Welcome to the gastronomic haven of Indianapolis, where carnivorous cravings are taken to new heights at the Best Steakhouses in Indianapolis. This city boasts a delectable array of dining establishments that have perfected the art of grilling the juiciest, most succulent cuts of meat. Whether you’re a steak connoisseur or a casual enthusiast, prepare to embark on a culinary adventure as we unveil the prime destinations that serve up unrivaled flavors, impeccable service, and an unforgettable dining experience. Let’s sink our teeth into the sizzling world of Indianapolis’ Best Steakhouses!

Earn up to 5% cashback on Restaurants!
Explore Best Credit Cards for Restaurants

Tony’s Of Indianapolis

Address: 110 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 638-8669
Website: tonysofindianapolis.com
Details: $$$$, Steak house

Tony’s of Indianapolis is an exceptional steakhouse that has garnered a remarkable reputation, evident from its multitude of five-star reviews. Located in downtown Indianapolis, this upscale establishment offers an exquisite dining experience that surpasses expectations. The staff exudes warmth and attentiveness, ensuring that every guest feels well-cared for throughout their visit. The menu boasts a diverse selection of delectable options, catering to various palates.

From the moment you step into Tony’s, you’ll be captivated by its elegant atmosphere. With private rooms available for a more intimate experience, the restaurant truly goes the extra mile to enhance your dining pleasure. The appetizers, such as the colossal shrimp cocktail, tantalize the taste buds with their generous portions and flavorful accompaniments. The steak offerings are nothing short of exceptional, with each cut cooked to perfection, leaving patrons in awe of the melt-in-your-mouth tenderness and rich marbling. And let’s not forget the delectable sides, like the creamy mashed potatoes and delightful Brussels sprouts, which elevate the meal to new heights.

In addition to the impeccable service and mouthwatering dishes, Tony’s also offers an enchanting ambiance. The soothing melodies of the live jazz trio on Friday and Saturday evenings create the perfect backdrop for a memorable dining experience. While Tony’s may be a splurge, the exceptional quality and attention to detail make it well worth the investment, whether for a special occasion or simply to indulge in culinary excellence. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to savor the extraordinary delights that Tony’s of Indianapolis has to offer.

St. Elmo Steak House

Address: 127 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225
Phone: +1 (317) 635-0636
Website: stelmos.com
Details: $$$$, Steak house

St. Elmo Steak House, located in downtown Indianapolis, is an iconic establishment that offers an unforgettable dining experience. The wait staff’s extensive knowledge of steaks and the menu showcases their expertise in the field, ensuring a remarkable culinary journey. The steak selection is exceptional, with each cut cooked to perfection, while the shrimp cocktail stands out as a must-try appetizer. The restaurant’s throwback atmosphere adds to the charm, creating a delightful ambiance that complements the dining experience.

As you step into St. Elmo’s, you are transported back in time to an era of elegance and sophistication. The impeccable service strikes a perfect balance between attentiveness and allowing guests to enjoy their meal at their own pace. The servers are friendly and knowledgeable, making your dining experience even more enjoyable. The signature shrimp cocktail, renowned for its sinus-clearing spiciness, leaves a lasting impression. The steaks, whether it’s the aged sirloin strip or the porterhouse, are cooked to perfection, ensuring a melt-in-your-mouth experience. The delectable sides, such as the baked potatoes and onion straws, further enhance the meal.

Get $25 off a bill of $50

Join inKind, dine at a participating venue
and pay your bill with inKind

Get $25 off

While St. Elmo’s is a pricier option, the quality of the atmosphere, service, and food justifies the cost. The restaurant exudes a lively and elegant vibe, capturing the essence of a bygone era. The well-crafted cocktails, like the renowned Pop’s Old Fashioned, add to the overall experience. The attention to detail, from the warm hospitality to the expertly cooked steaks, makes St. Elmo’s a must-visit destination in Indianapolis. It’s a place where you can savor exceptional cuisine, enjoy a vibrant atmosphere, and create lasting memories.

Ruth’s Chris Steak House

Address: 45 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 633-1313
Website: ruthschrisphg.com/indianapolis-downtown
Details: $$$$, Steak house

Ruth’s Chris Steak House in Indianapolis offers an exceptional dining experience that leaves a lasting impression. From the moment you step into the upscale atmosphere, you’ll feel the romantic appeal and the sense of dining at a top-tier establishment. The renowned reputation of this steakhouse speaks for itself, evident in its numerous five-star reviews and top rankings.

The food at Ruth’s Chris lives up to expectations, with steaks that are cooked to perfection, delivering a tender and flavorful experience. The menu offers a variety of sides, but the mashed potatoes and mushrooms come highly recommended. The prix fixe menu provides excellent value for those seeking a more budget-friendly option. While dining at Ruth’s Chris may come at a higher cost, the memories created are well worth it.

The staff at Ruth’s Chris Steak House goes above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. From the warm welcome to the knowledgeable and attentive service, every detail is carefully attended to. The bartenders offer expert guidance on drink selections, adding to the overall enjoyment. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for an exceptional meal, Ruth’s Chris is a great choice.

Overall, Ruth’s Chris Steak House in Indianapolis offers a splendid dining experience. The quality of the food, the professional service, and the pleasant atmosphere make it a top-notch steakhouse. It’s a destination that leaves a lasting impression and one that you’ll want to revisit again and again.

Prime 47- Indy’s Steakhouse

Address: 47 S Pennsylvania St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 624-0720
Website: steakhouseindianapolis.com
Details: $$$$, Steak house

Prime 47- Indy’s Steakhouse in Indianapolis is a hidden gem that delivers an outstanding dining experience. Whether you’re visiting for a date night, a celebration, or a business meal, Prime 47 offers a quiet and elegant atmosphere that sets the stage for a memorable evening. With its extensive selection of cuts and grades, this steakhouse caters to steak enthusiasts, serving only the highest quality prime beef. The kitchen excels in preparation, ensuring each steak is cooked to perfection. The menu also offers a wide range of non-steak options, including delicious seafood dishes like the sea bass.

Aside from the exceptional food, Prime 47 prides itself on its attentive and friendly staff. The service is top-notch, with staff members who take personal care to ensure that every guest feels well taken care of. The servers are knowledgeable about the menu and can provide recommendations for the perfect dining experience. The attention to detail and genuine hospitality create a welcoming atmosphere that leaves a lasting impression.

In addition to the impressive food and service, Prime 47 offers a variety of appetizers, sides, and desserts that complement the main course perfectly. From the flavorful scallops and the au gratin potato side with a hint of jalapeño to the mouthwatering bread pudding, each dish is crafted with care and attention to detail. The menu also includes an extensive drink list, featuring a variety of mixed drinks that add to the overall enjoyment of the meal.

In conclusion, Prime 47- Indy’s Steakhouse is a standout destination for steak lovers and food enthusiasts alike. With its prime-grade beef, diverse menu options, elegant atmosphere, and attentive service, it guarantees a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re indulging in a perfectly cooked steak, savoring delectable appetizers, or enjoying a delightful dessert, Prime 47 offers a complete culinary journey that will satisfy your taste buds and leave you wanting to return for more.

Sullivan’s Steakhouse

Address: 3316 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Phone: +13175801280
Website: sullivanssteakhouse.com/indianapolis
Details: $$$, Steak house

Sullivan’s Steakhouse in Indianapolis offers an exceptional dining experience with its attentive staff, inviting atmosphere, and tantalizing menu. From the moment you arrive, the team ensures that your evening is nothing short of excellent. The service is impeccable, with multiple team members going above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. Start your meal with the delectable steak egg rolls, a scrumptious appetizer that sets the tone for a delightful culinary journey. The menu features a variety of options, including salads, bisques, and mouthwatering steak and seafood dishes. Pair your meal with their perfectly crafted drinks for a complete dining experience.

When visiting Sullivan’s, be prepared for outstanding service and attention to detail. The staff goes the extra mile to make each guest feel special and cared for. Whether it’s celebrating an achievement or enjoying a family dinner, Sullivan’s ensures that every occasion is memorable. The servers are knowledgeable, attentive, and create a warm and friendly atmosphere. The restaurant’s commitment to providing an exceptional experience is evident in the quality of their food and the professionalism of their staff.

Sullivan’s Steakhouse is a go-to destination for steak lovers and those looking for a remarkable dining experience. With its updated menu and refreshing ambiance, Sullivan’s delights guests with perfectly cooked steaks, tantalizing appetizers, and delectable desserts. Whether you choose a classic steak option or venture into other mains like Ahi Tuna or pork chops, you can expect outstanding flavor and presentation. The attention to detail extends to the wine list, which offers an impressive selection to complement your meal. From private dining rooms to an inviting bar area, Sullivan’s caters to various dining preferences, ensuring a memorable visit for all.

In summary, Sullivan’s Steakhouse in Indianapolis delivers an outstanding dining experience with its attentive staff, inviting atmosphere, and mouthwatering menu. From the moment you step through the door, you’ll be greeted with warm hospitality and exceptional service. The menu offers a variety of options to suit different preferences, ensuring a memorable dining experience for everyone. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for an exquisite meal, Sullivan’s Steakhouse is the perfect destination.

Harry And Izzy’s

Address: 153 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225
Phone: +1 (317) 635-9594
Website: harryandizzys.com
Details: $$$, American restaurant

Harry & Izzy’s is a renowned steakhouse in Indianapolis that offers a memorable dining experience with its impeccable staff, inviting atmosphere, and delectable menu. Upon arrival, our reservations were promptly honored, ensuring a seamless start to our evening. The dining room exudes a classic steakhouse ambiance with its dark paneling, creating an elegant and timeless setting. The service provided by the staff was exceptional – professional yet friendly, and our server went above and beyond to engage in conversation despite being busy.

The menu at Harry & Izzy’s offers a range of enticing options, and we began our meal with their famous St. Elmo shrimp cocktail. The shrimp was succulent, perfectly complemented by the robust horseradish sauce. The main courses included steaks, fish, and pasta dishes, but the standout was the “New York strip steak Izzy style” with its remarkable orange and brandy sauce. The flavors were exceptional, making it one of the most memorable steak sauces we’ve ever tasted.

Harry & Izzy’s provides an outstanding dining experience that leaves a lasting impression. The restaurant has a reputation for serving melt-in-your-mouth steaks, and the quality of their food certainly lives up to the hype. The attentive and friendly service further enhances the dining experience. The attention to detail, from the presentation of the dishes to the knowledge of the staff, creates a truly superior dining atmosphere.

In summary, Harry & Izzy’s is a must-visit steakhouse in Indianapolis that offers an exceptional dining experience. From the moment you step inside, you’ll be welcomed by attentive staff and immersed in a classic steakhouse ambiance. The menu boasts a variety of delicious options, with standout dishes such as the St. Elmo shrimp cocktail and the “New York strip steak Izzy style.” Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply seeking an exquisite meal, Harry & Izzy’s provides the perfect setting for a memorable dining experience.

Geraldine’s Supper Club & Lounge

Address: 1101 English Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Phone: +1 (317) 600-3336
Website: geraldinesindy.com
Details: Steak house

Geraldine’s Supper Club & Lounge is a hidden gem in Indianapolis that offers an exceptional dining experience with its attentive staff, nostalgic atmosphere, and delectable menu. From the moment you enter, you are warmly greeted by the friendly concierge, setting the tone for the evening. The well-crafted cocktails served at the bar are a perfect way to start the night, and the attentive bartender ensures a seamless transition to your table. The menu offers an extensive selection, and highlights include the fresh and flavorful Oysters and the mouthwatering Steak Tartare. The Osso Bucco and Chateaubriand are standout entrees, cooked to perfection and bursting with flavor. The jazz music adds a delightful touch to the relaxed ambiance, completing the overall experience.

Geraldine’s Supper Club is the ideal venue for a special occasion, as demonstrated by the exceptional service provided for a couple celebrating their 25th wedding anniversary. From the moment they entered, they were transported back in time and greeted with genuine warmth. The service, led by their knowledgeable and attentive server, Molly, was exemplary. The manager also contributed to the memorable experience by sharing interesting facts and stories. The menu offered a delectable range of options, including delightful crab cakes and mouthwatering steak. The attentive and appreciative staff created an atmosphere of true hospitality, making it a remarkable evening.

For those seeking an unforgettable dining experience, Geraldine’s Supper Club & Lounge is a must-visit. The atmosphere exudes old-school coolness, and the menu delivers on its promise of exceptional food. The Bone Marrow appetizer is a standout, and the steaks are cooked to perfection. Sides such as Au Gratin potatoes perfectly complement the main dishes. The attentive service ensures that every need is met, and the impressive cocktail and wine selection adds to the overall enjoyment. Geraldine’s Supper Club is a destination worthy of a visit, offering an exquisite steak dinner experience in the heart of Indianapolis.

In summary, Geraldine’s Supper Club & Lounge provides a nostalgic and enchanting dining experience in Indianapolis. The warm and welcoming staff, reminiscent atmosphere, and delectable menu make it a standout choice. Whether you’re celebrating a milestone or simply seeking an exceptional meal, Geraldine’s delivers on all fronts. From the well-crafted cocktails to the perfectly cooked steaks, every aspect of the dining experience is thoughtfully curated. Don’t miss the opportunity to indulge in the delightful atmosphere, excellent service, and unforgettable flavors offered at Geraldine’s Supper Club & Lounge.

The Library Restaurant And Pub

Address: 2610 S Lynhurst Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46241
Phone: +1 (317) 243-0299
Website: thelibrary-indy.com
Details: $$, Steak house

The Library Restaurant And Pub is a hidden gem in Indianapolis that offers an exceptional dining experience with its attentive staff, inviting atmosphere, and mouthwatering menu. Whether you’re a solo business traveler or visiting with a large group, the service at The Library is top-notch. The servers are friendly, professional, and knowledgeable, ensuring that every aspect of your dining experience is taken care of. The menu boasts a variety of delicious options, from perfectly cooked steaks to flavorful seafood dishes. The calamari steaks and the Chicken Masala are standout choices, showcasing the culinary expertise of the kitchen. The warm and welcoming atmosphere, complete with seasonal decorations and live music, adds to the overall charm of the restaurant.

Visiting The Library Restaurant And Pub is a journey back in time, where quality food and exceptional service come together. The attention to detail and care provided by the staff is remarkable, making each guest feel special. The steaks are cooked to perfection, with tender and moist cuts that melt in your mouth. The menu offers a wide range of options, ensuring that every diner finds something to enjoy. Whether you’re craving a juicy steak, fresh seafood, or delectable pasta, The Library has it all. The friendly and accommodating staff, along with the inviting ambiance, create a memorable dining experience for everyone.

Conveniently located near hotels and other attractions, The Library Restaurant And Pub is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The combination of excellent food, friendly service, and reasonable prices make it a go-to destination for both business lunches and relaxed dinners. The variety of craft beers on tap adds to the appeal, and the attentive bartenders are happy to recommend the perfect drink to complement your meal. Whether you’re looking for a cozy spot to watch a game or a place to enjoy a romantic dinner, The Library Restaurant And Pub is the perfect choice. The exceptional service, delectable food, and welcoming atmosphere make it a dining experience you won’t forget.

The Fountain Room

Address: 830 Massachusetts Ave Suite 1480, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (463) 238-3800
Website: thefountainroom.com
Details: $$$, Restaurant

The Fountain Room in Indianapolis offers a truly wonderful dining experience with its fantastic décor, attentive staff, and delectable menu. The attention to detail in the period-inspired décor creates an immersive atmosphere that adds to the overall charm of the restaurant. Whether you choose to sit in the bar area or the main dining room, you’ll be surrounded by elements that accentuate the period experience. From the classic movies playing on the TV to the overall ambiance, every detail is thoughtfully crafted.

The staff at The Fountain Room is exceptional, providing outstanding service and making each guest feel welcome and valued. From menu recommendations to personalized attention, the servers go above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. Their personable and attentive nature adds to the overall enjoyment of the meal. The food at The Fountain Room is nothing short of excellent, with every step of the meal being thoroughly enjoyed by guests. The entrees are of high quality and generous serving sizes, leaving guests satisfied and eager to return for more.

While the cocktail selection at The Fountain Room leans towards whiskey-based options, the overall quality of the cocktails is great. However, the restaurant welcomes feedback and is committed to continuously improving. They have taken note of the desire for more non-whiskey related cocktails and have plans to expand the selection in the near future. The prime location of The Fountain Room adds to its appeal, making it a go-to destination for both locals and visitors. The combination of the exceptional food, attentive service, and charming atmosphere makes The Fountain Room a must-visit steakhouse in Indianapolis.

In conclusion, Indianapolis boasts a diverse and vibrant steakhouse scene that caters to every taste and preference. From classic establishments with rich histories to modern and innovative culinary experiences, the city offers a range of options for steak lovers. Whether you’re seeking a traditional steakhouse ambiance or a contemporary twist on steak, Indianapolis has something to offer. With top-notch service, expertly prepared cuts of meat, and inviting atmospheres, the best steakhouses in Indianapolis consistently deliver memorable dining experiences. So, whether you’re a local resident or a visitor to the city, be sure to indulge in the exceptional steakhouses that Indianapolis has to offer.