Best Steakhouses in Columbus [2024]

Welcome to our mouthwatering exploration of the Best Steakhouses in Columbus! If you’re a steak enthusiast seeking sizzling cuts of prime meat, you’re in for a treat. Columbus, Ohio, is home to a vibrant culinary scene that offers an array of exceptional steakhouses, each with its own unique charm and delectable offerings. From traditional classics to innovative creations, we’ll delve into the city’s finest establishments where you can indulge in top-notch steaks cooked to perfection. Get ready to embark on a carnivorous adventure through the Best Steakhouses in Columbus!

Jeff Ruby’s Steakhouse

Address: 89 E Nationwide Blvd, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone: +1 (614) 686-7800
Website: jeffruby.com/columbus
Details: $$$$, Steak house

Jeff Ruby’s Steakhouse in Columbus offers an unparalleled fine dining experience that consistently exceeds expectations. With impeccable service and an atmosphere of upscale elegance, it’s the perfect choice for special occasions. The menu, while on the pricier side, is on par with other high-end establishments in town, delivering exceptional quality.

This steakhouse stands out with its unique twists on traditional flavors. The steak seasoning offers a delightful departure from the norm, while the addition of a sushi bar adds an enticing touch of variety to the dining experience. The staff is well-trained and experienced, ensuring attentive service and a seamless bar service. From live music to crushed velvet seats, the ambiance successfully recreates the authentic feel of a New York City steakhouse.

At Jeff Ruby’s, every dish is a masterpiece. While renowned for their incredible steaks, they also impress with delectable alternatives such as the perfectly cooked pork chop. Noteworthy appetizers like the crab cake and wagyu meatballs add to the overall exceptional dining experience. The attentive service, combined with the expertly prepared food, ensures that every visit is a memorable occasion.

With exceptional service, a captivating atmosphere, and an outstanding menu, Jeff Ruby’s Steakhouse in Columbus is a culinary gem that guarantees an extraordinary dining experience. From the moment you step through the doors, you’ll be treated to a feast for the senses that will leave a lasting impression. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply indulging in a remarkable meal, Jeff Ruby’s is the place to be.

The Avenue Steak Tavern

Address: 1307 Grandview Ave #3013, Columbus, OH 43212
Phone: +1 (614) 485-9447
Website: theavenuesteaktavern.com
Details: $$$, Restaurant

The Avenue Steak Tavern in Columbus is a culinary gem that promises an unforgettable dining experience. With steaks that melt in your mouth and a menu featuring a variety of delicious options, this establishment never fails to impress. The specialty drinks are tasty, and the Parmesan green beans are a favorite among patrons. Whether you’re looking for drinks and appetizers or a full meal, The Avenue is highly recommended.

The excellent food is complemented by exceptional service and a welcoming atmosphere. The staff is knowledgeable and attentive, providing helpful recommendations for both food and wine. The muted ambiance adds to the overall charm of the place, creating a relaxed and enjoyable dining environment. The extensive wine list offers great selections, and the steaks are cooked to perfection, satisfying even the most discerning palate.

Whether it’s a special occasion or a casual outing, The Avenue Steak Tavern delivers on all fronts. From the fantastic appetizers to the delectable main courses, every dish is prepared with care and attention to detail. The restaurant strikes the perfect balance between elegance and comfort, making it an ideal choice for any gathering. With friendly service, impeccable flavors, and a memorable dining experience, The Avenue Steak Tavern is a must-visit destination in Columbus.

J. Gilbert’s Wood-fired Steaks & Seafood

Address: 1 E Campus View Blvd, Columbus, OH 43235
Phone: +1 (614) 840-9090
Website: jgilberts.com/columbus
Details: $$$, Steak house

J. Gilbert’s Wood-fired Steaks & Seafood in Columbus is a standout destination for celebrating special occasions or simply indulging in a remarkable dining experience. The restaurant exudes a cozy and warm atmosphere, providing the perfect setting for a winter anniversary or any memorable event. The attentive staff goes above and beyond to ensure a delightful dining experience.

The menu at J. Gilbert’s is a true culinary delight. From the perfectly cooked steaks with a charred wood-fired flavor to the delectable seafood options like seared scallops, every dish is prepared to perfection. The attention to detail is evident, from homemade blue cheese dressing to mouthwatering appetizers like onion rings and calamari. The desserts, such as Crème Brûlée and coconut cake, provide a sweet and satisfying finale to the meal.

Guests consistently praise the excellent service and the high quality of the food. The staff is attentive, knowledgeable, and accommodating, making every guest feel welcome and well taken care of. The combination of outstanding flavors, reasonable pricing, and a relaxed yet upscale atmosphere sets J. Gilbert’s apart as a top choice for upscale dining in the Columbus area.

J. Gilbert’s Wood-fired Steaks & Seafood offers an exceptional dining experience with its delectable menu, attentive staff, and inviting atmosphere. Whether you’re seeking a memorable celebration or simply want to savor a delicious meal, this restaurant delivers on all fronts. With their wood-fired steaks, delightful appetizers, and decadent desserts, J. Gilbert’s is a true gem that will leave you craving another visit.

Mitchell’s Steakhouse

Address: 45 N 3rd St, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone: +1 (614) 621-2333
Website: mitchellssteakhouse.com/location/mitchells-steakhouse-columbus-downtown
Details: $$$$, Steak house

Mitchell’s Steakhouse in Columbus offers a dining experience that surpasses expectations. Located conveniently close to hotels, it provides exceptional service and delicious steaks. The sides are also flavorful and complement the main dishes perfectly. Although it would be great to see some wine specials, patrons are still eager to return and give this steakhouse another try.

For those looking for a quick lunch, Mitchell’s is an excellent choice. The restaurant offers an elegant atmosphere and courteous service, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The meals are efficiently packaged for travelers who need to catch a flight, making it a convenient option. The attentive staff, including Michael, goes above and beyond to ensure that customers are well taken care of.

Mitchell’s Steakhouse consistently delivers on its promise of great steaks and an inviting atmosphere. Guests praise the beautiful ambiance of the restaurant, complete with stunning presentations of oysters and attentive service. The quality of the steaks is unparalleled, with options like twin lobster tails cooked to perfection. The dining experience is further enhanced by the friendly and efficient waitstaff, making every visit truly fabulous.

From the perfectly cooked steaks to the outstanding sides and desserts, Mitchell’s Steakhouse in Columbus offers a dining experience that rivals even renowned establishments. The menu is carefully crafted, and the quality of the food is exceptional. Whether you’re indulging in a three-course special or savoring the lobster bisque and bone-in ribeye, every dish is prepared with precision. The attentive and knowledgeable staff, such as Mykel, adds to the overall enjoyment of the meal. Whether it’s a business dinner or a special occasion, Mitchell’s Steakhouse is a top-notch choice that never disappoints.

The Top Steakhouse

Address: 2891 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43209
Phone: +1 (614) 231-8238
Website: thetopsteakhouse.com
Details: $$$$, Steak house

Nestled in Columbus, Ohio, The Top Steakhouse has been a beloved dining destination since 1955. Located in the Eastlawn neighborhood, it exudes a classic 1950s supper club ambiance, complete with a wood-paneled dining room, dim lighting, and cozy leather booths. The restaurant’s live piano music, performed by Sonia Modes, adds to the enchanting atmosphere. With its fine dining experience, The Top Steakhouse remains a top choice, particularly for those seeking the nostalgia of elegant dining from yesteryears.

Visitors to The Top Steakhouse can expect exceptional service and an impressive menu. Guests rave about the delectable jumbo shrimp cocktail, deviled eggs, escargot, and Caesar salad with grilled chicken breast as appetizers. When it comes to the main course, the specialty of the house, the char-broiled filet mignon and bacon-wrapped filet mignon, steal the show. Served with delectable sauces and sides like sautéed mushrooms and whipped potatoes, the steaks are cooked to perfection. Indulging in desserts like creme brulee and New York cheesecake is the perfect way to conclude a memorable dining experience at The Top Steakhouse.

With its impeccable service, attention to detail, and consistent quality, The Top Steakhouse continues to impress patrons. From the moment guests walk through the door, they are greeted warmly and guided through an exquisite culinary journey. The professional waitstaff ensures that every need is met, offering expert recommendations and ensuring a leisurely dining experience. The extensive wine selection, attentive service, and perfectly cooked steaks make The Top Steakhouse a cherished destination for birthdays, anniversaries, and other special occasions. Whether it’s enjoying the nostalgic atmosphere, savoring the sumptuous food, or relishing the delightful piano melodies, a visit to The Top Steakhouse is a delightful journey back in time.

Rodizio Grill

Address: 125 W Nationwide Blvd, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone: +1 (614) 241-4400
Website: rodiziogrill.com/columbus
Details: $$$, Brazilian restaurant

Located near Nationwide Arena in Columbus, Rodizio Grill offers a unique and delightful dining experience. The salad bar boasts a great variety of options, but it’s the meats that truly steal the show. From perfectly cooked steak to flavorful chicken, pork, and fish, the selection of grilled meats is simply amazing. The attentive and polite staff, including the manager who personally checks in with guests, adds to the overall pleasant dining experience. The concept of using a block to signal when to take a break from the continuous meat service is a clever touch.

Rodizio Grill has become a go-to choice for many families, making it a popular spot for birthdays and celebrations. The cost may be higher, but the quality and quantity of food make it well worth the price, especially for meat lovers. The attentive service ensures that guests are well taken care of, while the extensive salad bar offers a second meal in itself. Don’t miss the opportunity to try the delicious banana appetizer, which also serves as a fantastic dessert option. With its clean and inviting atmosphere, Rodizio Grill provides a fun and fulfilling dining experience that leaves guests satisfied and looking forward to their next visit.

For those seeking a Brazilian steakhouse experience, Rodizio Grill does not disappoint. The endless supply and variety of meats, along with a well-stocked salad bar, make it a haven for food lovers. The meats are flavorful and cooked to perfection, with options ranging from beef and chicken to pork, lamb, and sausage. The grilled pineapple is a particular favorite among diners. The attentive servers ensure that guests are never kept waiting for more grilled delights. The restaurant’s pricing may be higher, but the quality and taste of the food justify the cost. Overall, Rodizio Grill offers a unique adventure in dining, leaving guests full and satisfied.

Texas De Brazil – Columbus

Address: 4040 Easton Station Suite E 105, Columbus, OH 43219
Phone: +1 (614) 472-4072
Website: texasdebrazil.com/locations/columbus
Details: $$$, Steak house

Texas de Brazil in Columbus offers a unique and satisfying dining experience for meat lovers. The restaurant provides an all-you-can-eat meat buffet where servers circulate with various cuts of steak, lamb, pork, chicken, sausages, and more. The quality and flavor of the meats are exceptional, with options like filet mignon, flank steak, and bacon-wrapped chicken being particular favorites among diners. The restaurant employs a clever system using cards, where the green side signals the servers to bring more meat and the red side indicates a break.

The salad bar at Texas de Brazil is a delightful addition, offering a wide variety of fresh and delicious options, including sushi, shrimp, cheeses, and lobster bisque. While it’s tempting to indulge in the salad bar, it’s recommended to save room for the highlight of the meal—the succulent meats. The restaurant’s atmosphere is elegant and inviting, creating a pleasant dining ambiance for family gatherings, work events, or special occasions.

Though Texas de Brazil may come with a higher price tag, the quality of food and service justifies the cost. Lunchtime visits offer a more budget-friendly option while still providing a satisfying selection of meats. The attentive and professional staff ensure a great dining experience from start to finish. With its mouthwatering meats, abundant salad bar, and tempting sides, Texas de Brazil promises a truly memorable and carnivorous feast.

Ruth’s Chris Steak House

Address: 511 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone: +1 (614) 927-5663
Website: ruthschris.com
Details: $$$$, Restaurant

Nestled in downtown Columbus, Ruth’s Chris Steak House offers an exceptional dining experience that never fails to impress. The atmosphere is chic yet relaxed, providing the perfect setting for a memorable meal. The staff at Ruth’s Chris, from attentive servers to gracious hosts, goes above and beyond to ensure each guest feels welcome and valued.

The menu at Ruth’s Chris is a true delight for steak lovers and seafood enthusiasts alike. The steaks, such as the melt-in-your-mouth filet, are cooked to perfection, leaving a lasting impression. Seafood options like the crab cakes and grilled shrimp are flavorful and expertly prepared. The accompaniments, from the indulgent lobster mac and cheese to the pecan crusted sweet potatoes, elevate the dining experience to new heights.

In addition to the delectable food, Ruth’s Chris offers a well-curated wine list and handcrafted cocktails that perfectly complement the meal. The friendly and knowledgeable staff is always ready to assist with pairing suggestions. Despite the restaurant’s popularity, the service remains top-notch, ensuring that every guest feels cared for and attended to.

While parking may pose a slight challenge, the culinary journey that awaits at Ruth’s Chris Steak House makes it well worth the visit. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for an extraordinary dining experience, Ruth’s Chris Steak House in Columbus is the perfect destination.

Redlands Grill By J. Alexander’s

Address: 4000 Stelzer Rd, Columbus, OH 43219
Phone: +1 (614) 847-1166
Website: jalexanders.com
Details: $$$, American restaurant

Located in Columbus, Redlands Grill By J. Alexander’s offers an amazing dining experience that exceeds expectations. From the moment you step in, the friendly and pleasant staff ensures a memorable visit. The service is attentive, and the servers are knowledgeable, answering any questions with ease. While the menu may be on the higher end, the quality of the food justifies the price. The steaks are seared to perfection, leaving a lasting impression on your taste buds. Be sure to save room for their delectable homemade desserts, as they are not to be missed. Whether you’re visiting for a quick meal or a special occasion, Redlands Grill By J. Alexander’s guarantees a delightful experience.

The restaurant’s proximity to hotels makes it a convenient choice for tourists, and the relaxing atmosphere adds to the overall charm. The ambiance strikes a balance between sophistication and comfort, providing the perfect setting for a relaxed dining experience. The menu boasts a variety of options, with large portions that will satisfy even the heartiest appetites. From steak and burgers to seafood dishes, there is something to please every palate. The attention to detail is evident in every aspect, from the well-prepared salad plates to the mouthwatering kabob steak. Redlands Grill By J. Alexander’s is the ideal choice for a satisfying meal in a cozy and welcoming environment.

When it comes to exceptional service and culinary delights, Redlands Grill By J. Alexander’s does not disappoint. The commitment to excellence is evident in their carefully crafted dishes and attentive staff. The gluten-free options are a testament to their dedication to accommodating special dietary needs. The flavorful steak kabobs and delectable seafood dishes leave a lasting impression. The restaurant’s well-trained servers provide exceptional service, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The efficient table cleaning and preparation showcase their commitment to maintaining a seamless flow for all customers. Whether you’re a steak lover or prefer seafood, Redlands Grill By J. Alexander’s is the perfect choice for a memorable and delicious dining experience.

Ted’s Montana Grill

Address: Easton Gateway 4169, Worth Ave, Columbus, OH 43219
Phone: +1 (614) 337-1457
Website: tedsmontanagrill.com
Details: $$, American restaurant

Ted’s Montana Grill in Columbus offers an exceptional dining experience that is sure to impress. The staff provides amazing service, ensuring that every guest feels welcomed and attended to. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with a brick front structure and plenty of natural lighting. Whether you choose to dine indoors or on the patio, the ambiance strikes a perfect balance between fine dining and approachability. With convenient parking options nearby, it’s a hassle-free experience from start to finish.

The menu at Ted’s Montana Grill offers a wide variety of delicious options. The bison dishes, in particular, are a standout feature. From the perfectly cooked bison steak to the mouthwatering bison burger, the flavors are exceptional. The attention to detail in food presentation is evident, with each dish well-plated and visually appealing. The made-from-scratch meals taste fresh and flavorful, leaving a lasting impression.

The overall experience at Ted’s Montana Grill is top-notch. The knowledgeable and friendly servers go above and beyond to provide excellent service. They are attentive, offering helpful recommendations and ensuring that every detail is taken care of. The commitment to cleanliness and safety protocols is commendable, making guests feel comfortable and secure. Whether you’re visiting for a special occasion or simply craving a great burger, Ted’s Montana Grill is the perfect choice for a memorable dining experience.

Mitchell’s Ocean Club

Address: 4002 Easton Station, Columbus, OH 43219
Phone: +1 (614) 416-2582
Website: ocean-prime.com/locations-menus/mitchells-ocean-club
Details: $$$$, Seafood restaurant

Located in Columbus, Ohio, Mitchell’s Ocean Club is a renowned restaurant that offers an exceptional dining experience. Situated at Easton Town Center, this elegant restaurant and lounge focuses on seafood and prime steaks, providing a stylish atmosphere for guests to enjoy. With a main dining room, lounge, private dining rooms, and an outdoor terrace, Mitchell’s Ocean Club offers a variety of spaces to suit different occasions.

The menu at Mitchell’s Ocean Club is a highlight, featuring a range of delectable options. From jumbo shrimp cocktail and lobster bisque to Caesar salad and mouthwatering entrees like Branzino and Florida grouper, every dish is prepared with precision and bursting with flavor. The attention to detail in both presentation and taste is evident, leaving guests impressed with each bite. Indulging in the warm butter cake with berries or the 10-layer carrot cake for dessert is the perfect way to conclude a memorable dining experience.

The staff at Mitchell’s Ocean Club provides top-notch service, offering attentive and knowledgeable assistance throughout the meal. From friendly servers to attentive managers, the team ensures that guests feel welcomed and well-cared for. The restaurant’s compliance with COVID-19 precautions, such as spaced-out tables and mask-wearing staff, adds an extra layer of comfort and safety. With its convenient location, upscale ambiance, exceptional menu, and impeccable service, Mitchell’s Ocean Club is a must-visit destination for seafood and steak lovers alike.

Matt & Tony’s Wood Fired Kitchen

Address: 525 Short St, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone: +1 (614) 732-5098
Website: mattandtonys.com
Details: $$, Restaurant

Matt & Tony’s Wood Fired Kitchen in Columbus offers an excellent dining experience with its attentive staff, inviting atmosphere, and delightful menu. Whether you visit with a large group or for a casual evening out, the restaurant delivers on all fronts. The attentive servers ensure a seamless dining experience, making guests feel welcomed and well-cared for. The staff goes the extra mile to accommodate groups and make their visit special.

The menu at Matt & Tony’s Wood Fired Kitchen offers a variety of delicious options. From the mouthwatering BBQ ribs and prime rib specials to the flavorful boneless fried chicken and filet mignon, each dish is thoughtfully prepared and full of exquisite flavors. The generous portions and fair prices make the dining experience even more enjoyable. Don’t miss out on the delectable mozzarella cheese sticks, which are far from the ordinary, and the homemade BBQ sauce that adds a delightful touch to the chicken tender platter.

The ambiance of Matt & Tony’s Wood Fired Kitchen adds to the overall dining experience. The pleasant music playing in the background sets a relaxing tone, and the cleanliness and maintenance of the restrooms reflect the restaurant’s commitment to providing a comfortable environment. Whether you’re seeking a refreshing Blackberry Cucumber Mint Margarita or a classic Manhattan from the cocktail menu, the bar offers a great selection of drinks to complement your meal. With every visit to Matt & Tony’s Wood Fired Kitchen, you can expect excellent food, friendly service, and a warm and inviting atmosphere.

In conclusion, Columbus boasts a vibrant culinary scene that includes some exceptional steakhouses. Whether you’re a steak connoisseur or simply looking for a memorable dining experience, the city offers a variety of options to satisfy your cravings. From the elegant ambiance of Mitchell’s Ocean Club to the wood-fired flavors of Matt & Tony’s Wood Fired Kitchen, there’s something for everyone. Each steakhouse brings its own unique flair, from outstanding service to carefully curated menus. So, the next time you find yourself in Columbus, be sure to treat yourself to a mouthwatering steak dinner at one of these top-notch establishments. Your taste buds will thank you.