pizza in Pittsburgh. Whether you’re a long-time fan who has been savoring their pizza for decades or a first-time visitor looking for an unforgettable dining experience, Mineo’s delivers in every aspect. From the heavenly crust to the top-notch customer service, every detail has been carefully crafted to ensure a truly remarkable meal. Discover the taste that has stood the test of time at Mineo’s Pizza House.

Giovanni’s Pizza & Pasta

Address: 123 6th St, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Phone: +1 (412) 281-7060
Website: ilovegiovannis.com
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

Situated in Pittsburgh’s cultural district, Giovanni’s Pizza & Pasta is a hidden gem that never fails to impress. What sets Giovanni’s apart are their delectable pizza options, including mouthwatering vegan and vegetarian choices, and their commitment to providing friendly and efficient service. The pizza itself is exceptional, comparable even to the renowned Chicago style, leaving patrons craving more with each visit. Their gluten-free options are also commendable, as the staff ensures a seamless dining experience for those with dietary restrictions.

Whether you’re dining in or opting for delivery, Giovanni’s delivers on all fronts. From the moment you place your order, the attentive and welcoming staff ensures a smooth and speedy service, leaving no room for disappointment. The quality of their pizza is consistently top-notch, with each slice boasting a perfect balance of flavors. Even during peak hours, Giovanni’s maintains its excellent service standards, proving their commitment to customer satisfaction.

While Giovanni’s may have an unassuming exterior, its delectable offerings make it a must-visit spot. Locals and out-of-towners alike have discovered this hidden treasure and keep coming back for more. The warm and gooey cheese, the flavorful pepperoni, and the satisfyingly soft crust all contribute to an unforgettable pizza experience. Whether you’re in the mood for a quick slice or a whole pizza to share, Giovanni’s is the go-to place to satisfy your cravings and indulge in a truly delightful dining experience.

Piccolo Forno

Address: 3801 Butler St, Pittsburgh, PA 15201
Phone: +1 (412) 622-0111
Website: piccolo-forno.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Nestled in Pittsburgh, Piccolo Forno is a cherished local establishment with over 15 years of culinary excellence. With a team hailing from Italy, this restaurant stands out as the ultimate destination for authentic Italian cuisine in the city. Alongside their renowned pizza and pasta offerings, Piccolo Forno also boasts the equally impressive La Grapperia, a sister bar with a vibrant atmosphere, offering an array of wine, beer, and spirits. For a memorable dining experience, order a pizza from Piccolo Forno and savor it at Grapperia. Reservations are recommended, and please note that they are closed on Sundays and Mondays.

Prepare to embark on a flavor-filled journey as you indulge in the delightful dishes at Piccolo Forno. From the seafood spaghetti to the mortadella pizza, every bite is a testament to their commitment to outstanding flavors. The lasagna, in particular, stands out as an unforgettable creation, with unexpected yet delectable flavors that elevate this classic dish to new heights. While the prices reflect the quality of the ingredients and craftsmanship, it’s important to note that Piccolo Forno goes beyond traditional pepperoni pies, offering an elevated Italian dining experience that is worth every penny. The service is friendly and attentive, adding to the overall enjoyment of the visit.

The combination of excellent food and impeccable service makes Piccolo Forno a go-to destination for both locals and visitors alike. As you walk through Lawrenceville, the inviting atmosphere of the restaurant beckons you in. Once inside, the engaging staff ensures a pleasant experience from start to finish. Whether you’re indulging in their thin-crust wood-fired pizzas or savoring the homemade pastas, each dish is a testament to the culinary expertise and dedication of the team. With a clean and comfortable ambiance, Piccolo Forno offers a high-quality Italian dining experience that is sure to impress.

Piccolo Forno stands out among Pittsburgh’s dining scene as a haven for Italian food enthusiasts. With their wood-fired pizzas boasting thin crusts and fresh toppings, and their delectable homemade pasta dishes, this restaurant consistently delivers excellence on every plate. As you enter the restaurant, the warm and open interior welcomes you, setting the stage for a memorable meal. The knowledgeable waitstaff guides you through the menu, ensuring that your dining experience is tailored to your preferences. Whether you’re enjoying a Margherita pizza with arugula and onion or indulging in the daily special risotto, each dish is prepared with precision and showcases the finest ingredients. Piccolo Forno’s commitment to quality and their passion for creating simple yet extraordinary homemade dishes make this a must-visit destination for Italian cuisine enthusiasts.

Fiori’s Pizzaria

Address: 103 Capital Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15226
Phone: +1 (412) 343-7788
Website: fiorispizzaria.com
Details: $, Pizza Takeout

Fiori’s Pizzaria is a beloved pizza joint in Pittsburgh that has won the hearts of locals and visitors alike. The old-fashioned atmosphere and bustling crowds add to its charm. The star of the show is undoubtedly the pizza, which is a true delight. Whether you opt for a classic cheese pizza or customize it with toppings like roasted red peppers and sausage, you can expect perfection. The crust is crispy and light, providing the perfect base for the generous amount of melted stringy cheese and flavorful sauce. The combination of high-quality ingredients and skilled preparation ensures an exceptional pizza experience.

The staff at Fiori’s Pizzaria are friendly and attentive, making each visit a pleasant one. From the moment you step inside, you’re greeted with warm hospitality. The employees take the time to chat with customers, making them feel welcome and appreciated. Their knowledge of the menu and willingness to answer questions demonstrate their commitment to providing excellent service. Whether you’re dining in or getting a pizza to go, you can expect a positive and enjoyable interaction with the staff.

In addition to its mouthwatering pizza, Fiori’s Pizzaria offers other delectable options on its menu. Italian sub sandwiches, toasted to perfection with crispy buns, are a favorite among patrons. The small, no-frills establishment exudes a charming ambiance reminiscent of old Italian halls, adding to the overall experience. If you’re looking for a place with authentic Italian flavors and a genuine atmosphere, Fiori’s Pizzaria is a must-visit in Pittsburgh.

Pro tip: Don’t miss the opportunity to try their pizza with roasted red peppers—it’s a winning combination. Whether you choose to dine in or pick up your order, Fiori’s Pizzaria guarantees an unforgettable pizza experience that will keep you coming back for more.

Threadbare Cider House

Address: Filters and Topics
Maps
Reviews
Menu
Address
Phone: +1 (412) 322-5100
Website: threadbarecider.com
Details: $$, Cider bar

Threadbare Cider House in Pittsburgh offers a delightful experience for both adults and children. The spacious interior provides ample room for groups of all sizes, making it an ideal choice for family outings. Kids can enjoy the dedicated play area while adults indulge in the exceptional pizzas and a wide selection of drinks. The pizzas at Threadbare are gourmet thin crust creations that are sure to impress even the most discerning palates. The menu also features specialty ciders that change with the seasons, ensuring a unique and refreshing experience every time you visit. The summer/fall patio is a particularly enjoyable spot, offering a dog-friendly environment and adding to the overall charm of the place.

The staff at Threadbare Cider House are knowledgeable, friendly, and attentive. They provide informative and helpful suggestions regarding the drinks and food options available. Whether you’re sitting at the bar or dining with a large group, you can expect excellent service that enhances your overall experience. The appetizers, such as the pickled vegetables and homemade cheese and meats, are wonderful additions to your meal. The pizzas themselves are fresh, hot, and delicious, showcasing the quality ingredients used in their preparation.

For those looking for an educational and enjoyable experience, Threadbare offers tours that provide insights into the cider-making process and the history of apples in the region. The tour guides engage both children and adults with interactive activities and tastings. The tour concludes with a satisfying pizza feast, allowing guests to savor the flavors while appreciating the knowledge gained during the tour. If you’re not a cider enthusiast before visiting Threadbare, you’re likely to leave with a newfound appreciation for the craft and flavors of their hard apple ciders.

Threadbare Cider House is more than just a bar and pizza place. It’s a destination that offers a unique and enjoyable atmosphere, delectable pizzas, and a wide selection of ciders that cater to diverse tastes. Whether you’re a cider aficionado or simply seeking a memorable dining experience, Threadbare Cider House is the perfect spot to relax, indulge, and appreciate the art of cider-making and pizza craftsmanship.

In conclusion, Pittsburgh is home to a vibrant pizza scene that caters to all tastes and preferences. From classic favorites to gourmet creations, the city offers a diverse range of pizza options that are sure to satisfy even the most discerning pizza lovers. Whether you’re in the mood for a traditional New York-style slice or an innovative artisanal pie, Pittsburgh’s best pizza restaurants deliver in both flavor and quality. So, the next time you find yourself craving a slice of pizza perfection, be sure to explore the culinary delights offered by these top-notch pizzerias in the Steel City.