Welcome to our guide on the Best Mediterranean Restaurants in Indianapolis! If you’re craving the flavors of the Mediterranean, you’re in for a treat. Indianapolis is home to a vibrant culinary scene, and we’ve scoured the city to bring you a curated list of the finest establishments that excel in serving Mediterranean cuisine. From delectable hummus and falafel to mouthwatering kebabs and fresh seafood dishes, these restaurants are sure to satisfy your cravings. Join us as we embark on a flavorful journey through the Best Mediterranean restaurants in Indianapolis.

Earn up to 5% cashback on Restaurants!
Explore Best Credit Cards for Restaurants

Athens On 86th

Address: 2284 W 86th St West, Indianapolis, IN 46260
Phone: +1 (317) 879-8644
Website: athenson86th.com
Details: $$, Greek restaurant

Tucked away in a shopping plaza on the side of 86th Street, Athens On 86th is a hidden gem that comes highly recommended by locals and visitors alike. Reservations are a must, even on weekdays, as this Mediterranean restaurant is always bustling with eager diners. The menu boasts a traditional and solid selection of Greek dishes and beverages that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. From the saganaki and gyro special to the mouthwatering mousaka and special seafood pasta, the food at Athens On 86th is simply exceptional.

One of the standout aspects of this restaurant is its super staff, who go above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. Their helpfulness and patience make guests feel welcome and at ease. The friendly atmosphere adds to the overall charm of the place, with regulars feeling like part of the family. As you indulge in the delicious fare, you’ll be serenaded by music from the Greek Isles, enhancing the authentic dining experience.

The ambiance at Athens On 86th is relaxed and inviting, transporting you to a Greek Island getaway. The decor is interesting, and the flaming Saganaki cheese appetizers add a touch of excitement to your meal. The staff takes pride in what they serve, and their attention to detail shines through in every dish. Whether you opt for the kabobs, Greek salads, or lentil soup, you’ll be treated to fresh and flavorful fare. And be sure to save room for desserts like the heavenly baklava or the mouthwatering galactobouriko, a custard and phyllo pastry that is possibly the best dessert on the planet.

Athens On 86th is more than just a restaurant; it’s an experience that transports you to Greece through its delightful cuisine, warm atmosphere, and exceptional service. Whether you’re a seasoned fan of Greek food or a newcomer to the cuisine, this restaurant offers an extensive menu that caters to all tastes. From the moment you step through the door, you’ll be greeted like family and treated to a culinary journey that will leave you eager to return for more. Make sure to add Athens On 86th to your list of must-visit Mediterranean restaurants in Indianapolis.


Address: 15 W Main St, Carmel, IN 46032
Phone: +1 (317) 842-2724
Website: petosfamily.com
Details: $, Greek restaurant

Petos, located in Indianapolis, is a haven for those seeking delicious Greek cuisine that feels like home. Having moved from Ohio, we were thrilled to discover this gem. The menu offers a range of delectable dishes, including mouthwatering pasticio and moussaka, as well as delightful beef pastry appetizers. The portions are generous, and the flavors are authentic, prepared in-house with care and attention to detail. One highlight is the Saganaki, a traditional flaming cheese dish that adds a touch of excitement to your dining experience.

Get $25 off a bill of $50

Join inKind, dine at a participating venue
and pay your bill with inKind

Get $25 off

Upon entering Petos, you’ll be greeted with a clean and bright atmosphere, exuding warmth and hospitality. The owner and his family take great pride in ensuring every guest feels welcome and cared for. Their friendly and attentive service adds to the overall dining experience, making you feel like part of the Petos family. The decor is vibrant and eclectic, creating an inviting ambiance that enhances your enjoyment of the delicious Greek fare.

Petos is a hidden treasure located in the Castleton mall area. Although it may be a bit challenging to find, it’s well worth the effort. The restaurant offers curbside entrance and a friendly staff who are ready to assist you. Whether you’re craving their exceptional hummus, delectable Greek burgers, or any other authentic dish, Petos promises to deliver flavorful and satisfying meals. With their dedication to creating tasty and remarkable food, you’ll find yourself becoming a regular at this fantastic Greek eatery.

Taziki’s Mediterranean Cafe

Address: 4025 E 82nd St Suite 101, Indianapolis, IN 46250
Phone: +13173151125
Website: tazikis.com/location/keystone-crossing
Details: $$, Mediterranean restaurant

Taziki’s Mediterranean Cafe in Indianapolis is a delightful find for those in search of fresh and flavorful food. Whether you’re looking for a quick snack or a satisfying meal, this restaurant offers a welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff. The facility is clean and well-maintained, creating a pleasant dining environment. The staff is responsive and always ready to assist you with your order.

The menu at Taziki’s Mediterranean Cafe is filled with healthy and delicious options. From the grilled chicken feast with Greek salad to the mouthwatering chicken gyro, each dish is made with fresh ingredients and bursting with flavor. The focus on scratch-made food ensures that every bite is a delight. The restaurant takes pride in their commitment to using fresh ingredients and avoiding processed meats. This dedication to quality shines through in the fantastic flavors and great service provided.

The vegetarian options at Taziki’s Mediterranean Cafe are also worth mentioning. The menu caters to different dietary preferences, making it a versatile choice for all diners. The spacious and clean interior creates a pleasant ambiance, inviting you to sit back and enjoy your meal. Whether you’re stopping by for lunch or dinner, you’ll find a variety of enticing options to choose from. Taziki’s Mediterranean Cafe is sure to become your new favorite spot, where you can indulge in a delicious Mediterranean salad or any other tasty item from their menu.

Sultana Cafe And Hookah Bar

Address: 1107 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46202
Phone: +1 (317) 672-7000
Website: sultanaindy.com
Details: $$, Hookah bar

Sultana Cafe And Hookah Bar in Indianapolis is a hidden gem that offers a fantastic experience for those looking to enjoy hookah with friends. The friendly and attentive staff adds to the welcoming atmosphere, making your visit memorable. The highlight of one reviewer’s experience was being served by a warm, sweet, and professional staff member who went above and beyond to ensure a great Friday night.

Located on a quiet end of College Avenue near Mass Avenue, Sultana Cafe And Hookah Bar is a convenient and fantastic find. The staff is attentive and ensures you have a great time, making sure you feel comfortable and enjoy your visit. The customizable hookah options and happy hour specials during the week provide a delightful experience for hookah enthusiasts. The menu offers a variety of delectable Middle Eastern dishes, with the saganaki being particularly praised for its amazing flavor.

While initially hesitant due to the presence of hookahs and smoke, one reviewer was pleasantly surprised by the lack of smoke and thoroughly enjoyed the food. Sultana Cafe And Hookah Bar offers an amazing amount of fun, making it a top recommendation for those seeking a hookah bar in Indianapolis. From the make-your-own hookah choices to the delicious Middle Eastern cuisine and even belly dancing performances, the experience is authentic and enjoyable. The attention to detail in the decor adds to the overall ambiance, transporting you to a delightful sightseeing and dining experience.

Sultana Cafe And Hookah Bar is an awesome place with genuinely friendly staff, exceptional sangria, fresh and delicious food, and long-lasting hookah sessions. It’s a place where you can relax, enjoy the atmosphere, and have a great time with friends. The staff’s warm hospitality and the quality of the food and hookah make it a must-visit spot near Mass Ave.


Address: 339 S Delaware St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 643-7400
Website: nesso-italia.com
Details: Restaurant

Nesso, located in the Alexander Hotel in Indianapolis, is a remarkable Italian restaurant that offers an exceptional dining experience. The staff at Nesso are attentive and professional, providing top-notch service to ensure a memorable visit. The barkeeps, known for their fine cocktails, create delicious beverages and engage in friendly conversation. The inviting atmosphere of the restaurant adds to the overall dining experience.

The menu at Nesso features a variety of delectable Italian dishes that are sure to please every palate. From the amazing seafood pasta to the mouthwatering beef short rib, the food is prepared with care and skill. The burrata starter and Caesar salad receive high praise for their excellent flavors. Each dish is beautifully presented, showcasing the culinary artistry of the restaurant.

Nesso offers a fantastic wine list, with special discounts available on selected bottles. The attentive and knowledgeable staff, including a wine sommelier, provide helpful recommendations to enhance your dining experience. Whether you choose the delicious veal saltimbocca, the perfectly cooked risotto, or any other dish on the menu, you’re guaranteed a wonderful meal. The desserts are equally impressive, with options like tiramisu and ricotta donuts that are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.

Nesso, a delightful addition to the Indianapolis dining scene, combines exceptional food, great service, and a charming ambiance. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or looking for a memorable evening out, Nesso is the perfect choice for an extraordinary Italian dining experience.

In conclusion, Indianapolis boasts a vibrant culinary scene with a variety of outstanding Mediterranean restaurants to choose from. Whether you’re in the mood for authentic Greek flavors, delectable Italian dishes, or a fusion of Mediterranean cuisine, there is something for every palate. The staff at these restaurants go above and beyond to provide excellent service, creating a welcoming and enjoyable atmosphere for diners. From the warm and hospitable staff to the flavorful and diverse menus, these Mediterranean restaurants in Indianapolis are sure to leave a lasting impression and satisfy any craving for Mediterranean delights.