Best Pizza restaurants in Milwaukee [2024]

Welcome to our culinary journey through the vibrant city of Milwaukee! Today, we’re diving into the realm of gooey cheese, perfectly crisp crusts, and mouthwatering toppings. Join us as we explore the very best pizza restaurants in Milwaukee, where local pizzaiolos craft sensational pies that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. From classic Neapolitan styles to inventive gourmet creations, these eateries embody the essence of pizza perfection. Prepare for a delectable adventure as we uncover the hidden gems and beloved favorites among the best pizza restaurants in Milwaukee.

Transfer Pizzeria Café

Phone: +1 (414) 763-0438
Details: $$ – $$$, Italian, Pizza, Vegetarian Friendly

Nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, Transfer Pizzeria Café beckons pizza enthusiasts with its charming atmosphere and exceptional service. From the moment you step inside, the warm and inviting ambiance sets the stage for a memorable dining experience. The staff, well-versed in the menu offerings, provide attentive and knowledgeable service without being intrusive.

One cannot resist indulging in the array of delectable pizzas on offer. Whether you choose the classic flavors or opt for more adventurous combinations, Transfer Pizzeria Café delivers a taste sensation that leaves you craving for more. The garlic bread, a must-try, is so irresistible that you’ll find yourself tempted to savor every drop of its savory sauce.

Noteworthy among their offerings is the monthly special, expertly recommended by the servers. The dill pickle pizza, boasting a garlic sauce base and fragrant dill on top, is a delightful surprise for the taste buds. Each slice is a harmonious blend of flavors that will leave you yearning for another bite.

Besides their exceptional pizzas, Transfer Pizzeria Café caters to various dietary preferences. With vegan cheese options and gluten-free crusts, they ensure that everyone can delight in the pizza experience. Their commitment to quality ingredients and careful preparation shines through in every dish, making it a haven for pizza lovers.

With its exceptional staff, inviting atmosphere, and a menu that tantalizes the senses, Transfer Pizzeria Café stands out as one of the best pizza restaurants in Milwaukee. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, this gem of a pizzeria promises an unforgettable culinary adventure that will have you returning time and time again.

Santino’s Little Italy

Address: 352 E Stewart St, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Phone: +1 (414) 897-7367
Website: santinoslittleitaly.com
Details: $$, Restaurant

Santino’s Little Italy, located in Milwaukee, is a culinary haven that captures the essence of Italian cuisine. The moment you step inside, the inviting atmosphere envelops you, setting the stage for a memorable dining experience. The staff, known for their exceptional service, warmly welcome guests, ensuring a delightful evening awaits.

The menu at Santino’s Little Italy is a testament to the artistry of Italian cuisine. From mouthwatering pasta dishes to wood-fired pizzas, every bite is a celebration of flavor. Whether you opt for the classic Margherita pizza or indulge in their delectable feta pizza, each slice is a testament to their dedication to quality ingredients and impeccable craftsmanship.

In addition to their culinary delights, Santino’s Little Italy offers an extensive wine list, perfect for pairing with your meal. From aromatic reds to crisp whites, their selection complements the diverse flavors of the menu. Be sure to save room for their renowned tiramisu, a sweet finale that will leave you yearning for more.

Santino’s Little Italy is a gem in Milwaukee’s dining scene, where exceptional staff, a warm atmosphere, and an outstanding menu converge. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply craving authentic Italian flavors, this charming establishment promises an unforgettable experience that will have you eagerly planning your return.

National Pizza Pub & Grille

Address: 5501 W National Ave, West Milwaukee, WI 53214
Phone: +1 (414) 671-4224
Website: nationalpizzapubandgrille.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Located in Milwaukee, National Pizza Pub & Grille offers a delightful dining experience that encompasses great food, friendly staff, and a welcoming atmosphere. The menu boasts a variety of mouthwatering options, including homemade Mozzarella sticks and delectable cheesecakes with fresh raspberries. Whether you’re sitting at the bar or enjoying room service, the attentive and accommodating staff ensure a memorable dining experience.

The pub and grille, conveniently located within the Best Western hotel, provides a haven for guests seeking a satisfying meal. The reasonably priced pizzas and sizable burgers, such as the Grilled Chicken Bacon Ranch, tantalize taste buds with their flavorful combinations. The well-crafted food extends beyond the savory options, with scrumptious desserts like the creamy cheesecake stealing the show.

National Pizza Pub & Grille’s commitment to excellence is evident in their attentive service and outstanding cuisine. The late opening hours and affordable prices make it a favorite choice for families and weary travelers alike. With Matthew, the manager, ensuring a remarkable dining experience, guests can expect nothing less than superb service and exceptional food at this hidden gem in Milwaukee.

National Pizza Pub & Grille at the Best Western hotel has earned a well-deserved reputation for its outstanding food, attentive staff, and inviting ambiance. From delectable appetizers to indulgent desserts, every dish is prepared with care and served with a smile. Whether you’re a hotel guest or a local looking for a memorable dining experience, National Pizza Pub & Grille is a must-visit destination that promises to delight your taste buds and leave you wanting more.

Organ Piper Music Palace

Phone: +1 (414) 529-1177
Details: $$ – $$$, Pizza

Organ Piper Music Palace in Milwaukee is a unique and entertaining destination that combines the joy of live organ music with delicious pizza. From the moment you step inside, you’ll be captivated by the lively atmosphere and the remarkable Mighty Wurlitzer organ. The organist’s skilled hands bring the instrument to life, playing a diverse range of songs that will delight both children and adults alike.

While the music is undoubtedly a highlight, the pizza at Organ Piper is equally impressive. With a perfect balance of thin crust and flavorful toppings, their pizzas leave a lasting impression. Whether you opt for classic cheese sticks or indulge in a variety of other menu options, the food is consistently delicious and served hot.

The ambiance at Organ Piper Music Palace is a delightful throwback to a bygone era. The walls and ceiling are adorned with instruments that can be operated by the organ, creating a whimsical and entertaining setting. The venue also offers a game room for children, making it a perfect destination for families and those seeking a nostalgic afternoon of fun.

Organ Piper Music Palace is not only a place for great food and lively music but also a memorable experience. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a casual night out, this hidden gem in Milwaukee offers a unique blend of entertainment, tasty pizza, and a festive atmosphere. Don’t miss the chance to experience the joy of the Mighty Wurlitzer organ while savoring some delicious slices at Organ Piper Music Palace.

Ian’s Pizza Cream City

Phone: +1 (414) 727-9200
Details: $, Pizza, Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options

Ian’s Pizza Cream City in Milwaukee offers an incredible pizza experience with its unique and delicious creations. The Mac n Cheese and Smokey and the Bandit pizzas are particularly outstanding, with fresh and flavorful toppings that leave a lasting impression. The slices are generously sized, ensuring that every bite is satisfying. Whether you choose to dine in after a Bucks game or opt for convenient delivery to your hotel, the service is exceptional, with prompt and friendly delivery drivers and staff.

The variety of options at Ian’s Pizza Cream City is impressive, catering to different preferences and dietary needs. Gluten-free pizzas are available, and the staff is knowledgeable and helpful in assisting customers in making their selections. Alongside the pizzas, the breadsticks and salads are highly recommended, adding extra depth to the meal. The slices themselves are massive, requiring two paper plates to hold them, and they are reasonably priced considering their size and quality.

The vibrant atmosphere at Ian’s Pizza Cream City adds to the overall experience. Despite being packed, the lively vibe creates a fun and welcoming environment. The friendly and efficient staff are quick to offer suggestions and ensure a smooth and enjoyable ordering process. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Ian’s Pizza Cream City is a must-try destination that promises unique pizza slices, great service, and a memorable dining experience.

Balistreri’s Bluemound Inn

Address: 6501 W Bluemound Rd, Milwaukee, WI 53213
Phone: +1 (414) 348-5183
Website: balistreris.com
Details: $$, Restaurant

Balistreri’s Bluemound Inn in Milwaukee is a long-standing favorite, offering delicious food and excellent service. With a variety of options on their menu, the pizza stands out as a true highlight. The crust is especially noteworthy, and the abundance of toppings allows for personalized creations. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic Friday fish fry or a delectable pizza, Balistreri’s Bluemound Inn delivers on flavor and quality.

The restaurant provides a comfortable and welcoming atmosphere, with friendly staff members who ensure a pleasant dining experience. The service is attentive, and the team is polite and accommodating. In addition, during warmer weather, patrons have the option to dine outside on the inviting patio, adding to the overall enjoyment.

Balistreri’s Bluemound Inn boasts a well-stocked bar and a diverse selection of Italian appetizers. Their veal options are plentiful, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to offering a wide range of delicious dishes. The wine selection is also noteworthy, complementing the flavors of the food perfectly.

Whether you’re a longtime patron or a first-time visitor, Balistreri’s Bluemound Inn is sure to impress. From the mouthwatering pizza to the friendly atmosphere and attentive service, this establishment is a must-visit for those seeking a memorable dining experience in Milwaukee.

Ian’s Pizza Milwaukee

Address: 2035 E North Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Phone: +1 (414) 727-9200
Website: ianspizza.com
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

Ian’s Pizza Milwaukee is a haven for pizza lovers with its wide variety of flavors and toppings. From unique combinations like Ravioli, Macaroni and Cheese, Barbecue Potato, Vegan Philly Cheese, Vegan Gyro, to classics like Cheeseburger and Pepperoni, every slice is a delight. The menu offers something for everyone, ensuring that you’ll find a pizza that suits your taste buds. The prices are reasonable, making it an excellent choice for a satisfying meal.

This pizza joint stands out for its diverse selection of pizza slices. Favorites among customers include the Mac-n-Cheese and Maui Wowie, while specialty pizzas make regular appearances. The restaurant caters to vegetarians as well, with vegetarian choices and a salad bar. Ian’s Pizza Milwaukee also showcases its commitment to sustainability by using paper straws instead of plastic ones.

The ambiance at Ian’s Pizza Milwaukee is inviting and energetic, complemented by a friendly and efficient staff. Whether you opt for a single slice or a whole pie, the quality of the thin crust will impress you. With a central location, it’s a popular spot on bustling North Avenue, drawing in locals and visitors alike. Ian’s Pizza Milwaukee is a must-visit destination for pizza enthusiasts seeking a delicious and enjoyable dining experience.

Carini’s La Conca D’oro

Address: 3468 N Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53211
Phone: +1 (414) 963-9623
Website: atouchofsicily.com
Details: $$, Sicilian restaurant

Carini’s La Conca D’oro is a gem for Italian food enthusiasts in Milwaukee, offering a wide array of delicious dishes and exceptional service. The pizzas are a standout, boasting perfect crusts, delectable sauces, and a variety of mouthwatering toppings. The lasagna is a homemade delight, while the spaghetti bolognese is a standout option. The menu features an impressive selection, catering to various preferences.

Step into Carini’s, and you’ll feel like you’ve been transported to Italy. The warm and welcoming atmosphere, combined with friendly and knowledgeable staff, creates an authentic dining experience. The owner and chef often mingle with guests, ensuring their satisfaction and offering recommendations. Happy Hour specials and a diverse wine list further enhance the dining experience.

The wood-fired pizza oven, brought over from Italy, produces Neapolitan-style pizzas that rival those found in Naples itself. The attention to detail in crafting their dishes is evident, making each bite a true delight. Carini’s prides itself on being a family-owned establishment, pouring their heart and soul into delivering exceptional Italian cuisine. From the pizza to the pasta and other flavorful dishes, Carini’s La Conca D’oro is a must-visit for those seeking an authentic taste of Italy in Milwaukee.

Proof Pizza

Phone: +1 (414) 270-4433
Details: $$ – $$$, Italian, Pizza

Proof Pizza in Milwaukee offers a delightful dining experience with their delectable Neapolitan-style pizzas. The pizza at Proof is truly something to love, with a focus on fresh ingredients and perfectly crispy crusts. The toppings are thoughtfully chosen and baked to perfection, ensuring a delicious and satisfying meal. The friendly and welcoming service adds to the overall positive experience at Proof Pizza, making guests feel right at home.

Located in the lobby of the Saint Kate hotel, Proof Pizza provides a convenient and cozy atmosphere. The option of outdoor patio seating is a delightful feature, allowing guests to enjoy their pizza in a pleasant setting. The quick and friendly service ensures a seamless dining experience, while the Italian oven used to make and cook the pizzas adds a touch of authenticity and charm.

Proof Pizza not only offers exceptional pizza but also provides a variety of options beyond pizza. From appetizers like brussel sprouts to a range of pizza choices, every dish is crafted with fresh and flavorful ingredients. The quality of the cheese and toppings is evident, creating a truly delicious pizza experience. The affordability of the menu is another highlight, making Proof Pizza a great choice for those looking for high-quality food without breaking the bank.

Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite before a show or seeking a fast-casual option, Proof Pizza is a must-visit destination in downtown Milwaukee. The imported Italian pizza oven and the expertise of the chefs ensure that each pizza is cooked to perfection. With a range of toppings and a fluffy crust, the pizza at Proof is sure to satisfy any pizza lover. Don’t miss the opportunity to indulge in their superb pizzas and experience the delightful flavors they offer.

Lisa’s Pizzeria

Phone: +1 (414) 332-6360
Details: $$ – $$$, Italian, Pizza, Vegetarian Friendly

Lisa’s Pizzeria in Milwaukee is a must-visit destination for pizza enthusiasts. With over 55 years of history, Lisa’s has established itself as a local favorite. The pizza here is simply outstanding, with a thin and crispy crust that perfectly complements the flavorful toppings. The sauce, known for its delightful sweetness, is a highlight that keeps customers coming back for more. Lisa’s also offers a range of other Italian dishes, ensuring there’s something for everyone.

The atmosphere at Lisa’s Pizzeria is warm and inviting, with a touch of old-school charm. The restaurant has maintained its original character while incorporating updates to enhance the dining experience. The service is charming and attentive, with a friendly staff that adds to the welcoming atmosphere. Prices are fair, making it an excellent choice for those seeking quality food without breaking the bank. Whether you choose to dine in or opt for takeout, the delicious pizza from Lisa’s will not disappoint.

Lisa’s Pizzeria is a family-run establishment, adding a personal touch to the dining experience. The dedication to quality and customer satisfaction is evident in every aspect of the restaurant. The menu offers a variety of pizza options, along with appetizers and drinks. From the homemade salad dressings to the killer eggplant appetizer, each dish is prepared with care and attention to detail. The positive reviews from loyal customers speak volumes about the consistency and excellence of Lisa’s Pizzeria.

If you’re in Milwaukee and looking for a place to indulge in exceptional pizza, Lisa’s Pizzeria is the perfect choice. The down-to-earth feel of the restaurant combined with the mouthwatering flavors of their pizzas will leave you impressed. With the perfect balance of sauce, crust, and toppings, each bite is a delight. Supporting this local gem is not only a treat for your taste buds but also a way to preserve the tradition of this beloved East Side establishment.

Dom & Phil Demarinis Original Recipes

Address: 1211 E Conway St, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Phone: +1 (414) 481-2348
Website: domandphildemarinis.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes in Milwaukee is a must-visit pizzeria that has been delighting customers for decades. With a history spanning over 50 years, this family-run establishment has perfected the art of pizza-making. The pizza here is simply outstanding, with a thin and crispy crust that is generously topped with flavorful ingredients. Whether you opt for the classic combination of cheese, sausage, mushrooms, and onions or try their other specialty pizzas, you won’t be disappointed. The sauce and cheese are like no other, delivering a truly memorable flavor experience.

The welcoming atmosphere at Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes adds to the charm of the dining experience. The staff, including the owners Phil and Lucia, are known for their friendly and attentive service, making every customer feel like part of the family. The pizzeria has adapted well to the current times, with safety measures in place to ensure a comfortable dining experience. Their outdoor seating area offers a picturesque view of the Milwaukee skyline, adding to the overall ambiance.

Beyond the outstanding pizza, Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes also offers a range of delicious Italian dishes. From homemade salad dressings to mouthwatering appetizers, the menu caters to a variety of tastes. The commitment to quality is evident in every dish, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re craving pizza, pasta, or other Italian specialties, this pizzeria has something to satisfy every appetite.

If you’re searching for exceptional pizza in Milwaukee, look no further than Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes. Their time-tested recipes, warm hospitality, and commitment to quality have made them a beloved institution in the city. From the first bite to the last, you’ll savor the flavors and appreciate the care and craftsmanship that goes into each pizza. Make sure to add this pizzeria to your must-visit list when in Milwaukee.

In conclusion, Milwaukee is a city that takes its pizza seriously, and there are several outstanding pizzerias that have become local favorites. From the traditional thin-crust classics to innovative creations with unique toppings, these pizza restaurants offer a wide range of flavors to satisfy every palate. Whether you’re a fan of Neapolitan-style, deep-dish, or New York-style pizza, you’re sure to find a slice that will leave you craving more. So, the next time you’re in Milwaukee, be sure to check out these top pizza spots and indulge in some of the city’s best pizza. Your taste buds will thank you!