Best Pizza restaurants in Providence [2024]

Welcome to our guide on the best pizza restaurants in Providence! If you’re a pizza lover and find yourself in this vibrant city, you’re in for a treat. Providence boasts a thriving food scene, and when it comes to pizza, you won’t be disappointed. We’ve scoured the city to bring you a handpicked selection of the absolute best pizza restaurants in Providence. From traditional thin-crust delights to innovative gourmet creations, these eateries have perfected the art of pizza-making. Get ready to satisfy your cravings and embark on a mouthwatering pizza adventure!

Providence Coal-fired Pizza

Address: 385 Westminster St, Providence, RI 02903
Phone: +1 (401) 454-7499
Website: providencecoalfiredpizza.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Providence Coal-fired Pizza in Providence is a gem when it comes to pizza restaurants. With every visit, the pizza here is simply amazing, boasting a light and puffy crust that will leave you craving more. Their lentil salad is a standout, and the beer selection is both delightful and refreshing. The friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere make this restaurant one of our favorites. We even had the pleasure of being served by a wonderful waitress who made our experience even more enjoyable.

Aside from the outstanding pizza, their menu offers a great variety of options. We highly recommend trying their monthly special, the Eggplant Parm pizza, which had an amazing flavor that we hope becomes a permanent addition. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this restaurant is worth a visit. Don’t miss out on their coal fire wings and the Conrad and Eggplant pizzas, which are consistently phenomenal. The staff’s dedication to providing excellent service and the inviting atmosphere will keep you coming back for more.

Providence Coal-fired Pizza is a place that pleasantly surprises its customers time and time again. Even for takeout orders, the food exceeds expectations. We started with the Baked Goat Cheese, which was incredibly delicious. The real showstopper, though, was the Meat Lovers Pizza. It was truly spectacular, with the pepperoni adding a spicy kick that elevated the entire pizza. We were so impressed that this place has instantly become a go-to spot for pizza. The crust, which we typically disregard, was too good to resist, especially when dipped in the remaining baked goat cheese. It’s safe to say that this restaurant has won us over with its incredible offerings.

Don’t miss out on the fantastic pizza and wine selection at Providence Coal-fired Pizza. The staff members are attentive and provide great service, ensuring that your dining experience is top-notch. The restaurant itself is clean and well laid out, making it suitable for various occasions, whether you’re visiting with a group, family, or looking for a vibrant bar atmosphere. They even offer free valet parking, which is a convenient bonus. During our first visit to the beautiful city of Providence, we were blown away by the pizza’s quality, ranking it among the best we’ve had, including the renowned NYC and New Haven pizzas. With exceptional service and mouthwatering dishes, this place comes highly recommended.

Flatbread Pizza Company

Address: 161 Cushing St, Providence, RI 02906
Phone: +1 (401) 273-2737
Website: flatbreadcompany.com/locations/providence-ri
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Flatbread Pizza Company in Providence is a place that consistently delivers delicious pizza. Whether you opt for takeout or dine-in, the pizza here is truly outstanding. The staff is friendly and helpful, ensuring a pleasant experience. Even the unforeseen challenge of misleading maps leading to the restaurant didn’t dampen the quality of the food. The pizzas are taken out of a heated cabinet, arriving to customers still hot, which is a thoughtful touch appreciated by all.

The ambiance at Flatbread Pizza Company is inviting, with a casual atmosphere that exudes a touch of style. The use of organic ingredients in their pizzas and salads is commendable, appealing to those seeking wholesome options. They even offer dairy-free cheese for customers with milk allergies. The wood-fired oven adds a delightful flavor to their thin pizzas, making them truly memorable. Their menu also extends beyond pizza, with enticing options like the organic gluten-free pound cake with graham cracker ice cream. The bartenders are friendly and skillful, serving up refreshing drinks like the spicy mule.

Flatbread Pizza Company is a family-friendly establishment with a large dining area and outdoor seating available. The attentive service and speedy delivery of food add to the overall positive experience. Whether you’re a fan of classic toppings like pepperoni or looking to try unique creations like the Bahn mi pizza, you’re in for a treat. The dynamite lemonades are a must-try, perfectly complementing the flavors of the pizza. With their commitment to quality ingredients and excellent service, Flatbread Pizza Company is a place that deserves to be on your list of go-to pizza spots in Providence.

Caserta Pizzeria Bakr

Address: 121 Spruce St, Providence, RI 02903
Phone: +1 (401) 621-3618
Website: casertapizzeria.com
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

Caserta Pizzeria Bakr in Providence is a must-visit establishment that has been serving exceptional pizza for years. The pepperoni pizza and pepper pigs, a delightful combination of sausage and peppers in dough, are absolute winners. The simple yet inviting atmosphere and friendly service make the dining experience even more enjoyable. It’s no wonder that Caserta’s has become an institution that every city should have.

With over 55 years of experience, Caserta’s continues to impress. Their spinach pies and pigs in a blanket are regarded as the best anywhere, keeping loyal customers hooked. The pizza at Caserta’s is truly outstanding, featuring a well-cooked, thick crust, impeccable sauce, and a delicious blend of cheese. The pepperoni adds a tasty and flavorful kick. The sausage pies are equally excellent, showcasing the culinary expertise of this fine establishment.

Caserta’s is cherished by pizza lovers for its authentic Italian-style pizza. The cozy atmosphere inside adds to the overall charm. The pizzas, served in rectangles with mouthwatering crusts, are topped with a generous ladle of sauce on the cheese, adding a delightful touch. The dining experience at Caserta’s is always memorable, and many patrons are eager to return to indulge in their delicious offerings.

Sicilia’s Pizzeria

Address: 181 Atwells Ave, Providence, RI 02903
Phone: +1 (401) 273-9222
Website: siciliasonline.com
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

Sicilia’s Pizzeria in Providence is a hidden gem that offers delectable pizza options. Their Chicago-style pizza, with a choice of regular or stuffed crust, is a standout. The generous toppings and delicious sauce make every bite a delight. The restaurant has a warm and inviting atmosphere, providing an authentic Italian experience. The staff is knowledgeable about the menu and provides exceptional service, ensuring a memorable dining experience.

Whether you’re a fan of thin crust or deep-dish pizza, Sicilia’s Pizzeria has something to satisfy your cravings. The thin crust pizza is flavorful and far from cardboard-like, surprising even those who typically don’t prefer thin crust. The antipasti is a must-try, as it is generously portioned and incredibly delicious. The homemade house dressing is a perfect accompaniment to any salad. The restaurant also offers quick carry-out service, making it convenient for those on the go.

The dedicated staff at Sicilia’s Pizzeria contributes to the overall positive experience. From the friendly and attentive waiter, Wayne, to the prompt delivery service, the customer service is top-notch. The hot and crispy pizzas arrive quickly, ensuring a satisfying meal. The balance of flavors in the sauce, with just the right amount of sweetness and acidity, is a testament to the authenticity of the Italian cuisine served at Sicilia’s Pizzeria. Whether you’re a local or visiting Providence, this pizzeria is a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking a delicious and filling meal.

Pvd Pizza Providence

Address: 1035 Douglas Ave, Providence, RI 02904
Phone: +1 (401) 654-4466
Website: pvdpizza.com
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

PVD Pizza Providence is a local favorite, and its convenient location makes it a go-to spot for many. The menu offers a variety of options, from BBQ chicken pizza to sweet potato fries, ensuring there’s something for everyone. The restaurant’s commitment to quality is evident as the pizzas are delivered piping hot and bursting with flavor. The meat lovers pizza, potato skins, and other dishes have been praised for their delicious taste. It’s a place where you can satisfy your cravings and enjoy a memorable dining experience.

The sensational flavors of the food at PVD Pizza Providence leave a lasting impression. The pizza and pasta dinner received rave reviews, with customers comparing the experience to the famous scene in “When Harry Met Sally.” The mouthwatering flavors and love for food are evident in every bite. The mozzarella tomato prosciutto wrap, though the prosciutto was a little chewy, was still deemed very good. The restaurant also caters to different dietary preferences, offering customizable pizzas and a range of veggie choices for wings and burgers.

With the newly-opened Cranston branch, PVD Pizza Providence continues to expand its reach and delight customers with its offerings. The varied menu sets it apart from chain pizzerias, providing unique and satisfying options. The ability to customize orders and the availability of vegetarian choices further enhance the dining experience. Whether you’re a local resident or passing through the area, PVD Pizza Providence is worth a visit for a taste of their flavorful pizzas and other delightful dishes.

Piemonte Pizza

Address: 114 Doyle Ave, Providence, RI 02906
Phone: +1 (401) 273-0999
Website: piemontepizza.com
Details: $, Italian restaurant

Piemonte Pizza in Providence is a hidden gem that offers great pizzas and friendly personal service. Whether you’re in the mood for slices or whole pizzas, Piemonte has you covered with convenient pick-up and delivery options. The outdoor seating at sidewalk tables provides a charming atmosphere for enjoying their delicious creations. What sets Piemonte apart is their specialty ethnic pizzas and unique menu items, offering a culinary experience you won’t find elsewhere.

The flavors at Piemonte are outstanding, with good-sized portions that leave you satisfied. If you’re a fan of garlic, you won’t be disappointed as they deliver the perfect amount. From the warm marinara sauce to the toppings, every bite is a delightful experience. Visitors to Piemonte are pleasantly surprised by the quality of their pizza, even those who have tried renowned pizzerias in New York. The crust strikes a perfect balance between crispy and chewy, while the tangy and delicious sauce adds a delightful flavor.

The staff at Piemonte is known for their friendly demeanor, creating a welcoming atmosphere for diners. Whether you opt for classic choices like margherita or cheese pizza, or venture into their unique offerings like Kurdish pizza, you’ll be treated to an exceptional dining experience. Piemonte’s commitment to being a local small business is appreciated by customers who enjoy supporting the community. If you’re looking for a memorable pizza experience in Providence, Piemonte Pizza is the place to go, exceeding expectations and leaving a lasting impression.

Wise Guys Deli

Address: Wise Guys Deli, 133 Atwells Ave, Providence, RI 02903
Phone: +1 (401) 621-8111
Website: wiseguysdeli.net
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

Wise Guys Deli in Providence is a must-visit for anyone craving a variety of delicious options. From calzones and pizzas to subs and appetizers, their menu has something for everyone. The service at Wise Guys Deli is exceptional, with a staff that is always fast, attentive, and on point. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, they take care of their customers and ensure a satisfying experience. A standout item on the menu is the Buffalo chicken and cheese calzone with banana peppers, which is consistently perfect. It’s no wonder Wise Guys Deli is a go-to spot for many.

Despite not being one of the traditional pizza hot spots in the US, Wise Guys Deli never fails to impress with their solid pizza. Whether you opt for takeout or dine-in, their friendly customer service and hot food always leave a positive impression. The delivery service is also commendable, with prompt delivery times and delicious, hot, and fresh food brought right to your doorstep. The portions are generous, and the crispy crust and homemade, garlic-infused marinara sauce make every bite a delight. Wise Guys Deli is highly recommended for a satisfying pizza experience.

Located on Federal Hill, Wise Guys Deli is a small place with limited seating. It’s perfect for a quick bite or takeout, with a cozy atmosphere and a cool mafia/gangster theme. The staff is always friendly, and the food consistently lives up to expectations. It’s a convenient alternative to the bustling Federal Hill scene, offering delicious sandwiches and a unique dining experience. Whether you’re in the mood for pizza, sandwiches, or other tasty options, Wise Guys Deli is the place to go for good food, excellent service, and a satisfying meal.

Vasilios Pizza

Address: 579 Atwells Ave, Providence, RI 02909
Phone: +1 (401) 383-5111
Website: vasiliospizza.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Vasilios Pizza in Providence is a fantastic option for late-night dining. They offer delivery until 4 AM, ensuring that you can satisfy your hunger even during the late hours. The Italian sub is a standout item on their menu, delivering a phenomenal taste that will leave you satisfied. Additionally, their x-large Special Pizza is a hearty and fresh delight, featuring a variety of toppings that stand out in terms of quality and flavor.

When let down by other takeout pizza options, Vasilios came through with flying colors. Despite taking a bit of time, their pizza arrived exactly as ordered and was delicious. The pepperoni pizza, in particular, was quite decent. The staff is kind and helpful, both on the phone and during the delivery process. The prompt delivery service and reasonable pricing further contribute to the positive dining experience at Vasilios Pizza.

For those with dietary restrictions, Vasilios also offers gluten-free options. The Gluten Free Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza stands out with a super crunchy crust, which is not easy to achieve with gluten-free pizzas. The flavor is excellent, providing a satisfying experience even for those with specific dietary needs. With quick delivery and a diverse menu that includes hot sandwiches and other delectable options, Vasilios Pizza is the go-to choice for late-night dining in Providence.

Pasta Beach

Address: 195 Wayland Ave, Providence, RI 02906
Phone: +1 (401) 270-0740
Website: pastabeach.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Pasta Beach in Providence offers a delightful dining experience with a beachy atmosphere that exudes a sense of relaxation. The staff is friendly and accommodating, providing excellent service from start to finish. The menu boasts a wide variety of options, from mouthwatering pizzas to delectable pasta dishes, ensuring that there is something for everyone.

The pizzas at Pasta Beach are a standout, featuring a great crust cooked in a brick oven. The margherita pizza, in particular, is authentic and full of flavor. For those craving pasta, the options are equally enticing. The tagliatelle, a thicker fettucine-style pasta, is a hit with a choice of rich bolognese or flavorful mushroom sauce. The portions are generous, leaving diners satisfied and often with leftovers for future enjoyment.

The ambiance of Pasta Beach adds to the overall experience, with a clean and urban interior that creates a pleasant dining environment. The decor is modern and inviting, reflecting a summery vibe. The restaurant is popular among locals, and reservations are recommended to secure a table. Whether you’re looking for a casual lunch or a dressed-up dinner, Pasta Beach is the perfect spot to enjoy delicious Italian cuisine in a welcoming setting.

Al Forno

Address: 577 S Water St, Providence, RI 02903
Phone: +1 (401) 273-9760
Website: alforno.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Al Forno, located in Providence, is a highly regarded Italian restaurant known for its chef-focused menu and delectable dishes. The rustic modern interior creates a casual yet elegant atmosphere, setting the stage for a memorable dining experience. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive, ensuring that guests feel well taken care of throughout their visit.

The menu at Al Forno offers a wide range of options, including their famous grilled pizzas and succulent steak dishes. The pizzas, cooked in a unique brick oven, have a delightful crust that is sure to please pizza enthusiasts. The Dirty Steak, a popular off-menu selection, is a must-try, featuring a tangy sauce that perfectly complements the tender and flavorful meat. Each bite is a burst of deliciousness that leaves a lasting impression.

In addition to the remarkable food, Al Forno is known for its exceptional desserts. The desserts are prepared to order, guaranteeing freshness and a sweet ending to the meal. Whether you choose the made-to-order fruit tart or the indulgent apple crisp tart, you can expect a treat that will satisfy your sweet tooth. With its warm ambiance, friendly service, and outstanding cuisine, Al Forno is a top choice for Italian food lovers in Providence.

In conclusion, Providence boasts an impressive selection of pizza restaurants that cater to diverse tastes and preferences. From the authentic Neapolitan-style pies at Figidini Wood Fire Eatery to the innovative creations at Nice Slice, there is something for everyone in this vibrant culinary scene. Whether you prefer traditional flavors or crave unique toppings, these pizza establishments deliver mouthwatering experiences that leave a lasting impression. So, the next time you find yourself in Providence, be sure to explore these top pizza destinations and indulge in the city’s rich pizza culture.