Welcome to our guide on the Best Italian restaurants in Indianapolis! Whether you’re a resident or a visitor, if you have a craving for authentic Italian cuisine, you’re in for a treat. Indianapolis boasts a vibrant food scene, and Italian cuisine has found a special place in the hearts (and stomachs) of locals. From traditional trattorias serving up mouthwatering pasta dishes to elegant ristorantes with exquisite flavors, we’ve scoured the city to bring you a curated list of the Best Italian restaurants in Indianapolis. Get ready to embark on a culinary adventure like no other!

Earn up to 5% cashback on Restaurants!
Explore Best Credit Cards for Restaurants

Mama Carolla’s Old Italian Restaurant

Address: 1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Phone: +1 (317) 259-9412
Website: mamacarollas.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Nestled in a charmingly converted old home, Mama Carolla’s Old Italian Restaurant in Indianapolis offers an unforgettable dining experience. As you step inside, the cozy atmosphere transports you to a bygone era. With attentive and friendly waitstaff, the service here is top-notch, ensuring a memorable visit. Despite the restaurant’s popularity, the staff manages to provide prompt service even during busy periods.

The menu at Mama Carolla’s is a true celebration of old-fashioned Italian cuisine. From the vibrant and lively flavors to the generous portions, each dish is a testament to their culinary expertise. Whether you indulge in the eggplant puttanesca, chicken parmesan, or shrimp scampi, you’re in for a treat. Don’t forget to save room for their delectable desserts like tiramisu and cannolis.

Mama Carolla’s ambiance is as visually appealing as the food is delicious. The interior seating is divided into intimate rooms, offering a cozy and romantic setting. If you prefer outdoor dining, their patio with a beautiful garden is an excellent choice. While the restaurant can get busy and the rooms might be a bit crowded, the overall experience is worth it.

In conclusion, Mama Carolla’s Old Italian Restaurant stands out as one of the best Italian dining establishments in Indianapolis. With its gracious staff, inviting atmosphere, and mouthwatering menu, it’s no wonder this place is highly recommended. So, plan your visit accordingly to avoid a wait and indulge in a delightful culinary journey that will leave you longing to return.

Bazbeaux Pizza

Address: 333 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 636-7662
Website: bazbeaux.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

If you’re in search of the perfect pizza in Indianapolis, look no further than Bazbeaux Pizza. This restaurant offers a delightful atmosphere with good music and a cool vibe, making it an ideal spot for a date night or a casual lunch. The thin, perfectly crispy crust is the star of their pizzas, topped with generous amounts of cheese, fresh sauce, and an array of flavorful ingredients. Whether you opt for classic toppings or venture into their exotic options like artichoke or crab meat, the pizza at Bazbeaux is simply fantastic.

Get $25 off a bill of $50

Join inKind, dine at a participating venue
and pay your bill with inKind

Get $25 off

The staff at Bazbeaux Pizza is known for their friendliness and attentiveness, providing excellent service throughout your dining experience. They are quick to take care of your needs and ensure your satisfaction. Vegetarian and gluten-free options are available, catering to various dietary preferences. If you’re looking for a carry-out option, rest assured that your pizza will arrive hot and delicious.

Aside from the occasional pricing issue with soft drink refills, Bazbeaux Pizza continues to impress customers with their outstanding food and inviting atmosphere. The cozy interiors, complete with a spacious dining area and a well-stocked bar, create an enjoyable environment for dining. The menu extends beyond pizza, offering tasty salads and tempting sandwiches. With their commitment to fresh ingredients and great service, Bazbeaux Pizza remains a top choice for pizza lovers in Indianapolis.

Iozzo’s Garden Of Italy

Address: 946 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46225
Phone: +1 (317) 974-1100
Website: iozzos.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Experience the taste of authentic Italian cuisine at Iozzo’s Garden Of Italy in Indianapolis. This restaurant impresses with its fantastic food and attentive staff, ensuring a memorable dining experience. From the moment you step inside, you’ll be greeted by a cozy and romantic atmosphere, making it an ideal choice for special occasions or a romantic date night.

The menu at Iozzo’s offers a wide range of traditional Italian dishes that are prepared with care and skill. Whether you indulge in the short rib ragu, the rigatoni alla vodka, or the flavorful seafood options, every dish is prepared to perfection. The made-on-site pasta steals the show with its smooth texture, while the fresh ingredients and attention to detail elevate the flavors.

The attentive and professional staff at Iozzo’s adds to the overall dining experience. From friendly greetings to helpful suggestions, they ensure that your needs are met throughout your visit. The service is efficient, and the timing of each course is just right. The restaurant also offers a great wine list to complement your meal.

With its excellent food, welcoming ambiance, and impeccable service, Iozzo’s Garden Of Italy is a top choice for Italian cuisine in Indianapolis. Whether you’re seeking a romantic dinner, a business lunch, or a memorable dining experience, this restaurant is sure to impress. Make a reservation in advance to secure your spot in this hidden gem of the city.

Brozinni Pizzeria

Address: 8810 S Emerson Ave # 240, Indianapolis, IN 46237
Phone: +1 (317) 865-0911
Website: brozinni.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Discover the taste of authentic New York-style pizza at Brozinni Pizzeria in Indianapolis. This restaurant has garnered praise for its incredible pizza, flavorful appetizers, and friendly staff. Located conveniently near the speedway, it offers a pleasant dining experience in a great location.

The pizza at Brozinni is hailed as some of the best in the country. With a perfect crust as its foundation, each slice is packed with flavor and generous toppings. The garlic knots and pepperoni rolls are highly recommended and leave patrons wanting more. Whether you opt for the classic cheese pizza or explore their specialty options, the quality and taste are unparalleled.

The staff at Brozinni Pizzeria are known for their friendly and helpful demeanor. From assisting with menu choices to ensuring a pleasant dining experience, they go above and beyond to cater to guests’ needs. The service is efficient, and the staff’s attentiveness contributes to a positive overall atmosphere.

Whether you’re visiting Indianapolis or a local resident, Brozinni Pizzeria is a must-visit destination for pizza lovers. The large portion sizes, exceptional flavor, and reasonable prices make it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. If you’re in the area, don’t miss the opportunity to indulge in their delicious pizza, flavorful garlic knots, and other delectable menu items.

Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza

Address: 5646 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219
Phone: +1 (317) 356-6612
Website: jockamopizza.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Indulge in a delightful pizza experience at Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza in Indianapolis. This restaurant boasts excellent staff, a welcoming atmosphere, and a menu filled with mouthwatering pizza options. From the moment you enter, you’ll be greeted with friendly service and a vibrant ambiance.

The pizzas at Jockamo are the stars of the show, capturing the hearts and taste buds of visitors. Whether you opt for classic choices or explore their specialty pizzas, each slice is bursting with flavor. The crust is perfect, striking a balance between New York and Chicago styles. With a variety of toppings and combinations to choose from, you’re bound to find a pizza that suits your taste.

The staff at Jockamo are known for their exceptional service and attentiveness. From offering helpful recommendations to accommodating large parties, they ensure that every guest has a memorable dining experience. The atmosphere is cozy and informal, making it an inviting place to relax and enjoy your meal.

If you’re in search of the best pizza in Indianapolis, Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza is a must-visit destination. Their dedication to quality, innovative pizzas, and friendly service make it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Don’t miss the opportunity to savor their delectable offerings and experience the true essence of a great pizza place.

Iaria’s Italian Restaurant

Address: 317 S College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46202
Phone: +1 (317) 638-7706
Website: iariasrestaurant.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Immerse yourself in a delightful dining experience at Iaria’s Italian Restaurant in Indianapolis. This charming establishment offers an array of positive attributes, including a friendly and attentive staff, a cozy and nostalgic atmosphere, and a menu that showcases authentic Italian flavors. From the moment you step inside, you’ll feel the warm hospitality that has been a hallmark of Iaria’s since its opening in 1933.

The menu at Iaria’s is a treasure trove of Italian classics and house specialties. From mouthwatering pasta dishes to delectable pizzas, there is something to satisfy every craving. Indulge in the cheesy garlic bread and shrimp cocktail as starters, and then savor the flavors of the cheese tortellini in creamy tomato sauce or the fettuccini with clams. The homemade meatballs and veal dishes receive high praise from patrons, highlighting the restaurant’s commitment to quality and flavor.

The ambiance at Iaria’s is reminiscent of a classic Italian neighborhood restaurant, evoking a sense of nostalgia and comfort. Whether you choose to dine in the bar area or the cozy dining room, you’ll be treated to attentive service and a welcoming atmosphere. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure that every guest feels at home and has a memorable dining experience.

If you’re seeking an authentic Italian dining experience in Indianapolis, look no further than Iaria’s Italian Restaurant. The combination of exceptional service, flavorful cuisine, and a nostalgic ambiance creates an unforgettable visit. Whether you’re enjoying a family outing or a romantic date night, Iaria’s promises to deliver a delightful taste of Italy in the heart of the city.

Buca Di Beppo Italian Restaurant

Address: 35 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 632-2822
Website: locations.bucadibeppo.com/us/in/indianapolis/35-n-illinois-st
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Indulge in a culinary journey at Buca Di Beppo Italian Restaurant in Indianapolis, where you’ll be greeted by a friendly and attentive staff. The atmosphere is vibrant and engaging, with captivating surroundings that will keep you entertained as you await your delicious meal. The menu boasts a wide variety of mouthwatering options, served family-style, allowing you to share and savor the flavors with your loved ones.

Prepare to be amazed by the delectable dishes at Buca Di Beppo. From the Quatro Forte, featuring a delightful combination of manicotti, stuffed shells, ravioli, and chicken pasta, to the flavorful lasagna and the gluten-free options, every bite is a culinary delight. The portions are generous, ensuring that no one leaves the table hungry.

Not only does Buca Di Beppo offer exceptional food, but the service is also top-notch. The attentive and friendly staff will make you feel right at home, creating a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re visiting with a business group or enjoying a family outing, Buca Di Beppo is a perfect choice.

Discover the joy of Italian cuisine at Buca Di Beppo Italian Restaurant. From the warm and inviting atmosphere to the outstanding service and mouthwatering menu, every aspect of your dining experience will leave you wanting more. Come and create cherished memories while enjoying the flavors of Italy in the heart of Indianapolis.

Giorgio’s Pizza

Address: 9 E Market St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 687-9869
Website: giorgiospizzatogo.com
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

Immerse yourself in the flavorful world of Giorgio’s Pizza, a beloved Italian eatery in Indianapolis. With over 30 years of serving authentic New York-style pizza, Giorgio’s continues to delight patrons with their mouthwatering creations. The menu extends beyond pizza, offering a variety of simple yet delectable American Italian dishes and enticing lunch specials. Don’t miss out on their irresistible pepperoni stuffed breadsticks, a true crowd-pleaser.

Giorgio’s Pizza has become a downtown Indy lunch staple, providing a convenient and delicious option for a midday meal. Whether you dine in or opt for takeout, Giorgio’s never disappoints. The thin crust pizzas, generously topped with flavorful ingredients, are a standout. The lunch specials offer a quick and satisfying dining experience. Additionally, Giorgio’s prides itself on exceptional service, with staff members who make you feel like a valued guest.

For those seeking an authentic deep-dish pizza experience, Giorgio’s is the place to be. Known as one of the treasures of Chicago, Giorgio’s brings the same incredible taste to Indianapolis. If you’re a fan of deep-dish pizza or simply looking to expand your culinary horizons, Giorgio’s is a must-visit. They even offer frozen pizzas for you to enjoy in the comfort of your own home.

Indulge in the flavorful offerings of Giorgio’s Pizza. Whether you’re craving pizza, pasta, or a delightful slice of cheesecake, Giorgio’s has something to satisfy every palate. With friendly and passionate staff, a lively atmosphere, and generous portion sizes, Giorgio’s is sure to leave you wanting more.

Vito Provolone’s Restaurant

Address: 8031 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46217
Phone: +1 (317) 888-1112
Website: vitoprovolone.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Step into the warm and inviting atmosphere of Vito Provolone’s Restaurant, an Italian gem in Indianapolis. This bustling eatery has been delighting customers for years, with its popularity a testament to the exceptional service, delectable food, and inviting ambiance. The prices are reasonable, making every visit a true culinary “deal.” Indulge in their signature lasagna, prepared the Vito way with a touch of fennel, or savor the tantalizing “lemone” chicken pasta.

During the challenging times of COVID, Vito Provolone’s adapted by offering curbside pick-up options, ensuring that customers could still enjoy their renowned dishes, like the irresistible SMOG pizza. The sauce at Vito Provolone’s is legendary and leaves a lasting impression on every palate. The young women who handle carryout orders and greet guests with politeness and gratitude bring a delightful touch to the dining experience.

Vito Provolone’s Restaurant is a go-to destination for authentic Italian cuisine. The menu boasts a variety of mouthwatering options, from the stuffed mushrooms to the Shrimp Diablo. Each dish is meticulously prepared, leaving guests craving more. The friendly and attentive staff, along with the charming Italian atmosphere, add to the overall appeal of this family-owned establishment. Whether you’re seeking a family dinner or a special occasion meal, Vito Provolone’s is sure to exceed your expectations.

Ambrosia Restaurant

Address: Filters and Topics
Phone: +1 (317) 255-3096
Website: ambrosiaitalian.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Indulge in a delightful dining experience at Ambrosia Restaurant, a beloved Italian eatery in Indianapolis. With its traditional menu featuring an array of pasta dishes and enticing entrees, this restaurant has been a go-to destination for locals and travelers alike. The attentive and accommodating staff ensures that every guest feels welcomed and taken care of, making it an ideal spot for a romantic dinner or a family gathering. The restaurant’s commitment to quality service and cuisine shines through in every aspect of the dining experience.

Ambrosia Restaurant prides itself on its authentic recipes and flavors, providing customers with a taste of true Italian cuisine. From the mouthwatering lasagna to the delectable chicken Marsala, each dish is crafted with care and precision. The menu may lean towards the traditional side, but it never fails to impress with its rich flavors and generous portions. The restaurant also offers a well-curated wine list, allowing guests to pair their meal with the perfect selection.

The atmosphere at Ambrosia Restaurant is warm and inviting, creating a comfortable ambiance for guests to enjoy their meal. Whether you choose to dine indoors or on the shaded patio, the restaurant offers a pleasant setting to savor your Italian feast. The attention to detail extends beyond the food, with attentive management and staff who go above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. From their exceptional service to their dedication to quality, Ambrosia Restaurant stands out as a top-notch destination for Italian cuisine in Indianapolis.

Fresco Italian Cafe On The Canal

Address: 340 W Michigan St, Indianapolis, IN 46202
Phone: +1 (317) 797-9185
Website: frescoindy.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Experience the charm of Fresco Italian Cafe On The Canal, a delightful restaurant located along the scenic canal in Indianapolis. With its inviting outdoor seating and picturesque views, this hidden gem is the perfect spot for a leisurely lunch or a casual dinner. The friendly and attentive staff ensure that every visit is enjoyable, providing excellent service and making guests feel welcome.

The menu at Fresco Italian Cafe offers a variety of mouthwatering options, from delicious sandwiches and flatbread pizzas to refreshing salads and gelato. The Italian turkey sandwich and the cosmopolitan pizza are among the favorites, bursting with flavors that satisfy the taste buds. The brownie and chocolate chip cookie make for a delightful dessert, although the chocolate chip cookie can be slightly dry. The portions are generous, and the prices are reasonable, making it a great value for the quality of food.

Situated right on the canal, Fresco Italian Cafe offers a relaxing and laid-back atmosphere. Whether you choose to dine outdoors, taking in the scenic views and watching gondolas pass by, or opt for one of the cozy indoor tables, the ambiance is casual and welcoming. The cafe is known for its clean and comfortable setting, making it a favorite gathering spot for locals and visitors alike. With its combination of friendly service, tasty food, and picturesque location, Fresco Italian Cafe On The Canal is a must-visit destination in Indianapolis.


Address: 339 S Delaware St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 643-7400
Website: nesso-italia.com
Details: Restaurant

Indulge in an extraordinary dining experience at Nesso, an exceptional Italian restaurant nestled in the heart of Indianapolis. The staff at Nesso is renowned for their impeccable service, ensuring a memorable and enjoyable evening for every guest. Whether you choose to sit at the bar, where the skilled bartenders craft delightful cocktails, or opt for a cozy booth, the warm and welcoming atmosphere sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience.

The menu at Nesso is a true culinary masterpiece, featuring a delectable selection of dishes that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Start your meal with the burrata starter or the arancini appetizer, both of which are bursting with flavor. The entrees are equally impressive, with highlights including the amazing beef short rib and the agnolotti dish scented with truffles. The food is expertly prepared, showcasing a harmonious blend of flavors and high-quality ingredients.

The attention to detail extends beyond the menu, as the restaurant strives to create an ambiance that complements the exceptional cuisine. The cool vibe and stylish decor contribute to the overall experience, while the attentive staff ensures that every need is met. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply seeking a memorable evening out, Nesso is the perfect destination to savor the best of Italian cuisine in Indianapolis.

Puccini’s Pizza Pasta

Address: 1508 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260
Phone: +1 (317) 875-9223
Website: puccinispizzapasta.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Embark on a delightful culinary journey at Puccini’s Pizza Pasta, a hidden gem tucked away in an Indianapolis shopping center. The staff at Puccini’s is dedicated to delivering exceptional service, ensuring that every guest has a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re craving their mouthwatering pizzas, delectable calzones, or flavorful pasta dishes, Puccini’s menu has something for everyone.

The pizza at Puccini’s is a true standout, with a wide array of unique toppings and a crust that strikes the perfect balance between chewy and crispy. Their calzones are equally impressive, packed with delicious fillings that will leave you craving more. Vegetarian, vegan, dairy-free, and gluten-free options are available, catering to those with specific dietary needs. Puccini’s commitment to accommodating allergies and providing a diverse menu sets them apart.

Beyond the delectable food, the inviting atmosphere at Puccini’s adds to the overall dining experience. The restaurant is adorned with captivating original paintings, creating a visually appealing and vibrant ambiance. It’s no surprise that Puccini’s has garnered a loyal neighborhood following, with tables often filled and a line of eager customers waiting to indulge in their renowned pizzas. Whether you’re visiting with family or friends, Puccini’s offers a lively and enjoyable setting for all.

Prepare to be impressed by the generous and flavorful toppings, the freshness of their salads, and the friendly and efficient service. Puccini’s is not just a place for exceptional pizza, but also a destination for creating cherished memories with loved ones. So, gather your appetite and experience the tantalizing flavors that have made Puccini’s Pizza Pasta a beloved favorite in Indianapolis.

Nicolino’s Italian

Address: 2544 Executive Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46241
Phone: +1 (317) 381-6146
Website: nicolinositalian.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Indulge in a memorable dining experience at Nicolino’s Italian, located within the Wyndham hotel in Indianapolis. From the moment you step into the restaurant, the warm and attentive staff will make you feel right at home. Their dedication to providing exceptional service is evident in the positive reviews from satisfied customers. Whether you’re visiting for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, Nicolino’s offers a menu that will satisfy your cravings.

The food at Nicolino’s Italian is simply outstanding. Guests rave about the quality of the ingredients and the generous portions served. The diverse menu, which includes options from their buffet as well as à la carte selections, ensures that there’s something to please every palate. The attentive and caring staff go the extra mile to provide a truly enjoyable dining experience, making recommendations and catering to special requests.

The inviting atmosphere at Nicolino’s Italian creates a relaxed and welcoming ambiance. The restaurant’s clean and well-maintained decor, along with comfortable seating options, adds to the overall dining experience. Guests appreciate the friendly and laid-back service provided by the staff, who make them feel valued and well taken care of.

Whether you’re a hotel guest or simply looking for a delightful dining experience in the area, Nicolino’s Italian is a solid choice. From the flavorful dishes to the attentive service, this restaurant offers an excellent option for satisfying your Italian food cravings. Don’t miss the opportunity to savor their delectable cuisine and experience the warm hospitality at Nicolino’s Italian.

In conclusion, Indianapolis offers a delightful array of Italian restaurants that cater to diverse tastes and preferences. From traditional flavors to modern twists, these establishments have something for everyone. Whether you’re in the mood for mouthwatering pizzas, delectable pasta dishes, or authentic Italian desserts, the best Italian restaurants in Indianapolis deliver exceptional culinary experiences. With their warm and welcoming atmospheres, attentive staff, and dedication to quality, these restaurants ensure that every visit is a memorable one. So, the next time you find yourself craving Italian cuisine in Indianapolis, be sure to explore these top-notch establishments and indulge in a taste of Italy right in the heart of the city.