Best Pizza restaurants in Tampa [2024]

Welcome to our culinary adventure through the vibrant city of Tampa, Florida, as we uncover the absolute Best Pizza restaurants in Tampa. Nestled within this bustling city are pizzerias that are renowned for their mouthwatering creations and impeccable flavors. From traditional Italian establishments that have stood the test of time to innovative spots pushing the boundaries of pizza perfection, we have scoured the streets to bring you a curated list of Tampa’s finest pizza destinations. Get ready to embark on a delicious journey that will satisfy your cravings and leave you craving more.

Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria

Address: 514 N Franklin St STE 101, Tampa, FL 33602
Phone: +1 (813) 868-4440
Website: bavarospizza.com/bavaros-tampa
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Nestled in Tampa, Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria is a true gem, offering an exceptional dining experience for pizza enthusiasts and Italian food lovers alike. The cozy and inviting atmosphere sets the stage for an unforgettable meal. From the moment you step in, the friendly and knowledgeable staff are there to assist you in navigating the menu and make your dining experience extraordinary.

Prepare your taste buds for a delightful journey through their extensive menu. Bavaro’s pizza, cooked to perfection in their wood-fired oven, is nothing short of amazing. The dough, prepared with passion, is a highlight that will leave you craving more. The menu also extends beyond pizza, featuring an array of delectable pasta dishes, such as the Penne al la vodka and the flavorsome Ravioli fromage. Fresh ingredients and attention to detail make each dish a culinary masterpiece.

The positive reviews keep pouring in, with guests raving about the exceptional service provided by the attentive staff. From the moment you enter, the team at Bavaro’s goes above and beyond to ensure that your dining experience is nothing short of extraordinary. Whether it’s the friendly servers like Kendall or the newly appointed General Manager, Aisha, the dedicated team exemplifies top-notch service and creates a welcoming environment for every guest.

Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria is a hidden culinary treasure in Tampa. Located off the beaten path, it’s worth the short Uber ride to indulge in their wood oven pizza and explore the delectable flavors of their menu. The quaint and cozy atmosphere, combined with the mouthwatering dishes, makes Bavaro’s a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts seeking an authentic Italian experience. So, venture out and savor the best pizza and pasta Tampa has to offer at Bavaro’s.

New York New York Pizza – Ybor City

Address: 1512 E 7th Ave, Tampa, FL 33605
Phone: +1 (813) 248-1845
Website: nynypizzeria.com
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

Nestled in Ybor City, New York New York Pizza is a hidden gem that delights pizza lovers with its authentic flavors and excellent service. Despite the limited parking options, the food at this family restaurant is worth the minor inconvenience. The friendly and attentive staff create a welcoming atmosphere that enhances the dining experience.

Known for its New York-style pizza, New York New York Pizza truly lives up to its name. The crisp crust and San Marzano tomato sauce make each bite a delight. The restaurant offers a variety of toppings, from classic pepperoni to unique combinations, satisfying even the most discerning pizza connoisseurs. The menu also extends beyond pizza, with delicious pasta dishes and mouthwatering burgers that are sure to please every palate.

Visitors rave about the fast delivery service and the consistently high quality of the food. The pizzas are cheesy and packed with flavor, while the Stromboli and pasta dishes showcase the culinary expertise of the kitchen. The reasonable prices and cool, friendly staff add to the overall appeal of this establishment. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, make sure to visit New York New York Pizza in Ybor City for a pizza experience that will leave you craving more.

Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza

Address: 1901 S Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33629-5816
Phone: +1 (813) 258-2625
Website: acfp.com
Details: $$ – $$$, Italian, Pizza, Vegetarian Friendly

Located in Tampa, Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza is a go-to destination for pizza lovers in search of delicious flavors and excellent service. Whether dining in or ordering for delivery, guests are consistently delighted by the outstanding quality of the food. The pizzas are described as “DELICIOUS” and “amazing,” with a well-done crust cooked in their intensely hot oven, and a sauce made from sweet chunks of tomatoes. The toppings, such as Kalamata olives, bacon, and various classic combinations, add to the exceptional taste. The friendly and engaging staff, including servers like Laura and Jessica, provide attentive and professional service, going above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience.

The atmosphere at Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza is described as great for a relaxed night out with family or a casual date night. With individual-size pizzas available, guests have the flexibility to customize their orders to their preferences. The menu offers a variety of options, including vegan choices like cauliflower pizza, accommodating different dietary preferences. The restaurant’s commitment to customer satisfaction is evident in instances where mistakes were made, as the staff promptly corrected them, demonstrating a dedication to providing excellent service.

From their signature coal-fired pizza to the mouthwatering wings and slow-roasted options, Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza offers a wide range of delicious dishes. The positive reviews consistently mention the outstanding food quality, friendly service, and overall enjoyable dining experience. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza is a must-visit destination for pizza enthusiasts seeking exceptional flavors and a warm, inviting atmosphere.

Lee’s Grocery

Address: 2210 N Central Ave, Tampa, FL 33602
Phone: +1 (813) 374-0179
Website: facebook.com/pages/Lees-Grocery/220345264683299
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Nestled in a historic neighborhood on a quiet street, Lee’s Grocery is a hidden gem that offers a delightful combination of craft beer and delectable pizza. The unassuming old storefront may go unnoticed at first glance, but the line of cars parked along the street is a testament to its popularity. Inside, you’ll find a cozy dining area and bar adorned with coolers stocked with an eclectic selection of local and national brews, providing a wide range of options for beer enthusiasts. The bar also features a rotating tap, ensuring a new and exciting brew to try on every visit.

While the beer selection is impressive, it’s the pizza that steals the show at Lee’s Grocery. The thin crust, cooked to perfection, serves as the foundation for pies that are generously loaded with toppings. The variety of options and high-quality ingredients make these pizzas stand out from the crowd. With limited seating indoors, the outdoor patio provides a pleasant alternative for guests to enjoy their meal when the weather permits.

Visitors rave about the great food, craft beer, and inviting ambiance of Lee’s Grocery. The attentive and friendly service, coupled with the family-friendly atmosphere, make it a favorite spot for many. The reasonable prices and charming inner-city charm add to the overall appeal. Whether you’re seeking a unique pizza experience or looking to explore an extensive selection of craft beer, Lee’s Grocery is a must-visit destination in Tampa.

Sally O’Neal’s Pizza Hotline

Address: 1319 S Howard Ave, Tampa, FL 33606
Phone: +1 (813) 251-0220
Website: sallyonealspizza.com
Details: Pizza restaurant

Located in Tampa, Sally O’Neal’s Pizza Hotline is a hidden gem that has been delighting visitors with its outstanding pizza for over 30 years. The menu boasts an impressive selection of pizzas, including the highly recommended Chicago Style Deep Dish. With a focus on quality ingredients and attention to detail, their pizzas are praised for their flavorful toppings, delicious crust, and generous portions. The thin crust option is reminiscent of New York-style pizza, while the deep-dish offers a unique and satisfying experience.

Aside from their excellent pizza, Sally O’Neal’s also offers delectable breadsticks and a flavorful Greek salad that perfectly complements the meal. The friendly and attentive service adds to the overall dining experience, making it a great place for families and pizza enthusiasts alike. The cozy atmosphere and pizza-joint feel create a welcoming and enjoyable ambiance.

Visitors often express their surprise and delight at discovering Sally O’Neal’s Pizza Hotline, considering it a hidden treasure in Tampa. The combination of high-quality food, reasonable prices, and friendly service make it a must-visit destination for pizza lovers. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by Sally O’Neal’s and indulge in their mouthwatering pizzas and other delicious offerings.

Mangia Bene Pizzeria

Address: 1811 N 15th St UNIT D, Tampa, FL 33605
Phone: +1 (813) 248-2929
Website: mangiabenepizzamenu.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Mangia Bene Pizzeria, located in Ybor City, stands out as one of the finest pizza establishments in Tampa. Their commitment to excellence is evident in every aspect, from their top-notch customer service to the outstanding quality of their menu. With a traditional style oven typically found in the heart of NYC, their pizzas are perfection, made with the freshest locally sourced ingredients.

From the moment you step into Mangia Bene, you’ll be greeted by a helpful and knowledgeable staff who will gladly assist with any dietary preferences, such as vegan options. The owner’s dedication to maintaining a pristine and tidy restaurant is apparent, ensuring a clean and inviting atmosphere for all guests. The menu offers a wide variety of choices, with each dish made with precision and excellence.

Whether you choose to dine in or order online, Mangia Bene Pizzeria consistently delivers on their promise of delicious food and exceptional service. Open late, they cater to those late-night cravings, providing fast and efficient delivery. The Philly Cheese Steak Calzone receives high praise, along with their delectable pizza and flavorful wings. It’s no wonder that locals and visitors alike consider Mangia Bene their go-to pizza place in Tampa.

In summary, Mangia Bene Pizzeria is a must-visit for pizza lovers in Ybor City. Their commitment to quality, friendly staff, and mouthwatering menu make for an unforgettable dining experience. Whether you’re enjoying a slice of their famous pizza, savoring their delicious pasta, or indulging in their tempting calzones, Mangia Bene is sure to leave you craving more.

Forbici Modern Italian

Address: 1633 W Snow Ave, Tampa, FL 33606
Phone: +1 (813) 251-8001
Website: eatforbici.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Forbici Modern Italian in Hyde Park Village is a true gem when it comes to modern Italian cuisine in Tampa. The menu offers a diverse range of options, from classic pizzas to vegan dishes, ensuring there is something for everyone. The staff is friendly and attentive, providing excellent service that adds to the overall dining experience.

The restaurant’s atmosphere is cozy and inviting, with both indoor and outdoor seating available. The outdoor seating area is particularly enjoyable, allowing guests to relax and soak in the vibrant energy of Hyde Park Village. The live music adds an extra touch of ambiance to the dining experience.

When it comes to the food, Forbici Modern Italian truly shines. The pizzas are outstanding, with a perfect balance of chewy dough and flavorful toppings. The grain bowl, featuring black rice, grilled broccolini, and mushrooms, is a delightful choice for those looking for a healthier option. The calamari, meatballs, and charcuterie plate are also highly recommended as appetizers.

Whether you’re seeking a casual lunch, a romantic dinner, or a special celebration, Forbici Modern Italian is a fantastic choice. Their dedication to providing delicious food, friendly service, and a comfortable atmosphere make it a standout Italian restaurant in Tampa.

Viva Napoli

Address: 4301 W El Prado Blvd, Tampa, FL 33629
Phone: +1 (813) 443-8500
Website: vivanapolitampa.com
Details: $$, Restaurant

Viva Napoli is a hidden gem in a small neighborhood, offering delicious pizza and pasta that shouldn’t be missed. Their Nutella pizza for dessert is a must-try. While the calamari may be average, the overall menu is diverse and offers something for everyone. The portions are generous, making it a great place to share and try multiple dishes.

The authenticity of Viva Napoli’s Italian cuisine sets it apart. The wood-fired stone pizza oven produces some of the best pizza in Tampa, impressing even those with high standards. The menu showcases specialized ravioli, gnocchi, and other Italian classics, all executed with excellence. The lasagna, in particular, stands out as a customer favorite.

The owner’s Neapolitan roots are evident in the flavors and hospitality at Viva Napoli. The Italian hospitality is matched by the Sicilian chef’s amazing dishes and the wood-fired pizza oven, which adds an extra touch of authenticity. The warm and inviting atmosphere, coupled with attentive staff, ensures a memorable dining experience.

In summary, Viva Napoli offers an authentic taste of Napoli-style cuisine in Tampa. From their fantastic pizza, cooked in a traditional wood-fired oven, to their superb pasta dishes, every bite is a delight. The friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere make it a must-visit restaurant for those craving genuine Italian flavors.

Ledo Pizza

Address: 14432 N Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33618
Phone: +18139645700
Website: order.ledopizza.com/menu/ledo-pizza-tampa
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

Ledo Pizza is a go-to pizza parlor with a fantastic thin crust that keeps customers coming back. The use of provolone instead of mozzarella cheese adds a unique twist to their pizzas. The owners are actively involved in running the restaurant and make an effort to strike up friendly conversations with their patrons, creating a welcoming atmosphere. The menu offers more than just pizza, with delicious options like calzones, salads, wings, and fries that are equally satisfying.

Ledo’s pizza is known for its exceptional quality and taste. Visitors from Maryland, where the original restaurant is located, praise the Tampa location for its authenticity and ability to recreate the same flavors they love. The square pan pizza, topped with a thick slice of pepperoni on each cut, is a standout item. Customers often buy cases of their sauce, which is highly regarded and a favorite among loyal fans. The crust, in particular, is a favorite component, and many customers can’t resist devouring the four corners of the pizza.

Dining at Ledo Pizza is not just about the food; it’s also about the overall experience. The friendly and attentive service, clean restaurant, and familiar atmosphere make customers feel right at home. Whether you’re enjoying a cold draft beer, a flavorful Italian salad, or indulging in their signature pizza, Ledo Pizza offers a consistently satisfying dining experience that keeps customers returning time and time again.

Gourmet Pizza Company

Address: 610 S Armenia Ave, Tampa, FL 33609
Phone: +1 (813) 258-1999
Website: gourmetpizza-company.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Gourmet Pizza Company is a delightful restaurant known for its excellent pizzas and wide variety of options, including gluten-free and vegan choices. The staff is knowledgeable and accommodating, particularly when it comes to dietary restrictions and cross-contamination concerns. The owner personally engages with customers, demonstrating a genuine understanding of Celiacs and offering complimentary desserts as a kind gesture. The crust of their pizzas is thin, yet perfectly crisp with a slight chewiness on the inside, making it a standout feature.

The flavor combinations and quality of ingredients at Gourmet Pizza Company are exceptional. Customers rave about the pesto vegan pizza and the Portobello mushroom pizza, which showcase the delicious possibilities of vegetarian and vegan offerings. The menu caters to various dietary preferences, with unique options like a spicy Cajun Crawfish with Escargot Pizza and a Southwestern pizza with a black bean and corn base. The infusion of olive oils adds extra depth and flavor to the pizzas. Despite the basic decor, the focus on delivering unreal pizzas with fresh ingredients sets this restaurant apart.

Visiting Gourmet Pizza Company is well worth the trip, even if it involves a significant distance. Customers are willing to travel for the freshest, tastiest, and most savory pizzas in town. The quality and variety of pizzas, such as the five-cheese and cacciatore options, along with the generous portions of calzones, make it an irresistible choice for pizza lovers. The restaurant also offers gluten-free options, including a delicious mushroom pizza, and fresh salad mixes. With outstanding pizza, delicious desserts, and unlimited fountain drink refills, Gourmet Pizza Company remains a hidden gem cherished by the locals.

Best NY Pizza

Address: 14741 N Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33618
Phone: +1 (813) 963-7600
Website: bestnypizza.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Best NY Pizza is a beloved pizza place known for its reasonable prices and flavorful food. Unlike chain restaurants, their pizza has a distinct crust style and is packed with fresh ingredients and generous toppings, making it a favorite among customers. The calzones, although sometimes requiring a bit of a wait, are worth it. The staff is friendly and provides excellent service, creating a welcoming atmosphere for all patrons.

As a New York native, one customer attests to the authenticity of Best NY Pizza, having tasted countless pizza places claiming to offer NY-style pizza. Another customer, who received a gift certificate, initially had reservations about the name but was pleasantly surprised by the quality of the pizza. The restaurant has gained a reputation for serving the best NY pizza in Tampa, even surpassing some of the pizza joints in NYC itself. The menu extends beyond pizza, offering a full range of Italian dinner options, and the cannoli desserts are highly recommended.

Customers appreciate the large dining area, perfect for families, and the reasonable prices for their delicious pizza. With the perfect amount of sauce and awesome cheese, the pizza at Best NY Pizza has reminded patrons of the authentic taste of NY pizza. The toppings are plentiful, and options like a half-white and half-red pizza or a sausage and mushroom pizza showcase the variety and quality of their offerings. While the garlic knots may have been a bit bread-heavy for some, the overall experience and the chance to try other menu items like stromboli and zeppoli make it a place worth returning to.

Hampton Station Pizza & Beer

Address: 5921 N Nebraska Ave, Tampa, FL 33604
Phone: +1 (813) 238-1114
Website: clover.com/online-ordering/hampton-station-brews-tampa
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

Hampton Station Pizza & Beer is a local hangout known for its friendly atmosphere and wonderful food. Customers rave about the great pizza, wings, calzones, salads, and chili available at this neighborhood gem. The beer selection is impressive, complementing the delicious food perfectly. The restaurant offers both indoor and outdoor seating, with live music adding to the enjoyable ambiance. One standout feature of Hampton Station is its adult-only policy, providing a relaxed and laid-back environment for patrons to unwind and socialize.

The pizza at Hampton Station receives high praise, with customers mentioning the excellent crust and flavorful toppings. The wings are also a favorite, with the sweet Thai-chili flavor being particularly popular. The rotating beer selection is highly regarded, appealing to craft beer enthusiasts. The service is consistently friendly, and bartenders are known for their attentiveness and hospitality. Customers appreciate the unique setting of Hampton Station, which is housed in a converted old gas station, and enjoy the overall aesthetic and vibe of the place.

Overall, Hampton Station Pizza & Beer has established itself as a go-to spot in Tampa for delicious pizza, great wings, and an impressive beer selection. With its inviting atmosphere, friendly staff, and quality food and beverages, it has become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Whether it’s for a casual hangout, a Sunday NFL game viewing, or a relaxing post-work outing, Hampton Station offers a memorable dining experience.

New York New York Pizza – Westchase

Address: 11203 Sheldon Rd, Tampa, FL 33626
Phone: +1 (813) 926-6969
Website: nynypizzeria.com
Details: Pizza restaurant

New York New York Pizza – Westchase is an awesome pizzeria that offers an authentic and unprecedented dining experience. The portions are generous, the food is excellent, and the menu is filled with delicious options. The pizza is especially noteworthy, with a NY-style crust that is fast and fresh. Customers rave about the Supreme pizza, which is described as amazing. Whether you choose to dine in or have it delivered, the quality and taste of the pizza are consistently top-notch.

In addition to their outstanding pizza, New York New York Pizza – Westchase also offers other tasty options, such as pasta dishes and Greek salads. Customers highly recommend the Greek Salad, which pairs perfectly with the pizza. What sets this pizzeria apart is not only the quality of their food but also their exceptional service. The staff, including the friendly delivery drivers, go above and beyond to ensure a positive and enjoyable dining experience. Their attentiveness and upbeat attitude leave a lasting impression on customers, making them feel appreciated and satisfied.

Amidst a sea of mediocre pizza places, New York New York Pizza – Westchase stands out as a beacon of true NY-style pizza. Customers express their gratitude for having a place that serves real pizza and surpasses the offerings of chain pizzerias. The quality of the pizza is consistently good, and the salads are also highly regarded. The English-speaking staff members make the ordering process smooth and pleasant. For those seeking an authentic taste of New York, this pizzeria is the go-to destination.

Chubby’s Super Subs & Pizza

Address: 5023 Bayshore Blvd, Tampa, FL 33611
Phone: +1 (813) 831-5557
Website: ChubbysTampa.com
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

Chubby’s Super Subs & Pizza is a must-visit destination for pizza and subs in South Tampa. Their homemade and fresh pizzas stand out from the chain restaurants, offering a variety of choices including standard, white, and vegetarian options. The subs are also homemade and authentic, with highlights such as the delicious steak bomb available in both beef and turkey. For those seeking a meatless option, the hot veggie sub is a delightful choice. With over 10 years of being a loyal customer, it’s evident that Chubby’s consistently delivers satisfying meals and has never disappointed.

This small sub and pizza place on Bayshore Dr. offers incredible dishes that cater to a variety of tastes. From pizza and Greek salads to steak bombs and Philly steak and cheese subs, every bite is truly enjoyable. The friendly staff provides excellent service and accommodates special requests. Whether dining in or ordering at the counter, the attention to detail and quality of the food at Chubby’s Super Subs & Pizza are exceptional. It’s no wonder why customers love this place and keep coming back for their delicious offerings.

Located in the Ballast Point section of South Tampa, Chubby’s Super Subs & Pizza is a local gem that satisfies cravings for mouthwatering sandwiches, Italian dinner entrees, salads, and more. The warm atmosphere and attentive service make it a perfect spot to enjoy a cold draft beer and indulge in a flavorful Philly cheesesteak. The menu offers a good variety of options, and the prices are reasonable. Whether it’s the fresh and tasty sandwiches, the well-balanced pizza with just the right amount of sauce, or the inviting garlic bread bites, Chubby’s Super Subs & Pizza offers a delightful dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more.

Pizza Hut

Address: 4011 E Busch Blvd, Tampa, FL 33617-5933
Phone: +1 (813) 985-2297
Website: locations.pizzahut.com/fl/tampa/4011-e-busch-blvd
Details: $, Pizza

Pizza Hut is a great place to dine, with friendly staff and delicious food. The service was excellent, and the staff made the dining experience enjoyable. The location is conveniently close to Busch Gardens, making it a convenient choice for visitors to the park. The food is priced well, offering good value for the quality and portion sizes.

One customer, who was traveling alone from London, had a wonderful experience at Pizza Hut. They decided to visit the restaurant instead of buying expensive food at the park. The waitress provided great service, helping them understand the menu and making them feel welcome. The availability of free WiFi allowed them to stay connected with friends and family back home. The customer even made friends with two of the workers, who made their visit memorable with their hospitality.

For families visiting Busch Gardens, Pizza Hut is a fantastic option to feed the kids. The pizza is delicious, and the prices are affordable. The prompt and friendly service provided by the waitress enhanced the dining experience. Despite the neighborhood being a bit run down, Pizza Hut offers a budget-friendly option to enjoy a meal without breaking the bank.

Overall, Pizza Hut offers good food and exceptional service. The staff goes the extra mile to accommodate customers and ensure a pleasant dining experience. Whether you’re on a time constraint or simply looking for a place to feed the family, Pizza Hut delivers on both taste and service.

In conclusion, Tampa boasts a vibrant pizza scene with a variety of outstanding options to satisfy any pizza lover’s cravings. From authentic New York-style slices to unique gourmet creations, the city offers a diverse range of flavors and styles. Whether you prefer thin crust or deep dish, traditional toppings or innovative combinations, Tampa’s best pizza restaurants have got you covered. With their skilled chefs, friendly staff, and inviting atmospheres, these establishments deliver not only delicious pizzas but also memorable dining experiences. So, next time you find yourself in Tampa, be sure to explore these top pizza spots and indulge in the city’s pizza paradise.