Welcome to our mouthwatering exploration of the Best Pizza Restaurants in Indianapolis! If you’re a pizza lover searching for the ultimate culinary experience in the vibrant capital of Indiana, you’ve come to the right place. In this blog article, we’ll take you on a delightful journey through the city’s pizza scene, highlighting the establishments that consistently deliver exceptional flavors, quality ingredients, and unforgettable dining experiences. Whether you crave classic Neapolitan pies or innovative creations, get ready to discover the top pizzerias that will satisfy your cravings and leave you wanting more!

Earn up to 5% cashback on Restaurants!
Explore Best Credit Cards for Restaurants

Bazbeaux Pizza

Address: 333 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 636-7662
Website: bazbeaux.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Bazbeaux Pizza in Indianapolis is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts seeking a delightful dining experience. As you step inside, you’ll be greeted by a cozy atmosphere filled with good music and a cool vibe. The restaurant offers ample seating in its spacious interior, ensuring a comfortable dining experience for everyone.

The menu at Bazbeaux Pizza boasts an array of mouthwatering options that cater to diverse tastes. From the moment you take a bite of the cheese garlic bread, you’ll be captivated by its deliciousness. The pizzas are a true highlight, with thin and perfectly crispy crusts that are not burnt. Topped with generous amounts of cheese, fresh sauce, and a variety of delectable toppings, they offer a symphony of flavors that will leave you craving more. Whether you’re dining with family and friends or going on a date, Bazbeaux Pizza provides the perfect ambiance for any occasion.

The friendly staff at Bazbeaux Pizza adds to the overall positive experience. They are attentive and accommodating, ensuring that your visit is enjoyable from start to finish. The restaurant also caters to dietary preferences, offering gluten-free and vegetarian options. Whether you opt for carry-out or dine-in, the hot and delicious pizzas will undoubtedly satisfy your cravings. Don’t miss out on this gem of a pizza place when you’re in Indianapolis.

Brozinni Pizzeria

Address: 8810 S Emerson Ave # 240, Indianapolis, IN 46237
Phone: +1 (317) 865-0911
Website: brozinni.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Brozinni Pizzeria in Indianapolis is a hidden gem that captures the essence of New York-style pizza while offering a delightful dining experience. Located conveniently near the airport, it attracts visitors and locals alike with its mouthwatering menu and warm atmosphere.

The staff at Brozinni Pizzeria are friendly and extremely helpful, providing attentive service that enhances your dining experience. The establishment itself is well-maintained and situated in a great location, offering plenty of nearby activities and attractions.

Get $25 off a bill of $50

Join inKind, dine at a participating venue
and pay your bill with inKind

Get $25 off

When it comes to the food, Brozinni Pizzeria exceeds expectations. Their pizzas are simply amazing, with a delicious crust that serves as a solid foundation for a burst of flavors. From classic options to unique creations, the pizza here is a standout, and the garlic knots are an absolute must-try.

Whether you dine in or opt for carry-out, Brozinni Pizzeria delivers hot and delicious food promptly. The generous portions and fresh ingredients ensure a satisfying meal that will leave you craving more. If you’re in Indianapolis, this pizzeria is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts seeking an authentic and unforgettable experience.

Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza

Address: 5646 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219
Phone: +1 (317) 356-6612
Website: jockamopizza.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza in Indianapolis is a pizza haven that offers a memorable dining experience. The staff at this establishment are friendly and provide excellent service, ensuring that your visit is enjoyable from start to finish. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, creating a comfortable setting to indulge in their delicious pizzas.

When it comes to the menu, Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza offers a wide selection that caters to all taste preferences. From traditional favorites to unique creations, their pizzas are a delightful blend of flavors. The Slaughterhouse pizza is a standout, but you’ll find plenty of other options to satisfy your cravings. The crust is perfectly crafted and full of flavor, complementing the generous toppings.

One of the highlights of Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza is their commitment to quality. Their pizzas are prepared with attention to detail, resulting in a mouthwatering experience. Whether you choose the classic Cheese Louise or the Thai pizza, you can expect a burst of flavors that will leave you craving more. The menu also offers a variety of appetizers and drinks to complement your meal.

If you’re in Indianapolis and looking for a pizza place that offers a unique twist on traditional favorites, Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza is a must-visit. With their friendly staff, inviting atmosphere, and delicious menu options, it’s no wonder why locals and visitors alike keep coming back for more.

Giorgio’s Pizza

Address: 9 E Market St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 687-9869
Website: giorgiospizzatogo.com
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

Giorgio’s Pizza in Indianapolis is a beloved establishment that has been serving up the best New York-style pizza for over three decades. The staff is friendly and provides excellent service, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The menu offers a variety of options, including delicious pizza, simple American Italian dishes, and enticing lunch specials. Don’t miss their mouthwatering pepperoni stuffed breadsticks.

Whether you’re looking for a quick lunch or a pizza to enjoy at home, Giorgio’s Pizza is the perfect choice. Their downtown location makes it a convenient spot for a quick bite during the day or grabbing a pie for dinner. The quality and taste of the pizza are unmatched, making it a must-try for pizza lovers.

Not only is Giorgio’s known for their exceptional pizza, but they also offer a range of other delectable options. From pasta dishes to frozen pizzas, the flavors are reminiscent of the authentic Italian cuisine found in Chicago. The passion for food and Italy is evident in the atmosphere and interactions with the staff, creating an enjoyable and memorable dining experience.

If you’re searching for a taste of the east coast in Indiana, Giorgio’s Pizza is a hidden gem. The generous portions, friendly staff, and flavorful menu items make it a go-to destination for pizza enthusiasts and those craving a delicious Italian meal.

Ale Emporium

Address: 8617 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46250
Phone: +1 (317) 842-1333
Website: aleemporium.securetree.com
Details: $$, Bar & grill

Ale Emporium in Indianapolis is a beloved local spot that offers an exceptional dining experience. The staff at this establishment is attentive and friendly, ensuring that customers feel welcome and satisfied. The atmosphere is lively and upbeat, with plenty of TVs to catch your favorite sports games while enjoying the delicious food.

The menu at Ale Emporium is diverse and filled with mouthwatering options. Their wings are legendary, with the Hermanaki being a standout choice. The pizza is equally impressive, with a thin crust that satisfies your cravings. The food is consistently delicious, and they even offer a Tuesday evening steak filet special that is worth trying.

This restaurant is known for its great selection of food and a vast array of TVs, making it an ideal spot for large parties and sports enthusiasts. The bone-in and boneless wings are both excellent choices, and the stuffed breadsticks are a favorite among customers. While parking can be a bit challenging, especially on busy nights, the overall experience at Ale Emporium is worth it.

Whether you’re craving wings, pizza, or a flavorful steak, Ale Emporium is a must-visit in Indianapolis. The quality of the food, friendly service, and lively atmosphere make it the perfect destination for a memorable dining experience.

Pearl Street Pizza

Address: 65 E Pearl St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 638-3110
Website: pearlstreetpizzeria.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Pearl Street Pizza in Indianapolis is a hidden gem that offers a fantastic dining experience. The staff at this establishment is friendly and attentive, ensuring that customers feel welcomed and taken care of. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, resembling a dive bar with a touch of charm. The pizza and appetizers are simply amazing and definitely worth trying.

Whether you’re looking for a pre-game meal or a place to unwind after a business meeting, Pearl Street Pizza has you covered. The pizza is consistently top-notch, and the Mexican pizza comes highly recommended. The menu offers a variety of options, including wraps and sandwiches, that are sure to satisfy all taste preferences. The staff is prompt in serving food and drinks, ensuring that guests have a delightful dining experience.

Located near Bankers Life Fieldhouse, Pearl Street Pizza is a convenient spot for sports fans and visitors alike. The cozy atmosphere and friendly bartenders create a welcoming ambiance. The extensive beer selection adds to the overall experience, making it an ideal place to relax and enjoy a delicious meal. Don’t let its tucked-away location discourage you; Pearl Street Pizza is a true gem that offers great food, warm service, and a memorable dining experience.

Puccini’s Pizza Pasta

Address: 1508 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260
Phone: +1 (317) 875-9223
Website: puccinispizzapasta.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Puccini’s Pizza Pasta in Indianapolis is a hidden gem that offers a delightful dining experience. The staff is attentive and responsive, ensuring that any issues are promptly resolved. The menu features an array of mouthwatering options, from their amazing pizza and calzones to their delectable baked Italian dishes. The quality of the food is consistently high, with fresh ingredients and flavors that are sure to satisfy.

The atmosphere at Puccini’s is welcoming and inviting. It is a popular neighborhood spot, evident from the bustling tables and long lines of patrons waiting to carry out pizzas. The artwork adorning the walls adds a unique touch to the ambiance, creating a visually appealing backdrop for a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, Puccini’s is a hidden gem that should not be missed.

One of the standout features of Puccini’s is their commitment to catering to different dietary needs. They offer a range of options for vegans, vegetarians, and those with gluten or dairy allergies. The extensive menu ensures that there is something for everyone to enjoy. From vegan and gluten-free choices to unique pizza combinations, Puccini’s strives to accommodate various preferences and dietary restrictions.

Arni’s River Ridge

Address: 4705 E 96th St, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Phone: +1 (317) 571-0077
Website: meetyouatarnis.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Arni’s River Ridge in Indianapolis offers a delightful dining experience with its friendly staff and inviting atmosphere. The service is exceptional, with attentive and responsive servers who go above and beyond to ensure a great experience. The menu boasts a wide variety of options, including their legendary pizza and delicious salads. The Junior Salad is a standout, receiving rave reviews for its amazing flavors. Whether you’re craving pizza or a refreshing salad, Arni’s has something for everyone.

The quality of the food at Arni’s is consistently excellent. The pizza, especially the thin crust variety, is considered one of the best in the area. The attention to detail in preparing the pizzas, such as grinding up the pepperoni and sausage to fully cover the pie, sets Arni’s apart. The menu also features other delectable options, including appetizers like boneless wings and specialty drinks like the peach Long Island iced tea. The extensive menu ensures that there’s a dish to satisfy every palate.

The atmosphere at Arni’s is warm and welcoming, making it a favorite spot for casual dining. The bar area is separate from the main dining area, providing a cozy and relaxed setting. The restaurant is family-friendly, perfect for enjoying a meal with loved ones. With reasonable prices, an extensive menu, and a friendly staff, Arni’s River Ridge is a go-to spot for a great dining experience.

New Bethel Ordinary

Address: 8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker, IN 46239
Phone: +1 (317) 862-5020
Website: nbopizza.net
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

New Bethel Ordinary in Indianapolis offers a fantastic dining experience with its friendly staff and comfortable atmosphere. The crew at the restaurant is polite and friendly, providing excellent service that enhances the overall dining experience. The parking area in both the front and back is ample, ensuring convenience for guests. The restaurant has a pleasant and inviting ambiance, perfect for enjoying a meal with family and friends.

The star of the menu at New Bethel Ordinary is undoubtedly the pizza. The large pizzas are loaded with toppings, such as pepperoni, Italian sausage, and Canadian bacon, making them a flavorful and satisfying choice. The pizzas are known for their generous portions and delicious taste. While the pizza is a standout, the menu also offers a variety of other options, including sandwiches and specials, all of which are equally tasty and satisfying. Whether dining in or opting for carryout, guests can expect delicious comfort food and cold beverages.

New Bethel Ordinary is a hidden treasure in Indianapolis, located on the southeast side of the city. The tavern offers a cozy and friendly environment for dining in or carrying out. Along with their mouthwatering pizza, the restaurant also serves steaks, burgers, fries, and more, accompanied by a great selection of cold beers and refreshing drinks. The service is quick, and the staff is friendly, ensuring a pleasant dining experience for all guests. Whether you’re a pizza lover or looking for comfort food, New Bethel Ordinary is a must-visit destination.

Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mass Ave

Address: 545 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 602-3401
Website: goodfellaspizzeria.com
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mass Ave in Indianapolis offers an impressive dining experience with its delicious pizza, friendly staff, and inviting atmosphere. Whether you’re looking for a quick lunch or a late-night bite, this pizzeria has you covered. The pizza slices are big and satisfying, with options like New York style pizza that will leave you wanting more. The restaurant also offers an assortment of mouthwatering toppings, including pepperoni, sausage, and bacon, all served on a thin and flavorful crust.

The staff at Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mass Ave is incredibly friendly and attentive, ensuring that you have a pleasant dining experience. The atmosphere is lively and upbeat, with good music playing in the background. The restaurant offers both indoor and outdoor seating, allowing you to enjoy your meal in a comfortable setting. The breadsticks at Goodfellas are also a must-try, known for their massive size and delicious taste.

In addition to the fantastic pizza, Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mass Ave is home to a hidden gem called Wiseguy Lounge. This speakeasy-style bar offers a wide selection of cocktails, local craft beers, and an extensive bourbon collection. The bartenders are knowledgeable and friendly, creating a welcoming atmosphere for guests. You can even bring your pizza from the pizzeria into the lounge, making it the perfect combination for a great night out.

Whether you’re craving a slice of pizza, a giant breadstick, or a refreshing cocktail, Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mass Ave is the place to go. The combination of delicious food, friendly staff, and inviting atmosphere makes it a favorite destination for locals and visitors alike.

Vito Provolone’s Restaurant

Address: 8031 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46217
Phone: +1 (317) 888-1112
Website: vitoprovolone.com
Details: $$, Italian restaurant

Vito Provolone’s Restaurant in Indianapolis is a popular and bustling Italian restaurant known for its exceptional food, attentive service, and welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant’s consistent busyness speaks volumes about the quality of their service and delicious food. The prices are reasonable and well worth it for the overall dining experience. One highlight is the lasagna, prepared in the “Vito” way with fennel, which is highly recommended. Another favorite is the “lemone” chicken pasta, bursting with flavor.

During the COVID-19 pandemic, customers have enjoyed the convenience of ordering Vito’s SMOG pizza for curbside pickup, praising the mouthwatering taste and the restaurant’s signature sauce. The staff members who handle phone orders and greet customers are described as a delightful treat, always polite and appreciative, offering a pleasant interaction in today’s fast-paced world.

The menu at Vito Provolone’s offers an array of delectable options. Their pizza is especially fantastic, with the ability to customize toppings without any additional charge. Fresh ingredients, including tomatoes, add to the delightful flavor. The restaurant also serves a variety of Italian dishes, including pasta with vodka sauce and chicken fettuccine. The warm bread and flavorful salads are a perfect complement to the main course. The restaurant’s cleanliness and excellent service further enhance the dining experience.

Vito Provolone’s may appear unassuming from the outside, but the food and service are nothing short of excellent. The interior decor may benefit from updates, particularly the ceiling tiles and restroom facilities. However, the friendly and attentive staff members, such as server Mindy, consistently provide outstanding service. The restaurant is highly recommended for those seeking authentic Italian cuisine, including their mouthwatering filet, pizzas, and seafood fettuccine. Don’t miss the opportunity to indulge in their delectable garlic bread and memorable dining experience at Vito Provolone’s Restaurant.

In conclusion, Indianapolis boasts a vibrant pizza scene with a variety of outstanding restaurants to choose from. Whether you’re craving a classic New York-style slice, a gourmet specialty pizza, or a traditional Italian pie, the city has it all. From the mouthwatering pizzas at Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mass Ave to the legendary flavors of Arni’s River Ridge, these establishments have captured the hearts and taste buds of locals and visitors alike. Vito Provolone’s Restaurant, with its exceptional food and welcoming atmosphere, also deserves a spot on the list of the best pizza restaurants in Indianapolis. So, next time you’re in the city, be sure to explore these pizza hotspots and satisfy your cravings with a slice of heaven.