Welcome to our culinary journey through the vibrant city of Pittsburgh, where we dive deep into the oceanic delights that grace the menus of the Best Seafood restaurants in Pittsburgh. This steel city may be known for its rich industrial heritage, but it also boasts a thriving seafood scene that will leave you craving for more. From succulent lobster to mouthwatering shrimp, we’ve scoured the city to bring you a curated list of Pittsburgh’s finest establishments, where seafood lovers can indulge in the freshest catches and savor the flavors of the sea.
Robert Wholey’s
Address: 1711 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Phone: +1 (412) 391-3737
Website: wholey.com
Details: Seafood market
Nestled in Pittsburgh’s vibrant Strip District, Robert Wholey’s is a seafood restaurant that captures the essence of a bygone era, evoking nostalgia and delivering an exceptional dining experience. Stepping inside, you’ll find yourself surrounded by a lively atmosphere that appeals to both locals and tourists alike. Families with children will delight in the sights and sounds of Wholey’s, with its captivating displays and a mesmerizing fish-tossing show.
Reminiscent of traditional markets, this establishment offers a wide array of fresh seafood and butcher shop delights that will satisfy any discerning palate. Strolling through the expansive store is an adventure in itself, allowing you to immerse in the vibrant ambiance. While perusing their extensive selection, you may stumble upon intriguing finds like large octopi, perfect for grilling and exploring new culinary horizons.
Beyond its impressive seafood offerings, Wholey’s surprises guests with its interactive cooking classes held every Saturday. These informal demonstrations provide valuable insights and tips, allowing enthusiasts to enhance their culinary skills. Accompanied by an accordion player, the classes create a festive atmosphere that makes the entire experience truly memorable.
A true Pittsburgh classic, Wholey’s delivers not only a delectable seafood menu but also a captivating environment. From the mouthwatering scallop po’ boy to the indulgent soft shell crab hoagie, the restaurant offers an abundance of choices that will leave you spoiled for selection. While indulging in their generous servings, don’t miss out on their house-made tartar sauce and seafood cocktail sauce, known for their unparalleled flavor. The bustling atmosphere, accompanied by a model train running above, adds a touch of whimsy to your dining experience.
Located in the renowned Strip District, Wholey’s Fish Market is a haven for seafood aficionados and culinary enthusiasts alike. Their extensive selection of domestic and international fish and seafood, alongside a variety of fresh meats and poultry, ensures there’s something to suit every taste and preference. Whether you’re seeking the freshest sushi, the finest seafood for grilling, or simply looking to immerse yourself in the vibrant market atmosphere, a visit to Wholey’s is an absolute must.
Muddy Waters Oyster Bar
Address: 130 S Highland Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15206
Phone: +1 (412) 361-0555
Website: muddywaterspgh.com
Details: $$, Oyster bar restaurant
Join inKind, dine at a participating venue
and pay your bill with inKind
Nestled in the heart of East Liberty, Muddy Waters Oyster Bar is a hidden gem that brings the flavors of New Orleans to the Midwest. With its delectable selection of oysters and seafood dishes, this charming establishment captures the essence of coastal cuisine. The menu is a tantalizing fusion of Cajun flavors and seafood delights, offering a variety of options that will satisfy even the most discerning palate. From the fresh and succulent West Coast oysters to the flavorful seafood gumbo, each dish is prepared with meticulous attention to detail.
Aside from the exceptional menu, Muddy Waters offers a delightful dining experience with its inviting atmosphere and attentive service. The Bloody Mary bar, spanning an impressive 20 feet, provides an array of fixings, from shrimp and oysters to peppers and olives, ensuring a customizable drink to suit every taste. The restaurant’s commitment to creating a relaxed and laid-back environment adds to the overall enjoyment of the dining experience.
The attention to detail extends beyond the menu and atmosphere to the service provided at Muddy Waters. The friendly and attentive staff ensures that every guest feels welcome and well taken care of. Whether you’re seeking a refreshing cocktail from their extensive drink selection or indulging in their mouthwatering seafood tower, the staff goes above and beyond to ensure a memorable and satisfying dining experience.
Muddy Waters Oyster Bar is not just a restaurant; it’s a haven for seafood lovers and enthusiasts of Cajun cuisine. With its flavorful dishes, charming ambiance, and dedicated staff, this hidden gem in East Liberty offers a culinary experience that will leave you craving more. Whether you’re in the mood for fresh oysters, a delectable seafood gumbo, or a refreshing cocktail, Muddy Waters is the perfect destination to indulge in a truly unforgettable dining experience.
Roland’s Seafood Grill
Address: 1904 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Phone: +1 (412) 261-3401
Website: rolandsseafoodgrill.com
Details: $$, Seafood restaurant
Nestled in Pittsburgh’s vibrant Strip District, Roland’s Seafood Grill is a seafood lover’s paradise. The friendly and efficient staff create a warm and welcoming atmosphere that enhances the overall dining experience. With its reasonable prices and generous portions, this restaurant offers great value for your money.
The menu at Roland’s Seafood Grill boasts an impressive selection of delectable dishes. From the mouthwatering lobster rolls filled with ample chunks of succulent lobster to the flavorful Pasta Di Mare featuring a delightful combination of mussels, clams, shrimp, and scallops, each dish is prepared with meticulous attention to detail. The seafood offerings are fresh, and the attention to flavor and presentation is evident in every bite.
Roland’s Seafood Grill has become a go-to destination for seafood enthusiasts. Whether you’re savoring the giant beer-battered fish sandwich with its double layer of cod or enjoying the hot buttered lobster rolls that are packed with lobster meat, you’re in for a treat. The restaurant’s commitment to quality and its ability to cater to diverse tastes ensure a memorable dining experience for seafood lovers and non-seafood enthusiasts alike.
When you step into Roland’s Seafood Grill, you’ll be greeted by a bustling atmosphere and a team of attentive staff members ready to provide exceptional service. The vibrant Strip District location adds to the charm of this establishment. Whether you’re looking for a satisfying lunch, a delicious dinner, or a seafood feast, Roland’s Seafood Grill is the place to be.
Dorido’s Restaurant
Address: 6408 Brownsville Rd, Pittsburgh, PA 15236
Phone: +1 (412) 655-4711
Website: doridos.net
Details: $$, American restaurant
Located in a bustling neighborhood, Dorido’s Restaurant is a hidden gem for seafood enthusiasts seeking an exceptional dining experience. From delectable fish sandwiches to mouthwatering soups and enticing entrees, this restaurant offers a wide range of options that leave patrons raving. The positive reviews are well-deserved, as Dorido’s consistently delivers on quality and flavor.
One aspect that stands out is the fast, friendly, and professional service provided by the attentive staff. Despite being busy, the waitstaff goes above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining atmosphere. Whether you’re a seafood aficionado or a first-time visitor, the team at Dorido’s treats you like family, making your dining experience truly memorable.
The menu at Dorido’s is a seafood lover’s dream. From the heavenly Maryland Crab Soup with its light tomato base and generous crabmeat to the broiled scallops that are cooked to perfection, every dish is crafted with attention to detail. The crab cakes, packed with flavorful crabmeat and seasoned just right, leave a lasting impression. Even those with discerning tastes, like someone from Louisiana, highly recommend Dorido’s as a go-to destination for exquisite seafood.
Despite the challenges posed by the pandemic, Dorido’s continues to deliver excellence in seafood preparation. The quality of the food surpasses expectations, while the reasonable prices add to the overall appeal. Whether you’re in the mood for grilled seafood platters or fried favorites like oysters and fish fillets, Dorido’s consistently exceeds culinary expectations. The genuine friendliness of the staff and the relaxed atmosphere make this neighborhood joint a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts.
In conclusion, Dorido’s Restaurant is a seafood haven that rivals even a trip to the ocean. With exceptional dishes, attentive service, and a warm atmosphere, it has become a go-to destination for those seeking high-quality seafood in Pittsburgh. The rave reviews from satisfied customers speak volumes about the outstanding experience that awaits at Dorido’s.
Mitchell’s Fish Market
Address: 1500 Washington Rd, Pittsburgh, PA 15228
Phone: +1 (412) 571-3474
Website: mitchellsfishmarket.com/location/mitchells-fish-market-pittsburgh-pa
Details: $$, Seafood restaurant
Mitchell’s Fish Market in Pittsburgh is a renowned seafood restaurant that lives up to its reputation. From the moment you step in, the staff greets you warmly and ensures a pleasant dining experience. Their knowledge and friendliness create a welcoming atmosphere, and they even took the time to acknowledge our anniversary, making us feel truly special. The service throughout the evening was impeccable, and the food exceeded our expectations. Unlike other seafood restaurants with impressive views but lackluster meals, Mitchell’s Fish Market stands out with both its ambiance and the quality of its dishes.
We started our meal with piping hot sourdough bread, setting the stage for an exceptional dining experience. The filet/lobster and prime rib/scampi combinations were simply outstanding. The steaks rivaled those from the finest Chicago steakhouses, while the lobster and scampi were equally delightful. It was a truly memorable meal that surpassed any we’ve had in a long time.
The restaurant’s setting may not be posh, but it exudes a clean and tasteful ambiance with comfortable booths and tables. We appreciated the initial quietness as we arrived early, allowing for easy conversation. As the night progressed, the restaurant filled up, revealing its popularity. We noted a few recessed alcove booths in the bar area, which we plan to request on our next visit.
Mitchell’s Fish Market also boasts an impressive bar, where we enjoyed a refreshing gin martini. The featured wine perfectly complemented our meal, leaving a lasting impression that led us to order a case upon returning home. To top it all off, the complimentary key lime pie dessert was a pleasant surprise, with its ideal balance of tartness and sweetness, providing a delightful conclusion to our dining experience.
We are eager to return to Mitchell’s Fish Market to explore more of their menu options, including their popular happy hour specials. Whether you’re seeking exceptional seafood, a welcoming atmosphere, or a memorable dining experience, Mitchell’s Fish Market is the place to go.
Redfin Blues
Address: 100 Waterfront Dr, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Phone: +1 (412) 322-5837
Website: redfinblues.com
Details: $$, Seafood restaurant
Redfin Blues, a popular seafood restaurant located in Pittsburgh, offers a delightful dining experience with its exceptional staff, inviting atmosphere, and diverse menu. Situated in a charming neighborhood surrounded by lush greenery, the restaurant provides ample outdoor seating, making it a favored choice, especially during the COVID-19 era. Despite the wait for a table, the prompt and cheerful service made the dining experience worth it. The clientele at Redfin Blues encompasses a mix of families with young children, groups of friends, and individuals seeking a memorable meal.
Upon being seated, patrons are treated to a wide array of delectable dishes. The menu caters to every palate, ensuring that there is something for everyone to enjoy. From deep-fried pretzel bites to succulent shrimp, from a classic wedge salad to BBQ chicken flatbread, each dish is prepared with care and served hot. The food at Redfin Blues proves to be both flavorful and satisfying, perfect after a long day of traveling. Moreover, the restaurant boasts a picturesque river view, adding to the overall appeal of the dining experience.
The positive reviews of Redfin Blues continue to pour in, praising not only the food but also the attentive staff and the inviting atmosphere. The waitstaff is described as sweet, talkative, and attentive, providing excellent service despite being busy. The ambiance of the restaurant, with its proximity to the river and the constant movement of boats, creates a delightful and relaxing atmosphere for diners. Whether seated indoors or outdoors, patrons can enjoy the high-quality food, generous portions, and reasonable drink prices.
Redfin Blues is a hidden gem in Pittsburgh, offering an exceptional waterfront dining experience. With its multiple seating areas, including a tranquil garden and an inviting bar, the restaurant provides options for every preference. The menu impresses with its variety of flavors and caters to diverse tastes. Whether savoring the lobster roll, ahi tuna, wings, or salads, guests can expect a satisfying meal. The attentive staff ensures a pleasant dining experience, accommodating special requests and allergies with care. Even on a rainy day, the cozy indoor seating allows guests to enjoy their meals without compromising on comfort. Redfin Blues is a must-visit restaurant for those seeking great food, friendly service, and a picturesque riverside setting in Pittsburgh.
Original Oyster House
Address: 20 Market Square, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Phone: +1 (412) 566-7925
Website: originaloysterhousepittsburgh.com
Details: $, Seafood restaurant
The Original Oyster House, located in Market Square, is a must-visit seafood restaurant in Pittsburgh. With its rich history and friendly staff, it offers a quintessential Pittsburgh dining experience. The atmosphere is filled with nostalgia, and the walls adorned with photos of famous personalities and Miss America pageants from the past. The restaurant is divided into two sections, one with an ordering counter and tables, and the other with a bar and more tables, providing a vibrant and energetic ambiance.
When it comes to the menu, the Original Oyster House delivers exceptional seafood dishes. Their fish sandwich is renowned for its light, perfectly fried breading and delicious rolls. The fish itself is fresh and flaky, devoid of any overpowering fishy taste. The clam chowder is a recommended favorite, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to homemade, flavorful soups. Additionally, the crab cake and fried oysters are highly rated, offering generous portions and impressive flavors. The onion rings, made with the same breading as the oysters, are a delightful twist, and the homemade cocktail and tartar sauces are delectable accompaniments.
What sets the Original Oyster House apart is not just the quality of the food but also the genuine warmth and enthusiasm of the waitstaff. Their knowledge and pride in the restaurant create a welcoming and enjoyable dining experience. Whether you choose the restaurant side or the bar side with its historic ambiance, you’re sure to be impressed. So, if you’re seeking an authentic taste of Pittsburgh and a slice of its culinary heritage, the Original Oyster House is the place to be.
Gandy Dancer Saloon
Address: 100 W Station Square Dr, Pittsburgh, PA 15219
Phone: +1 (412) 261-1717
Website: facebook.com/GandyDancerSaloon
Details: $$$, Bar
Nestled in Pittsburgh, the Gandy Dancer Saloon is a captivating seafood restaurant that should not be overlooked. Its location alone is remarkable, offering stunning views and an intriguing historical ambiance. Step inside, and you’ll be greeted by an inviting atmosphere. The interior boasts a charming seafood bar situated to the right of the beautiful, elongated wooden bar. The bartenders, like Robert, are friendly and skillfully prepare delicious drinks that are a pleasure to sip on, such as the exquisite lemon drop martini with a sugar rim. Even if you plan to dine at the adjacent Grand Concourse Restaurant, it’s highly recommended to indulge in a drink at the Gandy Dancer Saloon first. Although the river view cannot be enjoyed from inside, the restaurant’s proximity to the Incline to Mt. Washington allows for a breathtaking nighttime vista of the city.
What sets the Gandy Dancer Saloon apart is the complete experience it offers. While there may be other bars with lower prices and free parking, this establishment remains a perennial favorite due to its overall charm. Sitting at the magnificent bar, enjoying well-crafted martinis, immersing oneself in the delightful seafood aroma, and admiring the beautiful surroundings create an unforgettable ambiance. The attentive wait staff, dressed in crisp white shirts and black vests, further enhance the feeling of being in a special place. The culinary offerings are equally impressive, with standout dishes like Charlie’s Chowder, delectable mussels, and unbeatable fish sandwiches.
For birthdays or a fun night out, the Gandy Dancer Saloon is a go-to destination. Whether it’s a girls’ night celebration or a romantic date, the restaurant consistently delivers fantastic food and top-notch service. Scott, an exceptional waiter, ensures that every visit is a memorable one. Indulge in mouthwatering appetizers like the trademarked mussels with hot bread, followed by pasta entrees like the shrimp primavera or shrimp pasta verde with goat cheese. The warm and cozy atmosphere, reminiscent of an old train station, adds to the overall charm. With great value and a wide range of seafood options, the Gandy Dancer Saloon is a must-visit for locals and newcomers alike.
In a casual and relaxed setting, the Gandy Dancer Saloon offers an impressive selection of great seafood dishes. The pasta primavera is a standout choice, consistently delivering a delicious and memorable experience. Served with hot rolls, the salads are crisp and fresh, while the mussels make for an excellent appetizer. The attentive service ensures a leisurely dining experience, perfect for celebrating special occasions. The bar area, featuring a piano bar and raw bar, is always bustling and provides a warm and inviting atmosphere. Enjoy a satisfying lunch with reasonable prices and generous portions. Don’t forget to indulge in their fresh warm rolls, and if you have a craving for seafood jambalaya, the Gandy Dancer Saloon will not disappoint. It’s a destination worth revisiting whenever you find yourself in Pittsburgh.
Del Frisco’s Double Eagle Steakhouse
Address: 455 Fifth Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15219
Phone: +1 (412) 240-6140
Website: delfriscos.com
Details: $$$$, Steak house
Indulge in an extraordinary dining experience at Del Frisco’s Double Eagle Steakhouse in Pittsburgh. Situated in the Frick Building, the restaurant offers a sophisticated atmosphere with classy decor and a modern steakhouse feel. The attentive and personable bartenders ensure a memorable evening, while the live entertainment adds to the vibrant ambiance. From start to finish, the whole experience is nothing short of fantastic.
Prepare to be impressed by the exceptional staff, including servers like April, John, and Rebecca, who provide outstanding service. The knowledgeable and attentive team goes above and beyond to make your visit special. Led by the charming General Manager, Nick, who is passionate about ensuring a delightful dining experience for every guest. The extensive menu features delectable options, with highlights including the mouthwatering porterhouse steak and the must-try caviar French toast. The presentation of each dish is impeccable.
Del Frisco’s Double Eagle Steakhouse is the perfect venue for celebrating special occasions. Whether it’s an anniversary or a birthday, the restaurant’s attentive staff, such as Sheldon and April, will make you feel truly valued. The indulgent desserts, like the off-the-hook butter cake, exceed expectations. Valet parking adds convenience to your visit, while joining the Landry’s club offers additional perks and rewards. Del Frisco’s Double Eagle Steakhouse is a culinary gem that shouldn’t be missed, whether you’re a local or a visitor to Pittsburgh.
Cioppino Restaurant & Cigar Bar
Address: 2350 Railroad St, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Phone: +1 (412) 281-6593
Website: cioppinoofpittsburgh.com
Details: $$$, Steak house
Cioppino Restaurant & Cigar Bar in Pittsburgh is a dining destination that exceeds expectations with its exceptional staff, inviting atmosphere, and diverse menu. As a chop house and seafood specialist, the restaurant offers a variety of options to please seafood enthusiasts. From the mouthwatering crab cakes to the tantalizing ahi tuna and halibut, every dish is presented with care and receives rave reviews. Guests can indulge in a memorable dining experience where each person at the table can savor something different and leave thoroughly impressed.
After dinner, guests can retire to the cigar bar, which adds an extra touch of luxury to the evening. The sophisticated and sleek atmosphere creates a perfect setting for enjoying favorite bourbons and fine cigars. The combination of delectable cuisine and the cigar bar contributes to a great overall experience for all patrons.
Cioppino Restaurant & Cigar Bar not only delights with its culinary offerings but also with its attentive and professional staff. With efficient and unobtrusive service, guests can enjoy a seamless dining experience. The atmosphere is designed to facilitate conversation, making it an ideal place for a quiet, professionally served meal. Whether it’s a special occasion or a casual dinner with friends, Cioppino Restaurant & Cigar Bar provides a remarkable dining experience that leaves a lasting impression.
In conclusion, Pittsburgh boasts a vibrant seafood dining scene that caters to all tastes and preferences. From upscale establishments offering exquisite seafood delicacies to casual joints serving mouthwatering fish sandwiches, the city has something to offer every seafood lover. Whether you’re seeking a fine dining experience with top-notch service or a relaxed atmosphere to enjoy fresh catches of the day, the best seafood restaurants in Pittsburgh have it all. So, if you find yourself in the Steel City, be sure to explore these culinary gems and treat yourself to a memorable seafood feast that will leave you craving for more.
