Welcome to the ultimate guide to the Best Seafood restaurants in Indianapolis! If you’re a seafood lover in the heartland of America, you’re in for a treat. Indianapolis boasts a vibrant culinary scene, and its seafood offerings are no exception. Whether you’re craving succulent shrimp, fresh oysters, or perfectly grilled fish, this city has it all. Join us as we dive into the top seafood spots that promise an unforgettable dining experience, tantalizing your taste buds with the ocean’s finest delights.
Tony’s Of Indianapolis
Address: 110 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 638-8669
Website: tonysofindianapolis.com
Details: $$$$, Steak house
Tony’s of Indianapolis is a culinary gem that offers an extraordinary dining experience in the heart of Indianapolis. Located just two blocks off the Circle, this restaurant is conveniently situated within walking distance of popular attractions. The restaurant boasts a vibrant atmosphere, creating the perfect setting for a memorable evening. The attentive and knowledgeable staff, consisting mostly of men, go above and beyond to ensure exceptional service throughout your visit.
While Tony’s is renowned for its perfectly cooked steaks, the seafood options are equally impressive. Indulge in mouthwatering dishes such as the Chilean sea bass or the seafood platter featuring colossal crab legs, shrimp, and two styles of oysters. The crab cakes are a must-try and are often praised as some of the best in town. For sides, the Mac n cheese and Brussels sprouts are delectable choices that complement the main courses perfectly.
Guests consistently rave about the quality of service at Tony’s. The attentive staff, including the friendly managers who make regular appearances at tables, ensure that every aspect of your dining experience exceeds expectations. This commitment to excellence sets Tony’s apart from other establishments in the city. Whether you’re visiting for business or pleasure, make a reservation in advance and prepare to be delighted by the culinary delights at Tony’s of Indianapolis.
Caplinger’s Fresh Catch
Address: 7460 Shadeland Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46250
Phone: +1 (317) 288-7263
Website: caplingersfreshcatch.com
Details: $$, Seafood market
Caplinger’s Fresh Catch in Indianapolis is a hidden gem that seafood enthusiasts won’t want to miss. Located on North Shadeland Avenue, this family-run fish market and restaurant offers a wide selection of fresh fish and seafood options. Whether you prefer smoked, grilled, fried, or blackened dishes, Caplinger’s has it all. The facility serves as a combination deli and restaurant, providing a cozy and friendly atmosphere for guests.
The menu at Caplinger’s Fresh Catch is filled with delectable choices. From the mouthwatering fried cod, which is considered one of the best in central Indiana, to the flavorful clam chowder and fresh greens, every dish is crafted to perfection. Seafood lovers will be delighted by the extensive variety, including house-smoked salmon, lobster rolls, and fried fish sandwiches. The generous portions and excellent seasoning ensure a truly satisfying meal.
Join inKind, dine at a participating venue
and pay your bill with inKind
Customers consistently praise the attentive and helpful staff at Caplinger’s. The employees are friendly, knowledgeable, and go above and beyond to make diners feel welcome. The cozy seating area is limited, so many guests opt for takeout or delivery. Whether you’re craving a seafood feast or looking to explore the extensive seafood market, Caplinger’s Fresh Catch is the place to be. Don’t forget to save room for their heavenly Key Lime Pie, a perfect ending to a delightful dining experience.
The Oceanaire Seafood Room
Address: 30 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 955-2277
Website: theoceanaire.com/location/indianapolis-in
Details: $$$, Fine dining restaurant
The Oceanaire Seafood Room in downtown Indianapolis is a culinary gem that offers excellent service and an unforgettable dining experience. Known for its fresh seafood flown in daily, this restaurant showcases a diverse menu that caters to seafood lovers. The atmosphere is elegant and inviting, providing the perfect setting for a special evening.
The attentive and knowledgeable staff at The Oceanaire Seafood Room truly enhance the dining experience. From friendly servers to helpful recommendations, they ensure that every guest feels well taken care of. The menu features a variety of delectable dishes, from the savory Oysters Rockefeller to the perfectly prepared Halibut “Ritzy.” The seafood is exceptionally fresh and full of flavor, making each bite a delight for the taste buds.
The restaurant also pays attention to the finer details, with an extensive wine list and a presentation that includes the flamed Baked Alaska served tableside. The selection of sides, such as the creamed corn and lobster Mac and Cheese, complement the seafood perfectly. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply indulging in the best seafood in town, The Oceanaire Seafood Room is a top choice that guarantees a memorable dining experience.
Salt On Mass
Address: 505 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 638-6565
Website: saltonmass.com
Details: $$$, Seafood restaurant
Salt On Mass is a seafood restaurant in downtown Indianapolis that offers a delightful dining experience. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and provides excellent service. From the moment you step in, you’ll feel welcomed and well taken care of. The menu features an impressive selection of seafood dishes, steaks, and cocktails, ensuring there’s something for everyone to enjoy.
The seafood at Salt On Mass is exceptional, with fresh catches flown in daily. Whether you opt for the blackened grouper, sea bass, or salmon, each dish is prepared with care and bursting with flavor. The seafood is paired with delectable sides like Parmesan risotto and shrimp and grits, creating a perfect harmony of flavors. The restaurant’s nautical vibe, with its blues and pale woods, adds to the charming atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for a special night out.
Guests appreciate the attentive and friendly service at Salt On Mass. The waitstaff is attentive without being intrusive, allowing you to savor each course and enjoy a leisurely dining experience. The restaurant’s location on Mass Ave provides a vibrant setting, and the contemporary design adds to the overall appeal. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply seeking a memorable meal, Salt On Mass is a top choice for seafood lovers looking for superb dining in Indianapolis.
Ocean Prime
Address: 8555 River Rd #100, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Phone: +1 (317) 569-0975
Website: ocean-prime.com/locations-menus/indianapolis
Details: $$$$, Seafood restaurant
Ocean Prime, located in Indianapolis, is a restaurant that offers an exceptional dining experience. The staff is attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable, ensuring that every guest feels well taken care of. The atmosphere is elegant and inviting, with plush carpeting, white tablecloths, and beautiful decor. Whether you choose to sit inside or on the patio, you’ll enjoy a comfortable and enjoyable dining environment.
The menu at Ocean Prime is a culinary masterpiece, featuring an array of seafood dishes and perfectly grilled steaks. The seafood is fresh and prepared to perfection, while the steaks are grilled to perfection. From the tempura shrimp sushi and French onion soup to the sea scallops with parmesan risotto and twin lobster tails, every dish is delicious and beautifully presented. The restaurant also offers a great selection of cocktails and a wine list that complements the menu perfectly.
The attention to detail and impeccable service at Ocean Prime sets it apart. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure that guests have an unforgettable dining experience. They are attentive, knowledgeable, and provide personalized service. The restaurant’s commitment to quality extends to every aspect, from the food to the ambiance. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for a memorable meal, Ocean Prime is the perfect choice for seafood lovers and those seeking a top-notch dining experience in Indianapolis.
Rick’s Café Boatyard
Address: 4050 Dandy Trail, Indianapolis, IN 46254
Phone: +1 (317) 290-9300
Website: ricksboatyard.com
Details: $$, Seafood restaurant
Rick’s Café Boatyard is a seafood restaurant in Indianapolis that offers a fantastic dining experience. The location is beautiful, with a view of the marina and water that adds to the ambiance. The staff is attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable, ensuring that guests have a pleasant and memorable time. Whether you choose to sit indoors or on the outdoor patio, you’ll enjoy the relaxed and comfortable atmosphere.
The menu at Rick’s Café Boatyard features a variety of seafood dishes that are prepared expertly and taste delicious. From jumbo shrimp martini and crab stuffed mushrooms to seafood chowder and seared sea scallops with bacon vinaigrette, every dish is flavorful and well-presented. The restaurant also offers a range of options, including sandwiches, pizzas, and prime cuts of meat, catering to different preferences. The cocktails and drink menu are extensive, and the restaurant even offers mocktails for those who prefer non-alcoholic beverages.
The service at Rick’s Café Boatyard is excellent, with attentive and friendly waitstaff who strive to make every visit special. They are knowledgeable about the menu and offer helpful recommendations to ensure guests have a satisfying dining experience. The restaurant’s attention to detail, from the bread and butter to the dessert menu, adds to the overall enjoyment. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or looking for a casual meal with great seafood, Rick’s Café Boatyard is a top choice in Indianapolis.
Mccormick & Schmick’s Seafood & Steaks
Address: 110 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 631-9500
Website: mccormickandschmicks.com/location/mccormick-schmicks-indianapolis-in
Details: $$$, Restaurant
McCormick & Schmick’s Seafood & Steaks is a top seafood restaurant in Indianapolis known for its great seafood offerings and exceptional service. The menu features a variety of dishes that are prepared using fresh ingredients, ensuring a high-quality dining experience. From the shrimp and crab to the seared ahi tuna and charred octopus appetizer, every dish is deliciously crafted and satisfying.
The atmosphere at McCormick & Schmick’s is welcoming and perfect for various occasions, whether it’s a romantic date night or a special celebration. The attentive staff provides excellent service, making guests feel well taken care of throughout their meal. The restaurant offers a range of options, including steak and seafood, ensuring that there’s something for everyone to enjoy.
With reasonable prices, delicious food, and an inviting ambiance, McCormick & Schmick’s is a go-to destination for seafood lovers. Whether you’re in the mood for a perfectly cooked filet, a seafood platter, or one of their delectable desserts, this restaurant guarantees a memorable dining experience. Visit McCormick & Schmick’s Seafood & Steaks for a delightful meal and exceptional service in the heart of Indianapolis.
Bonefish Grill
Address: 4501 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46250
Phone: +1 (317) 863-3474
Website: locations.bonefishgrill.com/indiana/indianapolis/4501-e.-82nd-street
Details: $$, Seafood restaurant
Bonefish Grill is a seafood restaurant in Indianapolis that offers a memorable dining experience with its excellent staff, inviting atmosphere, and diverse menu. The seafood is cooked to perfection, with standout dishes like the scallops and crab cakes leaving a lasting impression. The restaurant’s updated decor and menu provide a fresh and appealing ambiance for guests.
The service at Bonefish Grill is exceptional, with friendly and knowledgeable staff who go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience. The menu offers a wide variety of options, from the famous Bang Bang Shrimp appetizer to the flavorful tilapia imperial and deliciously prepared red snapper. The restaurant also impresses with its handcrafted cocktails and delightful desserts like the creamy and rich creme brulee.
Although the parking situation may be a downside, the overall quality of the food and service at Bonefish Grill more than compensates for it. The restaurant maintains its reputation for serving fresh seafood, delectable appetizers, and flavorful entrees. With its upscale yet relaxed atmosphere, Bonefish Grill is a top choice for seafood lovers and those looking for a memorable dining experience in Indianapolis.
Slapfish
Address: 345 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 686-9713
Website: slapfishindiana.com
Details: $$, Seafood restaurant
Slapfish is a delightful seafood restaurant in Indianapolis that offers a fantastic dining experience. The staff members are attentive and create a hospitable atmosphere, making guests feel welcome from the moment they arrive. The menu at Slapfish is focused on seafood and offers generous portions of delicious food. Whether you choose the grilled fish sandwich with coleslaw, the poke bowl, or the fried cod, each dish is exceptionally prepared with flavorful sauces. The prices are reasonable, providing a great value for the quality and quantity of food.
The restaurant features a modern industrial feel that is both comfortable and inviting. The service is excellent, and the staff members ensure that every aspect of the dining experience is enjoyable. From the tasty lobster dip served with homemade potato chips to the shrimp burrito paired with fresh homemade fries, the menu offers a variety of enticing options. Don’t miss the lobster rolls, a true highlight of the menu. Despite the fast casual counter ordering system, the food arrives promptly, and the flavors and presentation are outstanding.
Whether you’re a seafood lover or simply looking for a satisfying meal, Slapfish is the perfect destination. The fresh and affordable menu, along with the friendly service, creates a memorable experience. From the lobster grinder and clobster grilled cheese to the flavorful chowder and lobster tots, every dish is crafted with care. Slapfish is a seafood gem that brings a taste of coastal delights to Indianapolis, and it’s a place worth visiting again and again.
Pier 48 Fish House & Oyster Bar
Address: 130 S Pennsylvania St Suite B, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: +1 (317) 560-4848
Website: pier48fresh.com
Details: $$, Seafood restaurant
Located on the first floor of the Hyatt Place Indianapolis Downtown, Pier 48 Fish House & Oyster Bar is a convenient and delightful seafood restaurant in Indianapolis, Indiana. Open from breakfast to dinner, it offers a wide range of delectable dishes to satisfy any seafood lover. The restaurant boasts a casual and inviting atmosphere, with outdoor seating and multiple TVs for a fun dining experience. Whether you’re craving a classic lobster roll, fish and chips, or their famous fried chicken sandwich, Pier 48 delivers fresh and delicious flavors in every bite.
The staff at Pier 48 are knowledgeable and attentive, providing exceptional service to enhance your dining experience. They take pride in offering the freshest seafood, with daily deliveries ensuring the highest quality ingredients. From the savory clam chowder to the indulgent Whoopi pie desserts, every dish is crafted with care and delivers outstanding flavors. The restaurant is perfect for various occasions, whether it’s a business lunch, a family gathering, or a casual night out with friends.
Pier 48 Fish House & Oyster Bar has garnered praise for its excellent food and service. Guests appreciate the expertise of the servers, who provide recommendations and help pair sauces with different fish options. The Lobstah Rolls, Fish & Chips, and Fried Chicken Sandwich are among the crowd favorites, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to delivering delicious and satisfying meals. With its welcoming atmosphere, fresh seafood, and friendly staff, Pier 48 is a go-to destination for a memorable dining experience in Indianapolis.
Juicy Seafood Indy
Address: 2801 Lake Circle Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46268
Phone: +1 (317) 755-3962
Website: juicyseafoodindy.com
Details: $$ – $$$, Seafood
Located on W. 86th Street near St. Vincent Hospital in Indianapolis, Juicy Seafood Indy is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. The restaurant offers a delightful dining experience with its delicious seafood boil options. The atmosphere is casual and comfortable, perfect for enjoying a messy and fun meal. The staff provides excellent customer service, ensuring a pleasant and memorable visit. Whether you choose the raw oysters as an appetizer or dive straight into the mouthwatering seafood boils, every dish is served in savory juices that add to the flavor experience. The spice levels can be customized, ranging from mild to hot, satisfying a variety of taste preferences. The “Juicy Special” preparation is highly recommended.
Visiting Juicy Seafood Indy for the first time is a treat, as the friendly staff, courteous service, and inviting atmosphere make you feel right at home. The menu offers a wide selection of seafood options, including shrimp, scallops, and oysters, all served with their signature juicy flavors. The steamed oysters with Old Bay seasoning are a delectable choice, while the create-your-own boil combo allows you to customize your meal with various seafood, sausage, potatoes, and corn. The Juicy Special sauce is a must-try, adding an extra burst of flavor to your seafood feast. With medium spice providing a perfect balance of heat, those seeking a fiery experience can opt for a higher spice level. The pricing reflects the quality and value of the seafood, making it a worthwhile indulgence.
At Juicy Seafood Indy, the experience goes beyond the food. The attentive staff ensures you have everything you need, providing bibs, scissors, shell crackers, and a bucket for the ultimate seafood adventure. The manager takes the time to greet and engage with guests, adding a personal touch to the dining experience. While cracking open shellfish may not be everyone’s preference, the restaurant also offers fried items that don’t require tableside preparation. The combination of outstanding seafood, welcoming atmosphere, and exceptional service make Juicy Seafood Indy a must-visit destination for seafood enthusiasts in Indianapolis.
Blue Sushi Sake Grill
Address: 2721 E 86th St STE 100, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Phone: +1 (317) 489-3151
Website: bluesushisakegrill.com
Details: $$, Sushi restaurant
Situated in Indianapolis, Blue Sushi Sake Grill offers a delightful dining experience with its inviting atmosphere and delicious menu options. The restaurant’s vibrant ambiance is enhanced by red lanterns and captivating artwork adorning the walls, creating a visually appealing setting. The staff members are friendly, knowledgeable, and always ready to provide helpful suggestions. If you’re a sushi enthusiast, you’ll be pleased with the diverse selection of rolls, from the spicy octopus roll to the mouthwatering “Roja” roll, which features a delightful combination of tuna, yellowtail, cucumber, avocado, cilantro, and sriracha. The lunch specials are also worth trying, offering great value with options like sushi rolls paired with miso soup or salad.
Blue Sushi Sake Grill goes beyond just sushi, as they also offer cooked dishes for those who prefer them. The restaurant’s commitment to accommodating different dietary preferences is evident with their excellent vegan options. The Cowgirl and South Pacific rolls are highly recommended for those seeking vegan choices. Additionally, the restaurant’s sustainability practices make it a great choice for environmentally-conscious diners.
Customer service is exceptional at Blue Sushi Sake Grill, with attentive and friendly staff who take the time to explain the menu and make recommendations. The management team also ensures that guests have a memorable experience, engaging with customers and providing a warm welcome. Happy hour specials and separate happy hour menus offer opportunities to enjoy discounted prices on appetizers, sushi rolls, and drinks. Whether you’re visiting for a special occasion or a casual outing, Blue Sushi Sake Grill promises a wonderful evening of delicious food, excellent service, and a fun atmosphere.
When it comes to seafood in Indianapolis, there are several outstanding restaurants that cater to seafood lovers’ cravings. From the delightful flavors of Pier 48 Fish House & Oyster Bar to the mouthwatering seafood boils at Juicy Seafood Indy, these establishments offer a range of options to satisfy every palate. For those seeking a combination of sushi and sake, Blue Sushi Sake Grill provides a vibrant atmosphere and delectable rolls. No matter which restaurant you choose, you can expect attentive staff, inviting atmospheres, and menus that showcase the best of what the sea has to offer. Indianapolis truly has a seafood scene worth exploring.
