Welcome to the ultimate guide to the Best Pizza Restaurants in Louisville! If you’re a pizza lover like us, you’re in for a treat. Louisville, renowned for its culinary scene, is home to some truly exceptional pizza joints that will tantalize your taste buds. Whether you crave a classic Margherita or prefer adventurous toppings, this vibrant city has it all. Join us as we embark on a flavorful journey, exploring the top pizzerias that Louisville has to offer. Get ready to indulge in cheesy, saucy goodness at the Best Pizza Restaurants in Louisville!

Earn up to 5% cashback on Restaurants!
Explore Best Credit Cards for Restaurants

Coals Artisan Pizza

Address: 3724 Frankfort Ave, Louisville, KY 40207
Phone: +1 (502) 742-8200
Website: coalsartisanpizza.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Coals Artisan Pizza in Louisville is a delightful pizza restaurant that captures the hearts and palates of its customers. Nestled in a cozy location, it has a charming outdoor eating area that adds to its appeal. The staff here are attentive, friendly, and efficient, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The restaurant exudes cleanliness and tidiness, with spotless restrooms.

The menu at Coals Artisan Pizza is a true delight for pizza enthusiasts. Their thin crust, brick oven-style pizzas are a standout feature. The variety of toppings and flavors available will satisfy any craving, and the option to get a cauliflower crust is a pleasant surprise. Each pizza is made to order, allowing for personal preferences and substitutions. The unique combination of ingredients, such as fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, banana peppers, and more, creates mouthwatering masterpieces.

Apart from their delectable pizzas, Coals Artisan Pizza offers other appetizing options. The stuffed mushrooms are a must-try, bursting with delicious flavors. The wedge salad complements the pizzas perfectly. The restaurant also boasts an impressive selection of drinks, including a noteworthy bourbon list at reasonable prices.

With its welcoming atmosphere, exceptional service, and mouthwatering pizzas, Coals Artisan Pizza is a hidden gem in Louisville. Whether you’re exploring the area or simply craving a fantastic thin crust pizza, this restaurant is a must-visit destination.

Hometown Pizza

Address: 4041 Preston Hwy, Louisville, KY 40213
Phone: +1 (502) 363-4880
Website: HometownPizza.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Hometown Pizza in Louisville is a fantastic restaurant that offers delicious pizza and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. The staff members are attentive and provide excellent service, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The menu features a variety of mouthwatering options at reasonable prices, making it a great choice for families and individuals alike.

Get $25 off a bill of $50

Join inKind, dine at a participating venue
and pay your bill with inKind

Get $25 off

Customers rave about the quality of the pizza at Hometown Pizza. The thick crust pizza and breadsticks receive high praise, with many diners returning for more. The flavors are exceptional, and the portion sizes are generous. The restaurant also offers baked spaghetti, which is a crowd-pleaser, and the cheesy breadsticks served as appetizers are a hit with customers.

Located conveniently near hotels and attractions, Hometown Pizza is a popular choice for both locals and visitors. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or a family dinner, this restaurant has you covered. The friendly staff, delectable pizza options, and reasonable prices make it a standout destination in Louisville. Don’t forget to try their thin crust pizza for a truly delightful experience.

Wick’s Pizza Parlor (baxter Ave.)

Address: 975 Baxter Ave, Louisville, KY 40204
Phone: +1 (502) 458-1828
Website: wickspizza.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Wick’s Pizza Parlor on Baxter Avenue in Louisville is a must-visit destination for pizza lovers. The restaurant exudes a quirky and lively atmosphere, with fun artwork adorning the walls and a full bar to enhance the experience. The staff members are friendly, providing excellent service that adds to the overall enjoyment.

Customers rave about the delicious pizzas at Wick’s Pizza Parlor. The crust is crispy and tender, perfectly complementing the well-seasoned sauce and gooey cheese. Toppings like pepperoni and crumbled sausage add delightful flavors. The menu also offers a range of options beyond pizza, with fresh ingredients and ample portion sizes to satisfy any appetite.

The restaurant’s location and convenient parking make it easily accessible for both locals and visitors. Wick’s Pizza Parlor is known for its comprehensive menu, ensuring there is something for everyone. Whether you’re in the mood for a small bite like the stuffed breadwick or craving their famous Big Wick pizza, Wick’s is sure to deliver a memorable dining experience.

Don’t miss the opportunity to enjoy tasty pizzas, great service, and a fun ambiance at Wick’s Pizza Parlor on Baxter Avenue. It’s the perfect spot for a casual meal, watching games, or spending time with friends and family.

Impellizzeri’s Pizza

Address: 4933 Brownsboro Rd, Louisville, KY 40222
Phone: +1 (502) 425-9080
Website: impellizzeris.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Impellizzeri’s Pizza in Louisville is a must-visit pizza restaurant that offers a delightful dining experience. The staff members are friendly and attentive, ensuring that guests feel welcomed and well taken care of. The atmosphere is inviting and enjoyable, with fun touches like artwork on the walls and a full bar to enhance the experience.

Customers rave about the delicious pizzas at Impellizzeri’s. From the perfectly crispy and flavorful crust to the generous toppings, every bite is a delight. The menu also offers appetizers like meatballs and bruschetta, providing a perfect start to the meal. The restaurant’s commitment to quality extends to their salad options, with fresh ingredients and well-balanced dressings.

Impellizzeri’s is known for its excellent deep-dish stuffed pizza, featuring a double layer of cheese and toppings over a delicious crust and hearty sauce. Whether you’re craving classic flavors or unique combinations, Impellizzeri’s has something for everyone. The service is top-notch, and the overall dining experience is one that keeps customers coming back for more.

When in Louisville, make sure to visit Impellizzeri’s Pizza for a memorable meal. Whether you’re looking for Chicago-style pizza or simply a fantastic dining experience, this restaurant has it all. Enjoy the friendly staff, fantastic atmosphere, and mouthwatering menu options at Impellizzeri’s.

Pizza Lupo

Address: 1540 Frankfort Ave, Louisville, KY 40206
Phone: +1 (502) 409-8440
Website: pizzalupo.com
Details: $$, Pizza restaurant

Pizza Lupo in Louisville is a local gem that offers a unique and delightful dining experience. As a first-time visitor, you’ll notice the first-come seating arrangement and the convenient option to order food and drinks via an IQ code on the table or at the bar. The wait staff is friendly and accommodating, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The menu offers a variety of options, from classic Caesar salad with frisee and arugula to delicious pizzas with perfect crusts and generous toppings.

Despite the challenges posed by the pandemic, Pizza Lupo not only survived but expanded its local delivery service. The high-quality pizzas stand out among the competition, offering a superior product that surpasses other frozen and generic options. The pizzas at Pizza Lupo rival those found in major metropolitan cities and even in Italy itself, making it a favorite among locals and regular patrons.

The wood-fired oysters are a standout appetizer, bursting with flavor and beautifully presented. The recommended “Sting like a Bee” pizza, featuring hot honey and cupped pepperoni, is a magical combination of flavors. The dipping sauces offered by the restaurant are equally impressive, with the garlic butter standing out as a top-tier option. The overall experience at Pizza Lupo is impeccable, leaving patrons eagerly anticipating their next visit.

Located just blocks away from various accommodations, Pizza Lupo is a convenient and delicious option for a satisfying meal. The mouthwatering pizzas, perfect crusts, and flavorful sauces make it a standout choice. The friendly staff, welcoming atmosphere, and outstanding service contribute to a memorable dining experience. Don’t miss the opportunity to indulge in authentic Neapolitan-style pizza at Pizza Lupo, where every bite will transport you to Italy.

Fat Jimmy’s Middletown

Address: 12216 Shelbyville Rd, Louisville, KY 40243
Phone: +1 (502) 244-2500
Website: fatjimmyspizza.com
Details: $, Buffet restaurant

Fat Jimmy’s Middletown in Louisville offers the best pizza buffet experience in town. The salad bar is filled with a variety of fresh vegetables, dressings, and shredded cheese. The extensive selection of pizzas caters to everyone’s taste, from vegetarian options to meat lovers and chicken/ranch combinations. The buffet staff is attentive, constantly clearing tables and ensuring cleanliness. Families drive from afar to enjoy this fun and delicious dining experience.

Following the pandemic, Fat Jimmy’s buffet has implemented safety measures, providing each guest with their own set of tongs for a touchless experience. Outdoor seating options allow patrons to enjoy their meal at picnic tables, savoring every bite of pizza, salad, sweet balls, and butter balls. The menu offers an abundance of pizza options, and the flavorful sweet balls, coated in cinnamon sugar, are a highlight. Fat Jimmy’s in Middletown is a go-to destination for locals and visitors alike, providing a friendly atmosphere and high-quality pizza.

Whether you’re in Louisville for business or pleasure, Fat Jimmy’s is a must-visit pizza joint. While Louisville may not be known for having the best pizza, Fat Jimmy’s stands out with its delicious offerings and friendly ambiance. The buffet option allows patrons to sample a variety of dishes, including tossed salad, pasta salad, and an array of pizza options. The homemade Taco soup is a delightful surprise, and the veggie pizza garnished with fresh vegetables and cheese is outstanding. The affordable price makes Fat Jimmy’s an excellent choice for a satisfying meal, and the attentive staff ensures a pleasant dining experience.

Old School Ny Pizza

Address: 12907 Factory Ln g, Louisville, KY 40245
Phone: +1 (502) 882-1776
Website: oldschoolnypizza.com
Details: $, Pizza restaurant

Old School NY Pizza in Louisville is a hidden gem for pizza enthusiasts. With a wide variety of pizzas ready to be heated up for slices, customers can enjoy a super tasty and quick meal. The friendly service adds to the overall positive experience, making it a great stop for those on a cross-country drive or simply looking for delicious pizza. The authentic New York-style pizza transports customers to the streets of Staten Island, while the great salad options and good wine selection complement the meal perfectly.

The staff at Old School NY Pizza is known for their efficiency and graciousness, ensuring a smooth and enjoyable dining experience. The pizza itself is top-notch, comparable to the best in the Philadelphia-South Jersey area. The crust is a standout, made fresh in-house and perfectly complemented by a variety of toppings. The menu offers both traditional options and the chance to customize a counter pie with a selection of toppings. Exciting plans for expansion, including a bar section with TVs, add to the anticipation of future visits.

Old School NY Pizza captures the essence of New York-style pizza, providing a taste of home for those from the Big Apple. The cheese pie brings back memories of authentic New York pizza, while the garlic knots surpass even longstanding favorites in the city. The reasonable prices make Old School NY Pizza a great value, with generous slices and delicious sides like hot knots and garden salads. The real oven baking and friendly staff make it a must-visit for anyone seeking an authentic New York pizza experience in Louisville.

In conclusion, Louisville boasts a vibrant pizza scene with a variety of establishments offering unique and delicious pies. From the authentic New York-style slices at Old School NY Pizza to the family-friendly buffet at Fat Jimmy’s Middletown, there is something for every pizza lover in this city. The friendly staff, inviting atmosphere, and diverse menu options make these pizza restaurants stand out among the rest. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, be sure to explore the culinary delights that Louisville’s best pizza restaurants have to offer.